>Lesser things could harm him before at least twice before this.
Yes welcome to JoJo where the human characters' durability fluctuate at a drop of a hat. You can think of two times, I can think of several where he tanked blows above what you're thinking. The existence of low-end feats doesnt invaliate the higher end feats, consistency isnt an argument here given there's more high ends than low-ends.
>Context wise he got a lot of broken bones from this, which was even ignored.
He only got 3 broken bones, saying a lot is exagerating, and other than the rib, the collar bone fracture actually doesnt look that bad, arm fracture is somewhere in the middle. He actually walked out of the second kick pummel that knocked him through a building and like half a km without broken bones (probably longer given the Qasr El Nil Bridge is nearly 2km long), make of that what you will. Also getting broken bones doesnt change the fact he tanked em even if he took damage, the punches broke some bones but that was about it, he wasnt one shot, killed, crippled, etc by those blows. I mean just look at poor old Kak, one punch and he was dead. You could make mention that the first pummel broke some bones but that doesnt effect the other pummels he took nor the fact he survived said pummel even if he did take damage and honestly kinda just dealth with it.
>Other chracters do have a more consistent durability on this level...Jotaro isn't one of them.
I don't know about that, Jotaro is treated as one of the more durable Crusaders in almost every situation where they're all in danger.
>.Jotaro needs a key for his Part 6 self, where he was weak and we don't know what his stats would really look like.
True, but as you said yourself, we don't know what said stats really look like. All we know is he's stronger than Stone Free and can kill Pucci if given a chance. Seems kinda counterintuitive to give him a key where we don't know how strong he is.
> In his AP: "Upon gaining Time Stop, Star Platinum easily snapped both of DIO's legs with a single kick and ultimately obliterated him with a punch."
I mean, he did easily snap both his legs, you can't deny that, Jotaro didn't even seem to be going all out in that specific instance, yes he was mad and yes he was using more power than usual because of it but, he still easily snapped his legs like nothing. Hell earlier in the fight he smashed The World's hand too, prior to getting peak mad he also punched a hole clean through The World. And he did destroy him with one punch, also no, there was no concentrate all of his power into one punch thing. I just checked, all that was said and I quote.
All I have to do is blast Star Platinum's fist into him in those two seconds!
Nothing about concentrating power or anything, just that in order to kill DIO, he has to have Star Platinum ohko him in his time stop window. I mean obviously it was a full power punch but... What's your point? Star Platinum still obliterated him with one punch, even if hypothetically he poured all his Stand power into that one single punch, that would still be his AP.
>Both things need to be clarified, we could even add DIO being weaker in his left side.
You could make a mention of SP being pissed off when he did those feats but i dont think that'd change much given he's explicitly said to be the strongest Stand ever, even more so than The World by wog, multiple times and the breaking Dio's legs was done, while pissed off, in a moment he was purposely ******* with Dio and it seemed somewhat casual at that, going by Star Platinum's expression. Plus the concentrate all his power into one punch was never actually said, at all, I checked multiple translations. And yeah Dio was weaker on his left side prior to all the things you just mentioned. HIGH DIO isn't weaker in his left side, that was fixed upon drinking Joestar Blood, he's actually significantly stronger than his former self and is properly fused with his body with all previous detriments gone.
As for the whole him getting beat up by dudes in a jewelry store, that's really not a good example given that's such a low-end feat that if you honestly wanna use that as evidence it'd mean that Jotaro unironically breaks his legs and arms everytime he himself throws a punch given his own physical feats, and the fact he'd of been splattered by The World, much like those fodder the Pillar Men killed or gored like Kakyoin was by a casual, weaker punch, from The World, him getting tossed through a building would have killed too given he had zero protection from Star Platinum in that instance (as well as the kick that sent him through that building), the several blows he's taken from Stands that he managed to tank. tbh that's Goku 40 ton anti-feat tier of evidence, ie it's a case of blatant downplay. Or Hulk getting beaten by a Gorilla, that's a good one too. Or Silver Surfer getting mugged, **** that's actually funny, that's some Thanoscoptor tier quality.
Anyway all I got from this was you think Jotaro's durability should be lower, but given that for every low end feat a feat drastically higher exists, the best I'm gonna agree with is this.
Likely Building Level (Survived several blows from The World albeit with some broken bones)
or whatever we treat the world as. That should be the optimal course of action as it dictates it isnt entirely concrete and there is room for variation but also isnt being completely ignorant of the multitude of drastically higher durability feats.
As for Star Platinum, him being pissed off or calm doesnt change his AP (Well it does, what I meant is it wouldnt change what we list him as). You could clarify that he was pissed off when he broke Dio's legs but the whole concentrated punch thing simply isnt even real. It was a punch, a strong one, and a pissed one, but he didnt concentrate all his Stand energy into said punch nor power, that was never said.
