• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Ken Kaneki Vs Yuta Okkotsu & Yuji Itadori (Tokyo Ghoul Vs Jujutsu Kaisen)

Thing is, they are made of RC cells, which are akin to blood cells in the verse. They are very much a part of the body and therefore a part of the soul



I don't think that really matters. Sure, if it's disconnected, it's no longer part of him. But it should still hold his soul if they are still attached.

Kagune is literally considered an organ
By your logic, if I'm peeing and Toji walks by with SSK and cuts my urine stream, I'll die because that would be soul damage.
 
King of GOATS FRA

DFIkxKSwkE0EvJR9m3gb2n9sHc3_cPevW5gh5_Q4ddHza_tBNbpzV3ZNzzF3ffIlI7n-j9dqOdeDT0TkdQJ4QOES.jpg
I remember laughing so HARD when I first read this

I thought it was a meme translation at first 😭
 
By your logic, if I'm peeing and Toji walks by with SSK and cuts my urine stream, I'll die because that would be soul damage.
That's stramanning a bit

I did specify: " Sure, if it's disconnected, it's no longer part of him. But it should still hold his soul if they are still attached."

If the urine is in your body, then yeah, Toji one taps. If it's on the ground, no.
 
Soul damage is getting too wanked but then again we are talking about jjk fanbase. Would be easier to teach a headless chicken how to read.

Kaneki AP checks them FRA.
 
That's stramanning a bit

I did specify: " Sure, if it's disconnected, it's no longer part of him. But it should still hold his soul if they are still attached."

If the urine is in your body, then yeah, Toji one taps. If it's on the ground, no.
I used this obvious example to show that not every fluid that comes out of your body is part of your soul. Especially when the manga explicitly shows that the body is the core of life.

I would understand your logic if these were Kaneki's primary limbs, like Plastic Man, who stretches his arms and shapes them. But these are simply artificial limbs, and Kaneki creates new ones to replace the old ones.
 
Domains can be broken from the inside. It's just very hard because you are constantly being attacked by the sure-hit and the caster. The interior of the domain just upscales the caster's durability a lot, but that's it. Overcome that and you can shatter a little escape hole to get out. Gojo stated Sukuna could've broke out the domain by attacking the inside (Tho that was after he switched the exteriors weaker side with the interiors resilient side).
 
I would understand your logic if these were Kaneki's primary limbs, like Plastic Man, who stretches his arms and shapes them. But these are simply artificial limbs, and Kaneki creates new ones to replace the old ones.
This logic is understadable but I don't entirely buy it

But it doesn't affect the debate anyway, so let's end this part of the discussion.
 
Domains can be broken from the inside. It's just very hard because you are constantly being attacked by the sure-hit and the caster. The interior of the domain just upscales the caster's durability a lot, but that's it. Overcome that and you can shatter a little escape hole to get out. Gojo stated Sukuna could've broke out the domain by attacking the inside (Tho that was after he switched the exteriors weaker side with the interiors resilient side).
What is your voice?
 
at that point you're getting into a philosophical debate of what a soul is. can we even say kaneki has a soul?
I mean, I think we are all under that assumption, right?

This is just about to become another "No Chakra=No Genjutsu" meta huh....
 
What is your voice?
I said I don't care about the match-up and want JJK supporters to be able to focus on making the profiles better instead of us having to juggle a thousand matches. So put my vote as whoever is winning. If Kaneki is winning I'm fine to put my vote for him.
 
I mean, I think we are all under that assumption, right?

This is just about to become another "No Chakra=No Genjutsu" meta huh....
this isn't becoming anything, i'm just asking for your interpretation. i agree with nik here. if we assume that kaneki has a soul that can be targeted, the kagune wouldn't be part of his soul since it's basically just a genetic mutation that grants him what are essentially prosthetic limbs that he can plop out whenever he wants. i don't see the logic in saying its part of his soul.

but if you ask me, i think its weird enough we assume everyone from outside the verse has cursed energy, instead of equalizing it only to other energy systems like we do with every other verse.
 
Back
Top