All Might vs All For One but its different | 7-0-0

Afo: “If you wish to play pretend as All Might, I’ll treat you as if you were. Then, perhaps, you’ll realize that this isn’t just the game you see it as.”

Fight Takes place in Japan
Rampage Dark Might and Final War Arc AFO are being used

AFO: 7

Dark Might:

Icon:

Following

Rampage Dark Might is a good deal stronger than base All For One. Even in his Golden Age form, he could hold off three characters on AFO's tier without breaking a sweat. He becomes even more powerful after that, being able to match Shoto and Bakugo's Plus Ultra attacks.

As AFO needs to touch his opponent's real body to steal a Quirk, he cannot take Dark Might's Alchemy by touching the construct around his body. I'd also question if Search would work on him, since technically his real body is being covered. However, I'll go under the assumption that it does.

Dark Might's ranged attacks are far stronger and more numerous than anything All For One can do. All For One's only chance in base is to get close enough to use Spatial Manipulation, but that's about it. Impact Recoil can help lessen the impact from attacks, but Dark Might favors ranged attacks so it won't do anything to him.

All For One will need to use the Rewind Drug if he wants to overcome Dark Might.

At that point, Dark Might is kind of screwed. He cannot kill All For One and eventually he's going to take fatal damage, since AFO will be scaling far above him. Being able to one shot Gigantomachia is far greater than anything Dark Might has shown. All For One is going to kill him far more brutally than Izuku did.

While Dark Might is stronger at first, it's not a big enough gap that he could one shot All For One. There's nothing in his kit that can stop All For One from Rewinding.

Honestly, the only characters I think can beat Rewind All For One are peak Izuku and Tomura. I daresay even Prime All Might would fail, even if he's far stronger.

So yeah, All For One wins via Rewind Drug.

That cracked regen plus a power advantage and outright dura neg that's really hard to avoid because its borderline telekinesis seals the deal for me. AFO FRA.

Spatial manipulation go brrrr. AFO FRA

Bros first fight and he gets cooked. AFO FRA

AFO FRA

All for One FRA

Honestly I don't even think he'd need the rewind drug if he TRULY wanted to humiliate him given he could use his spatial warping quirk and turn him inside out (metaphorically I mean, in reality he'd just twist him like a used soda can), and he could just possess him by giving him All for One if all else fails, especially since Valdo seems to weak willed to put up much of a fight spiritually

Spatial Manipulation has limited range, and he never used it in his Weakened form to begin with.

AFO cannot use All For One on Dark Might until he gets through his rampage construct. If he does get through it, than Dark Might is already dead to begin with.

He could take his Quirk for giggles at this point, but that's irrelevant to his victory.

TheRustyOne said:

Spatial Manipulation has limited range, and he never used it in his Weakened form to begin with.

AFO cannot use All For One on Dark Might until he gets through his rampage construct. If he does get through it, than Dark Might is already dead to begin with.

He could take his Quirk for giggles at this point, but that's irrelevant to his victory.

Click to expand...

Fair enough

I think he would take his quirk though, just because he'd probably like to humiliate an all might impersonator

my goat AFO FRA

Silver Age Dark Might could OHKO Full Cowl Deku who's 42 Petatons
Golden Age Dark Might could toy with 3 characters all way stronger than that (Bakugo's Cluster could "sting" Complete Shigaraki who is as strong as prime All Might who is 2.54 Exatons, Deku is way stronger and Todoroki is comparable)
Rampage Mode Dark Might is even stronger and could contend with Bakugo and Todoroki who were both enraged beyond belief


All For One's calc puts him at 42 Petatons without the Rewind Drug, and 63 Petatons with the drug, as he's able to 1 shot Gigantomachia who's more threatening than multiple Near-High-Ends (which sounds incorrect, I feel like Prime AFO should scale to Prime All Might since he fought him but I digress)


I'm confused why so many people voted for All For One when Dark Might could 1 shot people on par with Pre-Rewind Drug All For One 2 transformations ago with a single punch. Yeah he has the rewind drug but he's legit getting knocked out before he has the chance to use it