6 Paths Adult Naruto should still be far stronger than his teen self, even if he was off guard
That's a completely baseless argument tho. Base Kaguya one tapped Isshiki offguard. So would we now scale it base Kaguya ~ Isshiki > Momoshiki > CF Kaguya? Offguard nerfs are unquantifiable as far as I'm aware.
And Sasuke's sword isn't anything special, especially after losing his Sword of Kusanagi against Kaguya. It's a plain ass sword,
Also completely baseless. It's pretty illogical to assume Sasuke would get a plainass sword to fight literal gods when even fodders like Orochimaru and Itachi could get swords made out of special materials, and other OP tools like gunbai, 6 paths weapons, etc, were laying around. Even if there is no evidence for it being special and we dismiss the logical assumption of him getting a better one, it's still a completely different weapon from Shins weapons so you can't scale Shin to it.
and at the time it wasn't being used by Sasuke, and therefore wasn't infused with his chakra
Sasuke was literally about to swing it so that would also probably not be true.
like your entire argument against the scaling chain is literally just "Naruto was off guard and was hit by Sasuke's sword therefore this uses Sasuke's AP", despite the fact that Shin's profile directly contradicts this
No? My argument is that Naruto was unquantifiably nerfed and hit by a weapon that's not Shins, as well as the fact that Sakura was indeed hurt by Shins blades as well, meaning
1. Shin only scales to unquantifiably nerfed Naruto
2. Shin only scales this high with a weapon that's not his (we see Naruto counter Shins own blades lol)
3. Sakura doesn't scale to Shins blades
So even scaling her anywhere near WA Naruto is generous enough, scaling her to adult Naruto is completely baseless.
Make a CRT to nerf Shin if you're unsatisfied
I'm still getting accustomed to the wiki since I'm pretty new here. When I feel confident at making bigger CRTs I probably will.
That aside, Shins page only scales his AP with blades to WA Naruto, not NE Naruto. So again, even if you scale Sakura to Sasukes blade here, it only gets her to WA Naruto level.