• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Recent content by Betaredex

  1. Betaredex

    Yasuri Shichika vs Emiya Shirou

    Man whose body is a sword vs man whose body is made of swords Perfected Deviant Blade Shichika vs Fate Route Shirou Shichika's Profile Shirou's Profile Shichika: Shirou: Inconclusive:
  2. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu revision

    For the first point, I assumed your reasoning behind not considering Manabu collapsing the superposition as destruction of some number of possible worlds was that there could be an external observer that keeps everything in a superposition. That was a misunderstanding on my part, I guess. In...
  3. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu revision

    Also, I'm concerned that this interpretation will cause a lot of inconclusive matchups, since there's no way to gauge what is a possibility of the universe that Manabu can observe and what isn't. I very much doubt that the existence of magic was already permitted within the laws of Manabu's...
  4. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu revision

    Also, I'd appreciate clarification on one thing: When you use the deduction that the Qualia-verse functions on the Copenhagen interpretation, are you implying that: a. Possibilities are not 4D constructs b. Manabu doesn't "destroy" alternate possibilities by observing them c. Both
  5. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu revision

    Just finished reading the thread, I appreciate the clarity of your argument. The one part of this interpretation that strikes me as strange is that there's no indication of whether that observer outside of the box who determines Manabu's observation actually exists. From Manabu's perspective...
  6. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    Is everyone here in agreement on 2-A then?
  7. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    Also, I think you're misunderstanding what 2-A is. To qualify as 2-A, you have to be able to destroy an infinite number of universes. Just because she didn't destroy every possibility doesn't mean she didn't destroy an infinite number of possibilities, which is the point I was trying to make before.
  8. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    I was a bit confused by what your argument was so I gave an explanation that didn't really apply. Sorry about that.
  9. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    My original point was that the the possibilities are ALL distinct worlds. The universe with magic existing was described by Manabu as another possibility, and it clearly isn't the same universe.
  10. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    2-A requires an infinite number of 4-D systems, not ALL 4-D systems. There are an infinite number of even numbers, every even number is an integer, and there are an infinite number of integers, but that doesnt mean every integer is even.
  11. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    I'm unsure what would prompt a 2-B rating. Whether you interpret the collapse of the superposition as an indication of AP or not, there's nothing that suggests that she'd be limited to a finite number of universes (which is what 2-B is).
  12. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    If there's only one universe remaining, doesn't that mean that the superposition of all the other possibilities was collapsed? Regardless, she can still manipulate every possibility through observation.
  13. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    Updated the page.
  14. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    Actually, time travel would fall under time manipulation. I felt like what she did when redefining herself out of the universe was more akin to Law Manipulation but it could fall under Information Manipulation as well.
  15. Betaredex

    Hatou Manabu Revisions

    I assumed it would be an uncountably infinite number since theoretically there are an uncountably infinite number of ways you can manipulate the laws of the universe. My reservation with regards to that is that it's never actually explored.
See more
Back
Top