Eh,
that's not strictly true.
Great find though. Unfortunately, most of it doesn't conform to our DC/Marvel scaling rules. While this doesn't mean it can't be used, it does mean the only viable scans are the ones that provide context to the power levels of the characters shown in the story.
For example, Spider-man kicking Electro through 40 stories and one-shotting Tombstone after he tanked a building level feat would count as scalable (and should be calculated imo).
Stopping a blow from Juggernaut and staggering Hulk level characters wouldn't.
Also, despite the downscaling you suggest the thread has several anti-feats as well, like Spider-man being taken down by a thrown car notably smaller than an American one, after all. To say that he's consistently herald tier is very, very questionable tbh.
This is not true.
Reddit and even
Spacebattles have been used as sources of respect threads before.