Konoha size removal

[M3X_2.0]

I’ve been reading the past two threads about the size of the village and I’m actually surprised that no one noticed the issue I’m gonna show below:

The scan they used for the calc is massively inconsistent with every other Konoha display, and not only in size but more importantly in architecture. The scan they used has the walls of Konoha engulfing the Forest Of Death and basically a lot of landscape that is obviously not inside the village, but it’s present in it’s outskirts.

Konoha is a village that’s architecturally structured in a circular shape protected by walls, and inside these walls are the houses and everything. Forest Of Death, empty landscapes etc are not inside the walls as that scan make it seem. Actually, pre-Boruto Konoha ends with the Hokage monument, and that scan would make Konoha have a lot more beyond the monument.

And there is another reason the size should be removed altogether: It’s useless. Konoha size is not used for anything other than one hypothetical calc. The only thing it brought was pointless discussions and time wasting for everyone involved. The only feat that uses the village size is that one Shinra Tensei where Pain completely pulverized the village hundreds of meters down, and that’s not even calculated!!!!

 

[Uzil-IVrei]

I'd say I agree with this, and idk if its just me but the last image is not showing, its just blank, i think its an error

 

[ItsMeat]

I'd say I agree with this, and idk if its just me but the last image is not showing, its just blank, i think its an error

It's empty for me too, lol.

Also, agree with the proposal

 

[Saqphire]

Damn @Foriaa my initial calc of Konoha was right all along

Agree with the thread

 

[YmTheSuper]

Yeah I agree. I was already planning on making this eventually. I will probably drop some more arguments to support the size removal tomorrow if there isn't universal agreement. (Also doesn't this removal affect the KN6 calc even if indirectly since it relies on the size of the forest and since we see that same attack in relation to the width and height of the crater that's the same size as the village, rather than affecting no calcs?)

 

[DavidTPPM]

Also doesn't this removal affect the KN6 calc even if indirectly since it relies on the size of the forest and since we see that same attack in relation to the width and height of the crater that's the same size as the village, rather than affecting no calcs?

No, actually not. The inconsistent thing here is Konoha itself, not the forest.

I'd even say the explosion seems to be purposely shown near the forest so we have a point of reference to signify that it's massive

 

[M3X_2.0]

Also doesn't this removal affect the KN6 calc even if indirectly since it relies on the size of the forest and since we see that same attack in relation to the width and height of the crater that's the same size as the village, rather than affecting no calcs?

Not really since it's not dependant on the village but the FoD, which I'm not contesting and I don't plan to.

 

[Testarossa002]

The only feat that uses the village size is that one Shinra Tensei where Pain completely pulverized the village hundreds of meters down, and that’s not even calculated!!!!

Because it doesn't scale to punches = useless

There's one other calc that sorts of uses it (Lee and 6 others breaking a meteor in half) but that's not calculated anyway

i agree

 

[ichimojii]

Agreed

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Agreed

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

Looks good, I agree.

 

[ichimojii]

Not really since it's not dependant on the village but the FoD, which I'm not contesting and I don't plan to.

Well FoD has to be downgraded to since it's clearly smaller then knonoha. I will probably make a thread on it if no one else will

 

[M3X_2.0]

Well FoD has to be downgraded to since it's clearly smaller then knonoha. I will probably make a thread on it if no one else will

It doesn’t have to, how are you gonna downgrade something with multiple size statements?

Can we please leave FoD alone in this thread?

 

[Uzil-IVrei]

I'm more than sure the Forest of death has a confirmed size of 10km, unless I'm remembering wrong.

 

[M3X_2.0]

It has a confirmed size of 10km from the gates to the tower, that's the radius. The Forest Of Death has a total of 20km in diameter.

 

[Damage3245]

I've been against the current accepted size of Konoha from the moment it was proposed. I agree with its removal.

 

[Dalesean027]

This is fine

 

[M3X_2.0]

Given how simple this is I suppose it can be closed. I've removed the calc from the verse page.

 

[Dalesean027]

Done