Arthur Morgan vs Dexter Morgan (5-0-0)

[Friedoil11]

I had an interesting idea, so lets find out if it works.

ARTHUR MORGAN VS DEXTER MORGAN
The rules:

1. The battle is set in Miami, Florida.
2. Dexter is in his second key.
3. Arthur has a whole year of prep time to understand where he is and to hide his identity and knows that in a year someone will search him and try to kill him.
4. Dexter knows the real name of Arthur, general description of him and his resistances.
5. Arthur starts with a revolver, his lasso, 1.000 dollars and an identity card
6. Dexter has access to all of his equipment.
7. Arthur has the freedom to change his name and do robberies if he needs to.
8. The police will start to search for Arthur only after the year has passed (only if Arthur committed crimes) and he knows it.
9. Dexter has a month to find and kill Arthur before the police does and puts him into jail.
10. Arthur wins if he survives the month or kills Dexter.
11. Dexter wins if he kills Arthur.
12. If the police arrests Arthur, it's inconclusive.

Arthur Morgan: Clousure, Anonymous_Learner, Pyro9278, Friedoil11, ThePrimalHunter,
Dexter Morgan:
Inconclusive:

 

[Friedoil11]

bump

 

[LegendariumOfLies]

Arthur resist Sleep manip and Poision manip which mitigates Dexter's main weapon. So the moment Dexter stabs Arthur with the M99 Syringe, this is going to happen:

 

[Friedoil11]

Arthur resist Sleep manip and Poision manip which mitigates Dexter's main weapon. So the moment Dexter stabs Arthur with the M99 Syringe, this is going to happen:

Two things:

1. Should I give prior knowledge of Arthur's resistances to Dexter in exchange of Dexter's weaknessess to Arthur to make it more balanced?
2. Since usually Dexter hits with the syringe from behind and will realize that it doesn't work, Arthur will surely try to turn around and shoot him, but since Dexter has higher reaction and perception speed, shouldn't he be able to stop him in time?

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[LegendariumOfLies]

Two things:

1. Should I give prior knowledge of Arthur's resistances to Dexter in exchange of Dexter's weaknessess to Arthur to make it more balanced?

Ig, would at least give Dex a win-con cause otherwise he is ******

1. Since usually Dexter hits with the syringe from behind and will realize that it doesn't work, Arthur will surely try to turn around and shoot him, but since Dexter has higher reaction and perception speed, shouldn't he be able to stop him in time?

Arthur can activate Dead-Eye at any point, so as soon as he stabbed he will activate. As far as stopping him how? Dex has lower AP and LS. Trying to grapple and punch Arthur is a Death Wish.

 

[Friedoil11]

Ig, would at least give Dex a win-con cause otherwise he is ******

Done

Arthur can activate Dead-Eye at any point, so as soon as he stabbed he will activate.

Although this is true, in their profiles it says that Arthur has superhuman reaction speed and subsonic perceptions with the Deadeye, while Dexter has subsonic combat and reaction speed and supersonic perception speed. The only type of speed advantage that Arthur has is his attack speed (which counts only for his firearms).

As far as stopping him how? Dex has lower AP and LS. Trying to grapple and punch Arthur is a Death Wish.

Well, I'm not saying that Dexter would win in a fist fight with Arthur, but it isn't his first time that he deals with someone stronger. A perfect example is Little Chino, which he might not be as strong as Arthur, but can easily overpower Dexter, even a few seconds after he woke up from two doses of M99.

 

[Friedoil11]

Btw, who would the police give a harder time to? Because if you think about it, Dexter has to find Arthur before the police does so that he can kill him, but the police might find clues of where he is or other clues on how he thinks (or things like that).

 

[Friedoil11]

do you think that Arthur would be able to hide from the police?

 

[SharkBook01]

Is SBA still in effect? Because I don't think there's any scenario where Dexter wins if they actually get into a fight. Arthur just blows his head off before he can react.

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[Friedoil11]

Is SBA still in effect? Because I don't think there's any scenario where Dexter wins if they actually get into a fight. Arthur just blows his head off before he can react.

Well,

Although this is true, in their profiles it says that Arthur has superhuman reaction speed and subsonic perceptions with the Deadeye, while Dexter has subsonic combat and reaction speed and supersonic perception speed. The only type of speed advantage that Arthur has is his attack speed (which counts only for his firearms).

As I already said here, the only speed advantage Arthur has is his attack speed, but I don't think Dexter is dumb enough to approach face to face a guy with a gun unless he has one too.

Well, I'm not saying that Dexter would win in a fist fight with Arthur, but it isn't his first time that he deals with someone stronger. A perfect example is Little Chino, which he might not be as strong as Arthur, but can easily overpower Dexter, even a few seconds after he woke up from two doses of M99.

The biggest problem here is the Physical advantage that Arthur has, but Dexter has already encoutered stronger foes.

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[BEASTHEART8800]

I'll note that Arthur actually shouldn't resist Sleep Manipulation, as he didnt take multiple tranq darts to go down, it only took one and it was a few seconds after he was hit.

But I'm planning a small CRT on that.

 

[Friedoil11]

I'll note that Arthur actually shouldn't resist Sleep Manipulation, as he didnt take multiple tranq darts to go down, it only took one and it was a few seconds after he was hit.

But I'm planning a small CRT on that.

Yeah. Btw I changed Dexter's key from the first ro the second one since they changed from when I created this match.

 

[Clousure]

Honestly, I'm voting Arthur here because he has higher AP and LS, and Dexter would def not be able to grapple with Arthur. Although Dexter MIGHT be able to stab Arthur with his M99 syringe, it would probably not fully work, especially due to the fact that he has poison resistance and that Little Chino woke up just a few seconds later after two doses of M99, and he was able to stun Dexter with a punch, which I doubt Arthur wouldn't be able to do. If Dexter tried to sprint directly to Arthur, Arthur would just shoot him before Dexter could reach him.

 

[Friedoil11]

Honestly, I'm voting Arthur here because he has higher AP and LS, and Dexter would def not be able to grapple with Arthur. Although Dexter MIGHT be able to stab Arthur with his M99 syringe, it would probably not fully work, especially due to the fact that he has poison resistance and that Little Chino woke up just a few seconds later after two doses of M99, and he was able to stun Dexter with a punch, which I doubt Arthur wouldn't be able to do. If Dexter tried to sprint directly to Arthur, Arthur would just shoot him before Dexter could reach him.

Counted

 

[Anonymous_Learner]

Arthur FRA

 

[Friedoil11]

Arthur FRA

Added

 

[Pyro9278]

I'm pretty sure Dexter doesn't stand a chance against Arthur. His stealth is countered by Arthur's enhanced senses. A direct fight will end with Dexter being overwhelmed by Dead Eye. I think this is a stomp.

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[Friedoil11]

Bump

 

[Employe]

Isn't it a stomp? Can Dexter plausibly do anything?

 

[Friedoil11]

Isn't it a stomp? Can Dexter plausibly do anything?

Well, while Arthur has an x4 advantage in AP (x3,8210179107759756488264536549825 if we want to be precise) and LS, I think that Dexter has enough skills, intelligence and experience in searching and murdering serial killers to at least not making this a stomp (without counting the speed and location advantage). After this, I think I'd vote for Arthur FRA.

 

[ThePrimalHunter]

Arthur FRA

 

[Pyro9278]

Well, while Arthur has an x4 advantage in AP (x3,8210179107759756488264536549825 if we want to be precise) and LS, I think that Dexter has enough skills, intelligence and experience in searching and murdering serial killers to at least not making this a stomp (without counting the speed and location advantage). After this, I think I'd vote for Arthur FRA.

Dexter cannot overcome Dead Eye or Arthur's enhanced senses. Stealth will not work, nor will any of his methods for hunting killers.