Homelander vs Homelander again (0-6-1)

[TegamiBachi25]

We can do Homelander vs Homelander since they're both 8-B again.

This is Comics 8-B Homelander vs Show 8-B Homelander. Speed is equalized and fight takes place on Earth.

Homelander:

Homelander 2: 6

Billy kills them both and we get a better ending for the show: 1

 

[DenzOnigiri]

Show Homelander winning this he's having higher calculated AP/Dura values, also possibly much deadlier Heat Vision, and ability like Rage Power will significant boost his physical stats/ability output.

 

[Doggo]

Show Homelander is arguably more skilled too ig

 

[Random-Helper323]

20 tons vs >>14.8 tons. AP might not be so different. Show is more skilled and has better heat vision, Comic is way more resilient and has better senses.

 

[Fallen_Angelicx]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Black_Noir_(Dynamite_Entertainment)

Should've done Black Noir instead for more irony

 

[Omegas03]

They both upscale a lot from their value

So TVlander has a small AP advantage, not just that, but he's vastly better at H2H combat. Comic Homelander only shot is to use that super yelling but he can't beat TVlander cqc cuz 1) he's buns at fighting (even more so than his TV version so imagine) and he'd actually a glass cannon. TVlander easily keeps up with 2 supes nearly his tier without heavy damage. Comiclander was ripped out fighting a peer of him in a minutes lol.

My vote goes to TV version

 

[Pyro9278]

TVlander FRA

 

[Rex_Eckles]

TV FRA.

 

[JustANormalLemon]

TVlander fra

 

[C2_of_Omegon]

AP/DURA gap is 1.3x which is basically not even worth talking about on it's own, TBH. Luckily, we've got more than that to consider.

TVlander has better CQC skills and Rage Power.

Comlander has sheer, bloody endurance.

I need to emphasize Comiclander's death because of the circumstances. Comic Noir was NOT Comlander's peer. He was his SUPERIOR. Despite that, Comlander devastated him on his way out. I mean look at it. Comlander kept fighting even after his jaw got taken off and given that Noir was still clutching bits of him afterward...it's very likely that he had to tear Comlander apart to really kill him. Not too mention, Noir, even in that state, survived a barrage of anti-supe weaponry, even if he was on his last legs. If that's the kind of damage comic supes on that level can endure, TVlander has some serious work ahead.

I think that TVlander will win the fight. His higher level of competence in HtH and his Rage Power will give him that edge but Comlander's endurance is just out of this world. Plus he's gonna fight like an animal to the end. That won't let him win but I believe that it will allow Comlander to do so much damage before he goes down that he ultimately drags TVlander to the grave with him. I understand if people don't agree with that but that's my view.

Hot take, I'm aware, but I gonna go inconclusive.

 

[O0DSF0o]

Tv fra

 

[TegamiBachi25]

counted

 

[Doggo]

TV FRA

 

[AThe1412]

TV FRA.

TVlander easily keeps up with 2 supes nearly his tier without heavy damage. Comiclander was ripped out fighting a peer of him in a minutes lol.

As Omegon pointed out, Noir was stronger. Comiclander still managed to deal a ton of damage to him which allowed the military and Butcher to finish him off.

 

[Omegas03]

The gap sure as hell wasn't even noticeable because Noir pulled out an extreme diff win, might as well say they were (almost) equal.

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

Voting for TV HL FRA

 

[C2_of_Omegon]

The gap sure as hell wasn't even noticeable because Noir pulled out an extreme diff win, might as well say they were (almost) equal.

Like how the two are basically equals in a physical sense here? The starting gap between TV and Comic only really exists on paper without factoring in the Rage Boost and even that's seems to be a burst of strength not a sustained effort. Even with it, given how close their baselines are, it's not going to be this overwhelming advantage. Factoring it in, well now it's back to being Noir vs Comlander but TVlander doesn't have the ability to keep functioning from taking that level of damage nor has he ever fought someone who can.

 

[Omegas03]

Like how the two are basically equals in a physical sense here? The starting gap between TV and Comic only really exists on paper without factoring in the Rage Boost and even that's seems to be a burst of strength not a sustained effort. Even with it, given how close their baselines are, it's not going to be this overwhelming advantage. Factoring it in, well now it's back to being Noir vs Comlander but TVlander doesn't have the ability to keep functioning from taking that level of damage nor has he ever fought someone who can.

will Comic Homelander actually be able to tear TVlander apart like that in an actual fight?

Say what you want, but I always thought that Comiclander may be as determined as you want but both him and Noir lasting like 30 seconds (not really sure about the timeframe itself, but it sure was short) in that fight and getting ripped apart also suggests they're both glass cannons for their AP/dura values.

TVlander can actually fight prolongued fights with peers.

 

[Funniest_person_alive]

Show homelander win

 

[TegamiBachi25]

votes counted and should be grace

 

[Funniest_person_alive]

Has grace passed?

 

[TegamiBachi25]

Has grace passed?

Yeah, I haven’t added it yet