Elden Ring Ratings Are Confusing

[RanaProGamer]

So ya boi has been pro-gaming and playing Elden Ring, so I checked out a lot of lore stuff and looked at the profiles for the God Tiers, and it got me scratching my head.

In Radagon's profile, he's rated as "At least Mountain level, possibly Large Star level to Multi-Solar System level (Able to fight against a late-game Tarnished, should at least be comparable or superior to Malenia, Blade of Miquella)".
However, when I checked Malenia's profile, she's rated as "At least Mountain level, possibly Large Star level (Was able to stalemate Prime Radahn in battle)", with Radhan only being High 4-C . So which is it exactly? Because even Rennala is listed as 4-A due to scaling to this Radagon.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Bruh who made Radagon's profile without approval

His planned rating was supposed to just be At least 7-A, possibly 4-A. His scaling is wrong.

 

[Liquid_Bigb0ss]

His planned rating was supposed to just be At least 7-A, possibly 4-A.

Besides removing the high 4-c stuff, I think resistances also need to be added to radagon. As well as “multiple-selves”, because radagon is marika…. but I also think Marika needs her own key on the profile as well. Might even be better to just save whatever what can even be used on the profile and scrap the rest of it.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Besides removing the high 4-c stuff, I think resistances also need to be added to radagon. As well as “multiple-selves”, because radagon is marika…. but I also think Marika needs her own key on the profile as well. Might even be better to just save whatever what can even be used on the profile and scrap the rest of it.

The profile should honestly be deleted. We were supposed to merge him with Queen Marika's profile.

 

[Liquid_Bigb0ss]

The profile should honestly be deleted. We were supposed to merge him with Queen Marika's profile.

makes sense. I agree with it being straight up deleted then.

 

[RanaProGamer]

The profile should honestly be deleted. We were supposed to merge him with Queen Marika's profile.

Marika doesn’t have a profile tho.

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Marika doesn’t have a profile tho.

That's my point. His page will just be merged with hers when she comes out.

 

[RanaProGamer]

That's my point. His page will just be merged with hers when she comes out.

Alright, and what of the ratings for the already existing profiles, do we keep them High 4-C or 4-A?

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Alright, and what of the ratings for the already existing profiles, do we keep them High 4-C or 4-A?

They're not changing