- 34,591
- 35,024
Based on this other source, the height for the troposhere in Japan in May is around 11 kilometers.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
My Hero Academia General Discussion Thread #18
- Thread starter TheRustyOne
- Start date
- 1,185
- 1,167
Does that affect all clouds or only natural ones? Cos the storm that was dispersed was artificial
Edit: nvm it’s to do with how high water vapour rises. We might be cooked gng. Unless timeframe upgrade (I’m coping)
- 34,591
- 35,024
As far as my understanding of it goes, the storm's source as being natural of artificial wouldn't have an effect on its interaction with the troposphere level.
- 1,185
- 1,167
At least the YouTube scalers can use that one to highball it.You know, I think I'm just gonna overdose on copium and use the method that gives us small planet level, sound good ?
Damn though, all the big manga getting downgraded.
- 8,736
- 13,887
“Guys I swear I don’t pray for downgrades and want every verse to be nerfed, I promise guys, it’s not my character and I don’t see how you could possibly come to that conclusion. I’m sorry if you think that, I’m just trying to be critical and high standards, I promise. I would never celebrate downgrades nor do I hope for every verse to be kicked out of tier 6, just trust me.”
- 14,995
- 10,527
Ghostimuscrime
He/Him- 3,678
- 3,958
LMFAO
- 1,185
- 1,167
I don’t think that’s specifically about Japan. The other source listed was specifically about Japan I believe, so it should be more valid.
- 34,591
- 35,024
Good point, I thought that source was talking about Japan.
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,843
- 6,084
Agreed, let's ALL blame Damage fr fr
- 34,591
- 35,024
This result of the calcs ends up being a lot more consistent with Star and Stripe's Intercontinental Cruise Punch almost killing Shigaraki tbh.
- 180
- 195
There’s that ******* word that I hate
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,843
- 6,084
"Come to have your Feats downgraded?" -Damage 2025
- 14,995
- 10,527
NGL this 16km source is suspicious
- 2,182
- 3,384
Damage can’t catch a break
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,843
- 6,084
Deserved it for moving like Prime All for one and obstructing Deku's Multi-continental future, Damage can tank all of this /j
- 34,591
- 35,024
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,843
- 6,084
Like when Deku was robbed of danger sense, we got to see him moving crazy wijcarnage deku.
unironically, this give and take fits MHA
- 14,878
- 16,615
People will think that MHA got downgraded from High 6-A to 6-B due to slander
Anonymous_Learner
He/Him- 6,843
- 6,084
Someone needs to do you and your downgrades like Deku did AFO
Facts bro, we're so cooked when this goes through
- 14,878
- 16,615
98% of Deku matches:
- 1,185
- 1,167
How so? You should state your reasons in the calc group thread if you think there’s any issues.
- 2,035
- 2,913
If we can get high enough FTL+, I don't mind losing Multicontinental final punch rating.
A speed advantage is all we need for Deku, Shigaraki and AFO.
With Deku we have stacking upto a unspecified amount of times. Who says he can't punch you a million times and then stack it ? The manga certainly doesn't.
Shigaraki and AFO both have a dura neg.
A speed advantage is all we need for Deku, Shigaraki and AFO.
With Deku we have stacking upto a unspecified amount of times. Who says he can't punch you a million times and then stack it ? The manga certainly doesn't.
Shigaraki and AFO both have a dura neg.
- 1,185
- 1,167
We could potentially even get to 6-A with Overdrive, depending on how upscaling goes
- 8,736
- 13,887
Why is the calc stopping at just the final shot we get from the anime? It’s basically only calcing the hole we see Deku initially make and claiming all speed stops at that point and nothing else is dispersed.
Deku is frozen in the air just like the manga, we just have a wider shot of what all he did. Why is it being assumed that nothing occurred afterwards? A dispersion speed of 77063 m/s just completely vanishes because the last thing we see is the hole? And we only don’t see more clouds being dispersed because it’s a slow mo establishing shot, not a real time look at the continued dispersion of the storm? By the logic of the calc, Deku cleared a tiny portion of the storm and the rest of it lingered for all time.
IMO that final shot should be where a deceleration is found like from the first calc thread and applied as the velocity of the dispersion continues outwards.
Deku is frozen in the air just like the manga, we just have a wider shot of what all he did. Why is it being assumed that nothing occurred afterwards? A dispersion speed of 77063 m/s just completely vanishes because the last thing we see is the hole? And we only don’t see more clouds being dispersed because it’s a slow mo establishing shot, not a real time look at the continued dispersion of the storm? By the logic of the calc, Deku cleared a tiny portion of the storm and the rest of it lingered for all time.
IMO that final shot should be where a deceleration is found like from the first calc thread and applied as the velocity of the dispersion continues outwards.
- 1,185
- 1,167
There might be a way to do that as well, given that Izuku doesn’t even move downwards during that scene.
- 8,736
- 13,887
And before someone brings up the Strong Winds calc, that calc assumes that the ENTIRE REST OF THE AREA that Deku dispersed was done at a speed of 124 m/s.
It’s basically saying that Deku dispersed one part at 77063 m:/s… then for the entire rest of the area, he dispersed at 124 m/s. Surely there is an issue there, especially considering the punch wouldn’t simply stop dispersing at initial speed immediately.
Also assuming the gust of wind hit America in 24 hours is crazy, because at that point they would not have referenced it as “the gust of wind from that day.” It would be tomorrow news, when clearly it’s framed as having hit them within a reasonable timeframe.
It’s basically saying that Deku dispersed one part at 77063 m:/s… then for the entire rest of the area, he dispersed at 124 m/s. Surely there is an issue there, especially considering the punch wouldn’t simply stop dispersing at initial speed immediately.
Also assuming the gust of wind hit America in 24 hours is crazy, because at that point they would not have referenced it as “the gust of wind from that day.” It would be tomorrow news, when clearly it’s framed as having hit them within a reasonable timeframe.
- 34,591
- 35,024
We calc what we can see happen. And trying to apply constant speed to the rest of the air beyond that dispersion just doesn't work; it violates conversation of energy.
- 8,736
- 13,887
IMO, the strong winds calc and initial Final Smash calc need to be put together properly. Not just added together.
The dispersion for the final smash should be the basis for the Strong Winds, with initial velocity at 77063 m/s, and then finding a proper deceleration rate to calculate how strong the winds were when they hit the end of America. 24 hours should be reduced for the time frame the wind hit as well, as that is a ridiculous assumption when that would be tomorrow to America, not the same day. It would’ve had to have been during a time where people were still active and awake enough to notice.
Also also, Japan and Washington state have a 16-17 hour time difference, yet it is day time for both of them.
That means the winds had to have hit within the timeframe of 4pm to 6pm at Washington and 8am to 10am at Japan, as that is the only times they are both in sunlight. For a large amount of people to notice (Meryl specifically as she refers to that gust of wind to be “from that day,” she wouldn’t be saying this if it was night and no one noticed), it would have to be between that timeframe no?
The dispersion for the final smash should be the basis for the Strong Winds, with initial velocity at 77063 m/s, and then finding a proper deceleration rate to calculate how strong the winds were when they hit the end of America. 24 hours should be reduced for the time frame the wind hit as well, as that is a ridiculous assumption when that would be tomorrow to America, not the same day. It would’ve had to have been during a time where people were still active and awake enough to notice.
Also also, Japan and Washington state have a 16-17 hour time difference, yet it is day time for both of them.
That means the winds had to have hit within the timeframe of 4pm to 6pm at Washington and 8am to 10am at Japan, as that is the only times they are both in sunlight. For a large amount of people to notice (Meryl specifically as she refers to that gust of wind to be “from that day,” she wouldn’t be saying this if it was night and no one noticed), it would have to be between that timeframe no?
- 8,736
- 13,887
Ah, never mind on the day light thing, was confusing a panel of the storm for being in America, it’s at night time.
Still, a 24 hour time frame is ludicrous imo
Still, a 24 hour time frame is ludicrous imo
- 8,736
- 13,887
But assuming that a shockwave immediately loses all strength by over 600x the second it reaches a single meter past what we initially see isn’t a violation of physics? Especially when we know that it continued onwards and cleared out weather for thousands of km? And the knowledge we have on its speed by the time it “stopped” (since we know it kept going for a week straight) is that it was still a strong gust?
Surely we have enough information there to come to a conclusion.
Also you want the verse downgraded, your opinion is literally biased to not wanting it to make sense if it doesn’t result in a downgrade. So your opinion is kinda absurd and/or designed to obfuscate so you can have your way, not cause of actual issues that can’t be reasoned.
- 34,591
- 35,024
Bruh, by the same logic no supporter of the verse can make a thread because they want the verse upgraded.
For what it's worth, I'm not the one who pointed out the current issue affecting the calc. I was going with the previous version which was 6-A.
- 14,878
- 16,615
Out of curiosity, assuming the result remains the same, the value for Deku and Prime All Might would be around 90 Teratons via the 60x multiplier?
- 2,035
- 2,913
We violate conservation of energy all the time. Fiction in general does.
Similar threads
- Locked
