Wannabe Joyboy Vs Larp [0-0-0]

[TheReal7Cris]

Current Garp Vs Kaidou

• Fight is at Onigashima
• Both Are Bloodlusted, Kaidou starts off in his hybrid form
• Both are 20m from each other
• SBA for the rest


Garp:

Kaidou:

Inconclusive:

 

[Nierre]

what makes you think old garp stands a chance here

 

[TheReal7Cris]

what makes you think old garp stands a chance here

Should I change it to Prime Garp then? although not much about his prime is known no? Perhaps Kuzan would be a better matchup then? Or..

 

[Nierre]

well

agenda piece be damned I'm not the most invested in one piece scaling but I doubt garp has the stamina to keep up with someone like Kaido. Dragon Form, Observation Haki and imo the advantage in pretty much every other category, I don't think Old Garp stands a chance in winning.

In regards to the Admirals/Prime Garp I'm probably not the best person to ask

try sending this in the one piece discussion thread to get more traction

 

[TheReal7Cris]

well

agenda piece be damned I'm not the most invested in one piece scaling but I doubt garp has the stamina to keep up with someone like Kaido. Dragon Form, Observation Haki and imo the advantage in pretty much every other category, I don't think Old Garp stands a chance in winning.

In regards to the Admirals/Prime Garp I'm probably not the best person to ask

try sending this in the one piece discussion thread to get more traction

Alright Thanks, very appreciated

 

[Bananossauro]

I can't see anything - other than the admiral agenda going at full force - that makes Garp scale to the level of Kaido's higher end of output/the stuff he brings out when trying and despite having some good showings of endurance by fightng a 1 versus Island, I'm tempted to believe that the caliber of fighter that Garp faced is not on the same level as the ones Kaido faced outside of Kuzan(and Garp lost that one too so it really don't look good for him in my eyes).
The dragon destroys the Cymbals of Oppression liberating the world from Larp

 

[SlendVeny]

Should I change it to Prime Garp then? although not much about his prime is known no? Perhaps Kuzan would be a better matchup then? Or..

Prime Garp slams, basically any Admiral loses hard.

 

[Ryuga21]

Old Garp doesn't have enough stamina to win. Even if we consider direct scaling to characters who fight for 5 days while being physically inferior to Garp (Ace and Jinbe; Jack, Neko/Inu), Kaido still has a ton of physical abilities (regeneration for example) that would give him a huge advantage in endurance, btw, Kaido's performance in this category is far superior to that of old Garp who couldn't hold out much against Kuzan after being stabbed... I would say Kaido takes this Mid-High or Mid diff.

 

[VioIeLFC]

I can't see anything - other than the admiral agenda going at full force - that makes Garp scale to the level of Kaido's higher end of output/the stuff he brings out when trying and despite having some good showings of endurance by fightng a 1 versus Island, I'm tempted to believe that the caliber of fighter that Garp faced is not on the same level as the ones Kaido faced outside of Kuzan(and Garp lost that one too so it really don't look good for him in my eyes).
The dragon destroys the Cymbals of Oppression liberating the world from Larp

Garp didn't lose to Kuzan, he lost to Kuzan + half the Blackbeard pirates and all the countless fodder on the island

In particular a big deal is made over Shiryus attack wounding Garp. Pretty clear it's Oda way of nerfing Garp

Garp does lose as he's old and well past his prime but it's a close fight.