• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Slow Mo Calc Definition Revision

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bump

Current Vote Count:
Votes for Revision 1: 0

Votes for Revision 2: 3 (Drite77, Floxy178, SomebodyData)

Votes for Revision 3: 1 (Agnaa)

Since revision 2 has the most votes, along with 3 staff votes, do you all believe it is enough to end this and apply the changes?
 
Last edited:
CatLover313 said:
Bump

Current Vote Count:
Votes for Revision 1: 2

Votes for Revision 2: 5 (3 Staff)

Votes for Revision 3: 1 (1 Staff)

Since revision 2 has the most votes, along with 3 staff votes, do you all believe it is enough to end this and apply the changes?
Click to expand...
Bump
 
This is a Calc group discussion, I am not sure if someone that is not a CGM has voting rights on it
 
Drite77 said:
This is a Calc group discussion, I am not sure if someone that is not a CGM has voting rights on it
Click to expand...
Ah, I tried to keep the common vote to show popularity but still have a parenthesis with CGM votes. I'll update it to just display the CGM/Admin votes
 
Just been told that for this revision to go through Revision 2 will need more staff votes unless Agnaa has a change of opinion. More votes will be needed to decide due to differing opinions. Time to continue bumping and asking
 
If the problem is that panels are being reused due to low quality and not as a representation of speed, then this should be a rule that only applies to works that reuse art. There are works than don’t usually reuse art but do it exceptionally in cases like this to portray high speeds.

I agree with revision 2, but with it not applying to works that don’t reuse art.
 
ElJoaki5 said:
If the problem is that panels are being reused due to low quality and not as a representation of speed, then this should be a rule that only applies to works that reuse art. There are works than don’t usually reuse art but do it exceptionally in cases like this to portray high speeds.

I agree with revision 2, but with it not applying to works that don’t reuse art.
Click to expand...
Feel like that's fair, I'll add a caveat message in revision 2 about possible exceptions can be made to series that don't typically reuse art.
 
CatLover313 said:
Possible Revision 2: In the case of non-animated visual media, such as Comics, manga, and manhwa, the standards for slow motion are stricter. In this case, if a reference object with known speed can be visually confirmed to not have moved even 1 pixel, with multiple panels of the reference object not moving and preferably different angles of the attack being shown, one can figure out the timeframe, by saying that it must have been less than the timeframe that the object would have taken to move 1 pixel, only two panels is generally not enough to warrant the use of this method. A potential example to follow is the third example in this post. Furthermore, the object of interest needs to be faster than the object of reference. [However, if a series is known not to commonly reuse art, exceptions could be made with the multiple-panel usage requirement]
Click to expand...
I'm curious, would this make a feat like this unable to utilize the 1pxl method? The leg didn't moved a single inch in these two panels
 
LIFE_OF_KING said:
I'm curious, would this make a feat like this unable to utilize the 1pxl method? The leg didn't moved a single inch in these two panels
Click to expand...
Hmm, I haven't read CM, but if the series isn't known to reuse art (and if there isn't any anti-feats, though that's more of a CRT thing), it could be seen as slow motion instance.
 
CatLover313 said:
Hmm, I haven't read CM, but if the series isn't known to reuse art (and if there isn't any anti-feats, though that's more of a CRT thing), it could be seen as slow motion instance.
Click to expand...
the Manga doesnt seems to reuse the same art, for example in the first two pages of Chapter 136, the protagonist Denji, whos tired, has many panels where he seems to have the same immobile face expression, but if you look closely, his eye wrinkles and the strands of his hair slightly changes, the exact same panel isnt reused

Edit: related to slow mo calculations, snail speed for slow mo calculations is 0.00275 m/s or 0.001625 m/s? cuz i saw that in ´´references for common feats´´ used these 2 different snail speeds for 2 speed calcs, shouldnt it be one?
 
Breadbear83 said:
the Manga doesnt seems to reuse the same art, for example in the first two pages of Chapter 136, the protagonist Denji, whos tired, has many panels where he seems to have the same immobile face expression, but if you look closely, his eye wrinkles and the strands of his hair slightly changes, the exact same panel isnt reused

Edit: related to slow mo calculations, snail speed for slow mo calculations is 0.00275 m/s or 0.001625 m/s? cuz i saw that in ´´references for common feats´´ used these 2 different snail speeds for 2 speed calcs, shouldnt it be one?
Click to expand...
I see most “current slow mo manhwa” calcs using 0.00275 seconds, but it def something that should be decided by a CGM instead of my opinion.
 
Breadbear83 said:
the Manga doesnt seems to reuse the same art, for example in the first two pages of Chapter 136, the protagonist Denji, whos tired, has many panels where he seems to have the same immobile face expression, but if you look closely, his eye wrinkles and the strands of his hair slightly changes, the exact same panel isnt reused

Edit: related to slow mo calculations, snail speed for slow mo calculations is 0.00275 m/s or 0.001625 m/s? cuz i saw that in ´´references for common feats´´ used these 2 different snail speeds for 2 speed calcs, shouldnt it be one?
Click to expand...
I have made a recalc. I plan to make a revision soon

It looks like the 1pxl method is also not applicable since the scenes are way too different/inconsistent
 
New Vote Count:

Revision 1: 0

Revision 2: 5

Revision 3: 1

I was told that there might potentially be another vote from a staff, so going to wait a bit before asking anything else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Vzearr
[HELP] Crater Feats: Being In Motion During A Crater Panel
Replies
1
Views
664
Agnaa
Agnaa
KnightDark_990
Po moves so fast that the Five Furious stop in slow motion in mid-air.
Replies
7
Views
2K
Arkansalter2
Arkansalter2
SunDaGamer
Addressing Earthquake calcs from Meteor Impacts
2
Replies
45
Views
5K
Billybobjoe321
Billybobjoe321
SomebodyData
  • Locked
Calc Group Discussion: The Issue with Dragon Ball's Planetary Calculations
2
Replies
43
Views
4K
Dalesean027
Dalesean027
NeverForgett
Honkai Star Rail, Honkai Impact - Calculations/Speed
Replies
28
Views
2K
Voidnether
Voidnether
Back
Top