Is this a fundamental aspects? (staff's opinion will be apreciated)

[Berga14]

Okay, i know that one conceptual self and/or informational self can be a fundamental aspect but what if there is something else not properly defined in the wiki?

About the "aspect" i'm talking about:

1. Without it, the soul dissipates and gets back to the cycle of reincarnation. This kills normal character while spritual lifeform will resurrect from their soul which is their conceptual self (more fundamental).
2. It's used by the soul as a way to express itself to the outside world.
3. It's indipendent from less fundamental part of a being. People can regenerate lower aspects as long as this one exist.
4. It's abstract.

Is this enought for this aspect to be considerate fundamental?

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

I mean yeah, fundamental aspects aren't limited to concepts or information iirc. It varies from verse to verse, in some it can be the soul, the mind, thoughts, time, history, etc. So I'd imagine these can qualify within the given verse

 

[Berga14]

So I'd imagine these can qualify within the given verse

well, the question is exactly this. Is an aspect with the characteristics i listed considerable fundamental and be used for HG ressurrection/regeneration or do i need more? I'm confused about at which point is something considerable fundamental or not.

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

well, the question is exactly this. Is an aspect with the characteristics i listed considerable fundamental and be used for HG ressurrection/regeneration or do i need more? I'm confused about at which point is something considerable fundamental or not.

There's a slight difference between an aspect just being fundamental vs having HGR, since aspects can be fundamental but simultaneously not fundamental enough to qualify for HGR iirc. You'd need proof this aspect exists beyond the mind and soul and at least one additional fundamental aspect beyond that, otherwise if I'm not mistaken it would just be MGR with a type 8 immortality at best

 

[Berga14]

You'd need proof this aspect exists beyond the mind

It does

and soul

It doesn't but the soul is also the conceptual self which is more fundamental than the aspect i'm arguing about

least one additional fundamental aspect beyond that

The additional thing IS the aspect i'm arguing about.

Basically it goes like that:
Body < mind < aspect under exam < soul (conceptual self as well) < informational self

 

[AlipheeseXIV]

Then yeah, I think there's merit in classifying this as HGR. Though, take that with a grain of salt as I am not the end all be all of knowledgeable members for HGR