• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Pokemon: Creation Trio (& Others) Tier 1 Upgrade (ACCEPTED)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
17,184
Reaction score
5,030
👋 It has been a while, everyone. I'm back with one of these. First Pokemon thread of the year, and it’ll be quite a doozie. And as you can see from the title, for once, Arceus ain’t (not mostly, anyway) the focal point of this. This is indeed an upgrade proposal, mainly, for the Creation Trio & whatnot. While Ive been MIA again, I saw some things happen here lately, and after observing some other cases of this happening, I thought this would be now as good a time as any to make a similar kind of case for Pokemon after doing some digging. To clarify, this will be in reference to the whole argument about parallel worlds being separated by that of a separate space.

I’ll get right into it. Long story short, according to our (current) standards, parallel universes that are existing side by side by one another would have an additional spatial dimension that acts as a separator for the said worlds. The said spatial dimension that would be beyond that of ordinary spacetime with at least another spatial axis. For our purposes, 4-D parallel universes that are parallel to each other, & displaced along another spatial dimension to keep them separated, would make this spatial dimension (insignificant sized) 5-D. Which can be tierable and applied as an upgrade if there’s sufficient proof of significant size for it. That’s the gist of what I gathered from this.

After doing some of my own research into how this stacks up with this information, I believe Pokemon can apply for this. Let’s get into why and see where this ends up as.

The Space Between Dimensions in Pokemon

Now taking a moment to briefly mention this in case of confusion, in Pokemon, many of us know of the scope of the verse’s cosmology. Barring Arceus’s Low 1-C realm, the cosmology currently reaches 2-A. You can refer to that & the extent of it here on Pokemon’s Cosmology blog.

What I'm going to be presenting next is technically not new information per se, but interesting material that hasn’t been accounted for here, until now. As I said above, the space between universes would normally be considered insignificant 5-D by default, & normally isn’t tierable, unless evidence of significant size is presented to say otherwise & allow it to scale. I believe Pokemon is now able to meet this standard.

In the subbed version of The Rise of Darkrai movie, we come across the narrator in the opening sequence outright mentioning that there is a rift between time and space, and that it is endless.



This, of course, is in reference to Dialga and Palkia’s battle in the movie. The setting for the battle those 2 had in Rise of Darkrai took place within this space-time rift. The rift here is not only explicitly stated to be a different space, but it is also considered the space between the dimensions.





As seen & stated in the 2 clips above, the rift appears to be acting as a dimensional space that’s separating the dimensions in the Pokemon Cosmology. Along with being stated as a different space, Palkia is shown to clearly enter Alamos Town from the rift through a dimensional portal. And on top of that, Ash & his friends, & all of Alamos Town, were literally present inside of this space with Palkia having teleported the entire city there and having it float within the rift. This demonstrates that there’s no direct connection present between universes, that the dimensions are instead separated by the rift & that this rift is indeed its own separate reality from the multiverse.

Now, we know that “dimensions” here in this context is speaking about parallel universes, since the rift was called a different space, and in between the dimensions, in comparison to that of the pokemon universe. What further helps establish this point is Palkia, where part of its lore and dominion over space, specifies that it lives within the rift in-between the dimensions, which also includes parallel universes.





At this point, I'm sure you all can see where I'm going with this. The rift between dimensions in Pokemon here being stated as endless, as well as being its own different space, would now give us proof that the space in between these dimensions, also cited as parallel universes, has a significant enough size for it to be applicable for scaling purposes. And in order for the rift to be capable of actually separating these 4-D universes, for being the space in between them, it would be required to be displaced along a higher-dimensional axis above the standard number of spatial dimensions. Thus, this would make the rift 5-D, & at a significant size.

There are other helpful details to support us here as well:

The Unown’s Dimension

In the above clips, we clearly see the very large presence of Unown roaming around in the middle of Dialga & Palkia’s battle within the rift. This gives us a great indication that the Unown’s dimension, & the rift between dimensions, are the same thing here. By going off of that, then some more supportive details from this are worth mentioning here for this.

Here, here, and here.

The Unown’s dimension has been seen before, and along with the rift’s statement of being a different space, we of course have the Unown’s dimension being called a world & another dimension in its own right. Their world is also depicted as having entire stars, nebulae, & whatnot contained within it.

A glaring detail to notice here is せかい ("sekai"), a term in the Japanese version which was mentioned. In Japanese, “Sekai” can have 3 different meanings, depending on the context behind it. “Planet”, “Society”, or “Universe”. Given the context we have here, such as the Unown’s world being also known as another dimension & the presence of stars & nebulae depicting their world on a cosmic scale, it should be fair to claim “universe” is what the meaning here is, as “planet” & “society” wouldn’t fit under this.

On top of that, here is another little piece of evidence worth considering.

For what it’s worth here, while this is from the dub version & we normally prioritize the original language, the dub should be suitable to use as supportive supplemental evidence when additional context can be provided, & the subs do not contradict it (especially in Pokemon’s case with the nature of how the verse works here). And in the dub, Misty in this same moment straight up calls the Unown’s world a universe.

With everything as presented thus far, this would help out even more to hammer in the point that the space between dimensions is not only indeed a separate space of significant size, but that it does function as a universe of its very own, and for being the space between separating parallel universes, the rift would be tiered at 5-D so far.

With that being said, however, we can try taking this even further. Another point to add here into this also that may be helpful.

EDIT: Nevermind on the bottom section. It's been determined that more is needed to prove an additional time-axis is required, so low 1-C for the god tiers, 1-C for Arceus is the new proposal.

The Rift Having a Time Axis

As already explained above for the given reasoning, the endless rift between dimensions that Dialga and Palkia were battling in should be 5-D with significant size. To go along with this, the rift should also contain its own time axis.

During the course of Dialga & Palkia’s battle in The Rise of Darkrai, we can discern that their own space-time powers are shown to be effectively able to operate inside of the rift. One prior clip displays DIalga using it’s signature move against Palkia, Roar of Time, which as we know is able to distort time. Along with that, we also see that Dialga was able to cause the flow of time to go totally out of whack inside of the rift just by roaring.

With both of these things taken into account, Dialga being able to do these things involving time demonstrates that the rift doesn’t lack time. Quite the opposite. There would need to be a temporal framework present within itself in order for this to occur. Because of that, an additional time axis for this rift would mean that an uncountably infinite number of snapshots of 5-Dimensional space from the rift would be generated.

As a result, if i'm understanding this correctly, then not only would this should further help make the rift be significant enough of a 5-D space to further qualify as a Low 1-C structure, but the addition of a time axis would make the rift qualify as a 1-C structure in its totality.


How This Would Scale

With everything presented up to now, the rest will be easy to explain.

Should this upgrade come to pass, these Pokemon that immediately come to mind would be able to become Low 1-C:

EDIT: Forgot some Trainers & Pokemon scale to this, I'll quickly edit them into the list as well.

The Creation Trio​

Putting aside the obvious knowledge of the Creation Trio having created the totality of the Pokemon Cosmology, Dialga & Palkia in the movie were significantly affecting the dimensional rift here.

We see that the two of them were causing shockwaves within the rift, on several occasions. One of the clips above demonstrates this.

More importantly, Dialga and Palkia were going to destroy the rift as well during their battle.

The Lake Trio​

Self Explanatory. The Trio combined can rival that of one of the Creation Trio and can sate them. Individually they’d be 1/3rd of this.

The Lunar Duo (Darkrai & Cresselia)​

Cresselia is equal to Darkrai, the latter who’s comparable to both Dialga and Palkia and puts up a fight against them both. For a number of reasons that his page already does the job of explaining for me.

Eternatus

Zacian & Zamazenta (Crowned Shield Keys Only)

Arceus​

Very self-explanatory. Given Avatar Arceus’s reasons for already being Low 1-C, this proposal going through would undoubtedly bump Arceus up to 1-C.

Trainers​


And with that......here we go.

Agree (11):

Staff: @Planck69, @Random-Helper323, @Vietthai96

Non-staff: @Bobsican, @Robo432343, @Da3ggman, @JJSliderman, @RM97, @Ghengiroo115, @Monkey_Dunno,
@Hypercyber37

Disagree:

Neutral (1):

Staff:

Non-staff: @DaReaperMan
 
Last edited:
Scaling is fine, but not sure on this being Tier 1, not exactly my specialty and this requires pretty in-depth knowledge on tier 1 standards.
 
For a moment I got scared and thought you wanted to upgrade everyone to 1-A or something, lol.

Anyway, the argument seems coherent to me.

But there’s one thing the post doesn’t explain: how are you going to treat all the instances where the Creation Trio fights other PokĂ©mon? For example, in the Hoopa movie, Hoopa summons the Creation Trio and several PokĂ©mon are shown as at least somewhat comparable to them. That also happens consistently in the manga and the games.

Are you going to upgrade all Legendary Pokémon to Low 1-C?
 
But there’s one thing the post doesn’t explain: how are you going to treat all the instances where the Creation Trio fights other PokĂ©mon? For example, in the Hoopa movie, Hoopa summons the Creation Trio and several PokĂ©mon are shown as at least somewhat comparable to them. That also happens consistently in the manga and the games.

Are you going to upgrade all Legendary Pokémon to Low 1-C?

For the moment, we currently treat this as a case of PIS, most especially the Hoopa movie, because of the quantity of legendaries conjured up to one place where those legendaries consistently have feats that are not on the level of the Creation Trio.

With that being said, there may be some other interesting stuff which, if it checks out, could also be potential additions for a lot of legendaries. But thats being held off for now.
 
For the moment, we currently treat this as a case of PIS, most especially the Hoopa movie, because of the quantity of legendaries conjured up to one place where those legendaries consistently have feats that are not on the level of the Creation Trio.

With that being said, there may be some other interesting stuff which, if it checks out, could also be potential additions for a lot of legendaries. But thats being held off for now.

That sounds really arbitrary. I don't know how to feel about it.
 
That sounds really arbitrary. I don't know how to feel about it.
Most pokemon have feats below tier 6, legendaries included, you really think a Pokémon whose claim to fame is making 40 day hurricanes is comparable to things that shit out universes while highly weakened?
 
Most pokemon have feats below tier 6, legendaries included, you really think a Pokémon whose claim to fame is making 40 day hurricanes is comparable to things that shit out universes while highly weakened?

It’s not a matter of “what I think,” it’s a matter of what the work shows, and what the work shows is something that’s decided and approved in the offices of The PokĂ©mon Company, the people in charge of the franchise.

Darkrai and Cresselia don’t have cosmic implications in context either, yet they’re currently 2-C.
 
Guys, again. Please leave the scaling out of this thread, if you want to argue it or ask questions we can do so later.

The proposal itself is a lot to work with and I do not want this getting cluttered up with derailing.
 
Guys, again. Please leave the scaling out of this thread, if you want to argue it or ask questions we can do so later.

The proposal itself is a lot to work with and I do not want this getting cluttered up with derailing.

Derailment?? This is literally one of the central topics of this thread. You’re arguing that Darkrai and Cresselia scale off this just because they “put up a fight” against the Creation Trio.

Saying the other PokĂ©mon don’t get the same treatment just based on vibes is incoherent.
 
Derailment?? This is literally one of the central topics of this thread. You’re arguing that Darkrai and Cresselia scale off this just because they “put up a fight” against the Creation Trio.

Saying the other PokĂ©mon don’t get the same treatment just based on vibes is incoherent.

Regardless, this is derailing because this is the consensus the site for a while has gone with. It's on the pages for a reason. And now all of a sudden it's being questioned. Which is fine, but it's taking away discussion from the actual upgrade here, And tier 1....anything, is already a lot to deal with.

If you have questions on how we scale them, it should just be taken to another thread to be focused on or left to be discussed later, so the upgrade itself can be the topic here.
 
Scaling should be completely secondary and can be handled on its own in another thread.

As for the cosmology, I am fine with the Rift being Low 1-C, given it not only separates parallel space-time continuums but is in itself stated to be endless. That much seems straightforward.

The time axis on the other hand does need more elaboration than just being able to use time based abilities on a certain place. In absence of a direct statement of a second temporal dimension, proof of the multiverse being embedded in this higher time axis would be something like time travel on such a scale showing change to the dimensions within it.

So I can agree with Low 1-C for the totality of the multiverse and Creation Trio (and Arceus being 1-C subsequently) but no higher than that until there's more elaboration on the Rift having a timelinen of its own.
 
Regardless, this is derailing because this is the consensus the site for a while has gone with. It's on the pages for a reason. And now all of a sudden it's being questioned. Which is fine, but it's taking away discussion from the actual upgrade here, And tier 1....anything, is already a lot to deal with.

This way of doing things seems completely counterproductive to me. Severe inconsistencies in scaling can cause serious problems for a Tier 1, you know?

Anyway, suit yourself.
 
Scaling should be completely secondary and can be handled on its own in another thread.

Thank you.

As for the cosmology, I am fine with the Rift being Low 1-C, given it not only separates parallel space-time continuums but is in itself stated to be endless. That much seems straightforward.

The time axis on the other hand does need more elaboration than just being able to use time based abilities on a certain place. In absence of a direct statement of a second temporal dimension, proof of the multiverse being embedded in this higher time axis would be something like time travel on such a scale showing change to the dimensions within it.

Hmm. Thats a fair point. Would being able to see into the future of what happens in the 5-D structure be evident of a time axis being there?
 
Thank you.



Hmm. Thats a fair point. Would being able to see into the future of what happens in the 5-D structure be evident of a time axis being there?
This is a generally achievable action in most fiction that usually has no greater implication, so not quite, else any feat of multi-universal precognition would make a cosmology Low 1-C. It depends of course on the context though. A sequence of events affecting the overall multiverse i.e. being able to time travel before or foresee the creation/destruction of certain universes within the multiverse, would be better evidence of this.
 
This is a generally achievable action in most fiction that usually has no greater implication, so not quite, else any feat of multi-universal precognition would make a cosmology Low 1-C. It depends of course on the context though. A sequence of events affecting the overall multiverse i.e. being able to time travel before or foresee the creation/destruction of certain universes within the multiverse, would be better evidence of this.

Okay gotcha. There may be something, but for now id rather make that its own thread when digging through it more. For now im good with arguing 5-D rift & 1-C for Arceus.
 
Scaling should be completely secondary and can be handled on its own in another thread.
The full scope of the pages affected by a content revision thread should be known by the time it's applied. Changes which affect site standards as a whole are completely exempt from this, but usage of those new standards to update specific series isn't. Upgrades to statistics and changes to abilities are required to include a list of characters believed to be affected in the post introducing those changes. Downgrades to statistics and changes in accordance with alterations in site standards should include such a list if possible, but if not, a mention that one is unsure will suffice.
From our discussion rules. It has to be handled here.
 
Anyways, my original post remains unchanged but I am neutral to others outside Arceus and the Creation Trio scaling, given my unfamiliarity with the setting.
 
If Ho-Oh got reason to scale for this, sure. (And yeah, I know Lugia got a thing on the Hoopa movie)

Nice try being cheeky tho.
Make a thread titled "Creation Trio and Legendary Scaling". This thread is just for upgrading CT and Arceus, with anyone who CURRENTLY scales being listed in the OP. Ho-oh and Lugia are High 6-A right now. They are not currently scaling to the Creation Trio, nor are many others. Tell me, without a different thread being made, are tier 6 characters effected by tier 2s being upgraded?
 
Make a thread titled "Creation Trio and Legendary Scaling". This thread is just for upgrading CT and Arceus, with anyone who CURRENTLY scales being listed in the OP. Ho-oh and Lugia are High 6-A right now. They are not currently scaling to the Creation Trio, nor are many others. Tell me, without a different thread being made, are tier 6 characters effected by tier 2s being upgraded?
I will not entertain you on this. Our rules are clear. If this revision affects other characters in any way, it has to be brought up here.

That the Hoopa movie messes with things is not my problem. Decide here if you want to factor it in the scaling implications of the thread. But currently, Hoopa is indeed directly affected, and if that affects others, so be it.

Last thing I will say on the matter.

Edit: Btw, this also affects all the trainers scaling to the CT in some way. But I don't think those are particularly controversial? But yeh
 
Last edited:
Make a thread titled "Creation Trio and Legendary Scaling". This thread is just for upgrading CT and Arceus, with anyone who CURRENTLY scales being listed in the OP. Ho-oh and Lugia are High 6-A right now. They are not currently scaling to the Creation Trio, nor are many others. Tell me, without a different thread being made, are tier 6 characters effected by tier 2s being upgraded?

"Upgrades to statistics and changes to abilities are required to include a list of characters believed to be affected in the post introducing those changes."

I don’t see any requirement that the characters mentioned have to be only those who currently scale one way or another.

This is a general rule. If a change is made and that change still maintains that X Pokémon scale from the Creation Trio because they fought them, then all the other instances where that happens must necessarily be discussed as well.

Instead of wasting time acting rude and writing useless cheeky messages, contribute to the thread by offering ideas on how to address the scaling chains.
 
From our discussion rules. It has to be handled here.

I actually wasn't aware this was a posted discussion rule, either. So my apologies I will say.

In that case, I guess I'll just say outright that none of the legendaries outside of the ones named in this thread should be getting this upgrade. Not without some new feats that have come to present that case, anyway.

It's been, verbatim, made clear here that the Hoopa stuff was to be thrown out as PIS because of it being a setting of multiple legendaries randomly thrown together made to fight each other beyond their control, and disregarding that, this is a one time instance of these legendaries doing that compared to their normal feats & scaling that is very certainly considerably inferior to this.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't aware this was a posted discussion rule, either. So my apologies I will say.

In that case, I guess I'll just say outright that none of the legendaries outside of the ones named in this thread should be getting this upgrade. Not without some new feats that have come to present that case.

It's been, verbatim, made clear here that the Hoopa stuff was to be thrown out as PIS because of it being a setting of multiple legendaries randomly thrown together made to fight each other beyond their control, and disregarding that, this is a one time instance of these legendaries doing that compared to their normal feats & scaling that is very certainly considerably inferior to this.
No worries.

And yeah, I definitely agree the entire Hoopa movie is a clear case of outliers. But still, it is important to mention.
 
I don’t see any requirement that the characters mentioned have to be only those who currently scale one way or another.

This is a general rule. If a change is made and that change still maintains that X Pokémon scale from the Creation Trio because they fought them, then all the other instances where that happens must necessarily be discussed as well.

Instead of wasting time acting rude and writing useless cheeky messages, contribute to the thread by offering ideas on how to address the scaling chains.
I have an idea: you go ahead and make a scanned list of everyone who should scale to CT and why.

I'd do it myself but I'm already juggling multiple revisions already, specifically for Starcraft, don't need to add figuring out how to get scans from my tablet onto a site that takes them to that experience.
I will not entertain you on this. Our rules are clear. If this revision affects other characters in any way, it has to be brought up here.

That the Hoopa movie messes with things is not my problem. Decide here if you want to factor it in the scaling implications of the thread. But currently, Hoopa is indeed directly affected, and if that affects others, so be it.

Last thing I will say on the matter.

Edit: Btw, this also affects all the trainers scaling to the CT in some way. But I don't think those are particularly controversial? But yeh
Oh and sorry for getting heated, I have no idea why that drove me up the wall so fast
 
I have an idea: you go ahead and make a scanned list of everyone who should scale to CT and why.

You’re no one to tell me what to do, lmao. I didn’t put a gun to Kukui’s head to make him make the thread. I can help, sure, but don’t try to be funny, because you’re not.

I'd do it myself but I'm already juggling multiple revisions already, specifically for Starcraft, don't need to add figuring out how to get scans from my tablet onto a site that takes them to that experience.

I don't care.
 
You’re no one to tell me what to do, lmao. I didn’t put a gun to Kukui’s head to make him make the thread. I can help, sure, but don’t try to be funny, because you’re not.



I don't care.
No need for the attitude now.
 
You’re no one to tell me what to do, lmao. I didn’t put a gun to Kukui’s head to make him make the thread. I can help, sure, but don’t try to be funny, because you’re not.



I don't care.
Well, to put it in more friendly terms, the burden of proof would fall on you to claim any scaling of this sort, given that the OP isn't even advocating for it.
 
Well, to put it in more friendly terms, the burden of proof would fall on you to claim any scaling of this sort, given that the OP isn't even advocating for it.
Thank you, was struggling with wording that didn't sound too bewildered
 
Anyway, as a baseline, I see two ways to approach this problem:

1. No one scales from the Creation Trio except the Pixie Trio, and all the instances where other PokĂ©mon fight them are treated as PIS, which is more or less how the verse is currently handled, as far as I understand. This would mean that neither Darkrai nor Cresselia scale, for obvious reasons. While this is the easiest alternative, it would need to be properly justified, because you can’t just ignore feats without explanation.

2. The scaling chains are valid, in which case most of the instances where Pokémon scale from the Trio for X or Y reason would need to be brought up and addressed.
 
Well, to put it in more friendly terms, the burden of proof would fall on you to claim any scaling of this sort, given that the OP isn't even advocating for it.

Like I said, I can help. I’m just not very patient with that kind of attitude.
 
Well, to put it in more friendly terms, the burden of proof would fall on you to claim any scaling of this sort, given that the OP isn't even advocating for it.

This is what's confusing for me too considering the other legendaries named here are not even ones im advocating to get this upgrade, and the one thing being argued to justify them having it is riddled with PIS.

Darkrai & Cresselia undoubtedly scale to this. We've had several discussions already in the past and Darkrai is consistently comparable to the Creation Trio. Even in the same movie he's blatantly around their level and capable of taking serious attacks from them for much of that fight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top