- 2,778
- 3,375
Permission granted by @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless in discord
All credits goes to @Ruler_Star_Kuma, @RaikiKurohane99, @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless, @Hecky2222
So it isn't even secret over wiki flooded by ID larpers and we got wanks that taken out of context. Hence after discussion with UMR, we decided to make staff thread(In case prevent this thread from spam and arguments from mediatok larpers that doesn't even counter nor relevant to thread). So let's begin
Immeasurable Speed or what is it even?
Whole immeasurable speed chainscaling comes from this feat performed by Hedgehog in Volume 7 Chapter 23. At first glance, everything feels alright, until you look at context, which makes no sense if we think this feat performed by pure speed
So first question to context of this scene will be "Was Hedgehog in past even or God who was fighting with dude simply performed attack to past? If second, then why tf Hedgehog who remains here in present should avoid attack by moving further into past. Unless it is just him manipulating his past-self to avoid that attack. This can be read even in OTL when you look at this: Within a limited space-time environment, the ability to alter phenomena was only natural for a god. So essentially ability to alter phenomena in context can't be speed, but rather it implies past manipulation. This is context. But what does RAW Translations tell us?
As you can see, even in RAWs text straight up tells "it is past manipulation" instead of speed. This is textbook Causality Manipulation which can be meet often in verse, and we have in fiction similar abilities of past alteration
So Proposal 1 includes:
1. Hedgehog "Immeasurable Speed" will be changed to "Causality Manipulation", and everyone who was chainscaled to Hedgehog will lose this speed
2. Hedgehog and Top Tiers will be scaled to best speed calc feat.
Biggest Joke: History Regeneration
This thread aka our favorite LARPzerty managed to take everything out of context and now every god tier has High Godly Regeneration through History, eventhough it was stated multiple times by other users "History Regen is rare". If you are lazy to read. Let me bring up full context:
In very short version of context: History Erasure comes from special thing called "Erasure Bold". It was when Mitsuki was explaining that to Yogiri. This thing has own name "Erasure Bold" and was used only once. ONLY ONCE AND IT DIDN'T WORK.
Whole context for people who are interested
As we can see, it was used only one time. So this doesn't prove how gods regenerate from Erasure Bold. To assume this is true: We should think Mitsuki uses his trump card everytime and Existence Erasure is rare thing in Verse. Which we can see it isn't. It is like saying any God from DB can survive Zeno's EE(Cringe analogy but you get point of "Best attack that isn't used more than one time" I hope).
But you can ask "Sure, but they have causality, information, conceptual erasure, why don't they use it against each other". Response to it was covered here perfectly:
But we don't say nuke it to LGR back. It was stated soul = mind in Instant Death. Meaning whoever on UEG level would get Mid Godly Regeneration
And based on this we should add this to Gods profile
1. History Regeneration Downgrade, as well it would include why any other regenerations not possible
2. As well stated above. Gods who are in UEG level would get Mid Godly Regeneration Overtime, whereas Yogiri would have MGR Negation
Finally additions
After all nuke, we can add something right?
Yogiri should get Causality Manipulation under his first gate, this would become "Greater Causality Manipulation" for his third gate as a result
TLDR:
1. History Regen will be changed to MGR
2. Immeasurable Speed will be changed to MFTL+
3. Addition to profile
Agree: @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless @Reiner04 @Vietthai96
Disagree:
Neutral:
All credits goes to @Ruler_Star_Kuma, @RaikiKurohane99, @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless, @Hecky2222
So it isn't even secret over wiki flooded by ID larpers and we got wanks that taken out of context. Hence after discussion with UMR, we decided to make staff thread(In case prevent this thread from spam and arguments from mediatok larpers that doesn't even counter nor relevant to thread). So let's begin
Immeasurable Speed or what is it even?
Whole immeasurable speed chainscaling comes from this feat performed by Hedgehog in Volume 7 Chapter 23. At first glance, everything feels alright, until you look at context, which makes no sense if we think this feat performed by pure speed
OTL of Vol 7 Chapter 23“Just die!” The Hedgehog’s right arm was twisted off and blown away. “So you can even dodge that?!”
Although she seemed furious at first, the woman howled with glee upon seeing the Hedgehog’s response. She had performed an attack on the past. The Hedgehog responded to the attack by moving even further into the past, partially avoiding the attack that had forcibly rewritten an already determined outcome. Within a limited space-time environment, the ability to alter phenomena was only natural for a god. If one couldn’t fight on that level, they had no business fighting a god. For the Hedgehog, who had been designed specifically to fight against gods, such an ability was a necessary function.
So first question to context of this scene will be "Was Hedgehog in past even or God who was fighting with dude simply performed attack to past? If second, then why tf Hedgehog who remains here in present should avoid attack by moving further into past. Unless it is just him manipulating his past-self to avoid that attack. This can be read even in OTL when you look at this: Within a limited space-time environment, the ability to alter phenomena was only natural for a god. So essentially ability to alter phenomena in context can't be speed, but rather it implies past manipulation. This is context. But what does RAW Translations tell us?
確定した事象を無理やりに書き換えるその攻撃を、針鼠ヘツジホツグはさらに過去の自分を操作することにより対応したのだ。
Raws of Vol 7 Chap 23限定的な時空間においての事象の改変は、神ならできて当たり前の技能だ。その次元での闘いができないのなら、神と闘う資格はない。
Translation by @RaikiKurohane99 in discordThe attack that forcibly rewrites a determined (fixed) phenomenon, the hedgehog Hedgehog dealt with it by further manipulating his past self.
The alteration of phenomena within a limited spacetime is a skill that, if one is a god, can naturally be done. If one cannot fight at that dimension, there is no qualification to fight a god.
As you can see, even in RAWs text straight up tells "it is past manipulation" instead of speed. This is textbook Causality Manipulation which can be meet often in verse, and we have in fiction similar abilities of past alteration
So Proposal 1 includes:
1. Hedgehog "Immeasurable Speed" will be changed to "Causality Manipulation", and everyone who was chainscaled to Hedgehog will lose this speed
2. Hedgehog and Top Tiers will be scaled to best speed calc feat.
Biggest Joke: History Regeneration
This thread aka our favorite LARPzerty managed to take everything out of context and now every god tier has High Godly Regeneration through History, eventhough it was stated multiple times by other users "History Regen is rare". If you are lazy to read. Let me bring up full context:
In very short version of context: History Erasure comes from special thing called "Erasure Bold". It was when Mitsuki was explaining that to Yogiri. This thing has own name "Erasure Bold" and was used only once. ONLY ONCE AND IT DIDN'T WORK.
Chapter 25 Volume 13Mitsuki collapsed, his erasure bolt winking out before it reached Yogiri. Hisfriend Alexia was still frozen
Whole context for people who are interested
As we can see, it was used only one time. So this doesn't prove how gods regenerate from Erasure Bold. To assume this is true: We should think Mitsuki uses his trump card everytime and Existence Erasure is rare thing in Verse. Which we can see it isn't. It is like saying any God from DB can survive Zeno's EE(Cringe analogy but you get point of "Best attack that isn't used more than one time" I hope).
But you can ask "Sure, but they have causality, information, conceptual erasure, why don't they use it against each other". Response to it was covered here perfectly:
This is outright fishy, especially since this scan comes along from the same chapter where we get (the objectively best character) Kouryu explaining the significance and nature of a God's omnipotence as a whole.
Kouryu explained as it being inherently subjective, varying from person to person as well as when it comes down to two Gods fighting another, it's not only strength but ones mindset AND strength that can have one come out on top, it all being defined by each God's own will and emotions. Contradictions with something like omniscience hamper these sorts of ideals, so they're ignored for the most part.
Such mental hampering is very detrimental to the point that Gods like Malna after getting mentally done in (mogged) by Kouryu, though still superior to him as said by himself, she’s able to be killed by getting impaled from behind by the likes of Miranda, without any notion of her core, soul, or concept even getting damaged. Implying that Gods (once mentally done in) can perish from much less than any aspects being destroyed.
It possibly wouldn't be so bad, possibly, but this isn't the only time something like this happens. I believe ignoring this is (obviously without a doubt) bad and VERY hard to do. Especially concerning how existence erasure on our actual page says it's never assumed to be done to any metaphysical aspects like the soul of someone automatically/by default. Heck, there's examples and blatant showings where a character has been described to be 'erased', but they're doing little more than attacking them with AP (likely to assume advantage of the weakness of their omnipotence powers) but no mention of anything important.
Even while said examples do include the likes of striking the cores, it's hardly any evidence to imply it's tied to something like the Gods concept, UEG even going out of her way to actively differentiate between the two in her experience against the likes of Rick and against the nameless instant death boy. Hell, not even any suggestion it's like their soul unless it's to assume a 'likely', it tosses up the question for if every other God should have such high level of overtime revival as you're proposing. Mind you, that same boy (if not just their ability alone in terms of effectiveness) having the likelihood of being stronger than what Touichiro has been shown to really do. So only really UEG benefits, and even then it'd be Mid-Godly at best due to her seeing it as a way to permanently put her down, she just comes back ridiculously faster overall from something like core destruction.
To address this, this also seems very fishy as if you're trying to fish for some sort of NEP out of the Gods when not even THE UEG (horrible name) sees the concept of nonexistence as impossible, and that's alongside the fact of Kouryu tossing up the question of if where they had been was even real to begin with (thus making it vague.) It should be saying a lot if you think a God any lower than her should gain such a thing. But, that's me assuming you are, this is a regeneration thread after all. It's moreso a God being in an afterlife waiting room of sorts.
However, I explicitly have the most problem right here. Mitsuki is a top of the line god, though this text specifies it as him likely giving the person being talked about some mercy, it's less there being no choice and more likely among the way Gods have gotten defeated before as described in this post, and not having defeated them to such an extent (history erasure) because of one missing piece of context left out.
That being, Mitsuki's history erasure works on.. himself as well. History Erasure, at least how Mitsuki defines his will have everyone not remember you upon being struck by it, even including from himself. It goes hand in hand with his control over his jurisdiction of a dream in that upon being forgotten by him, it is then one essentially gets hit with a sort of 'super erasure' due to them disappearing from his dream overall. Unless you can show that Gods can exist being erased so deeply to where they can disappear from his dream and come back.. just how exactly does this apply to every other god?
This link leads to the history erasure scan for Mitsuki's erasure bolt, don't know what this is doing here (made a mistake or something?) But because I know what scan you're talking about, I'll indulge it a bit.
'Conceptual attacks' mean nothing by themselves, UEG can induce her attacks with the concept of ignoring defense, but something like that is unrelated. See where that falls apart? So they can be considered unimportant.
Complete erasure - See to my link about the different sorts of erasure within Instant Death as for what 'complete erasure' can refer to.
Causality Erasure - You'd think this would seem fairly surefire as additional evidence, yeah, but.. so what? Is this assuming Gods can resist such erasure just because it exists in the sea? We've seen gods other than UEG essentially survive much less, no? Not like any bit of the OP in terms of some of the evidence dedicates it's time to addressing the points involved in the same Mid-Godly downgrade thread for someone like UEG in the first place, why would they work for the Gods who're explicitly below them? But like I said - she explicitly needs to be conceptually killed anyway, so Mid-Godly for her at best is fine.
And based on this we should add this to Gods profile
So Proposal 2 includes:Weaknesses: Gods and their Omnipotence functionally rely on their mindset, this effectively allows one to potentially outright nullify or even ignore aspects (such as regeneration) for them to be killed via lesser means than they can usually handle. Said death from then onward leading them to be rendered in their Non-Combat Applicable state.
1. History Regeneration Downgrade, as well it would include why any other regenerations not possible
2. As well stated above. Gods who are in UEG level would get Mid Godly Regeneration Overtime, whereas Yogiri would have MGR Negation
Finally additions
After all nuke, we can add something right?
Yogiri should get Causality Manipulation under his first gate, this would become "Greater Causality Manipulation" for his third gate as a result
TLDR:
1. History Regen will be changed to MGR
2. Immeasurable Speed will be changed to MFTL+
3. Addition to profile
Agree: @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless @Reiner04 @Vietthai96
Disagree:
Neutral:
Last edited: