• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Shinobu Oshino's AP revision

Status
Not open for further replies.

PrettyFearMachine

VS Battles
Retired
4,868
1,314
Apparently there's a statement in Monogatari, which implies that Shinobu can destroy the planet.

"Well, doing away with a shrine might be not enough of a miracle -- but 'twas a sufficient display of power. Though if I truly made use of my power, it would be the earth I could make disappear, not a simple shrine."

I propose changing her Kiss-Shot Ace-whatever key's tier to "At least Low 6-B, possibly 5-B".

EDIT: Apparently Kiss-shot's feat was recalced at "Country level+", so her tier should actually be "At least 6-B, possibly 5-B".
 
I'm neutral on this change, for now.
 
Iirc Shinobu had also stated that she could run across the whole planet in a second or something (Someone should clarify this since my memory is not that strong).
 
-BANLK- said:
Iirc Shinobu had also stated that she could run across the whole planet in a second or something (Someone should clarify this since my memory is not that strong).
I don't remember seeing this, but you have known about a few untranslated novel things (such as human Shinobu) before I have. Given the scale of the series I wouldn't be surprised if she had that sort of statement. I'll add it to the profile if I ever see it.
 
Eh probably

The Low 6-B feat is probably higher, but I'd need to figure out Antarctica in all of it's stuff in order to really tackle it
 
DMUA said:
Eh probably
The Low 6-B feat is probably higher, but I'd need to figure out Antarctica in all of it's stuff in order to really tackle it
The issue is that the light novel says that Antarctica was almost destroyed, so only the ice part of it was taken into account, for safety's sake.

But you can go ahead and try to recalc it if you want.
 
DMUA said:
Eh probably

The Low 6-B feat is probably higher, but I'd need to figure out Antarctica in all of it's stuff in order to really tackle it
I've done a recalc of it which takes into account the proper masses and fragmentation values, but I'm sticking with Low 6-B since it was "almost destroyed" from that jump, not completely fragmented over the entire landmass.
 
@Agnaa

What results did the recalc give you? Maybe we could arrange something like this:

"At least Small Country level to Your recalc, possibly Planet level"?
 
It doesn't even have a calc on the page

If I got the radius of Antarctica, we could probably use near total fatalities to estimate the results
 
RebubleUselet said:
@Agnaa

What results did the recalc give you? Maybe we could arrange something like this:

"At least Small Country level to Your recalc, possibly Planet level"?
1.14e23 joules, Country level.

Quick, dirty, and messy calc writeup here​
apparently arctic ice has a fragmentation value of 1.8J/cc
Antarctica's average altitude is 2.5km, and the ice sheet has an average height of 1.9km, meaning landmass has an average height of 0.6km

apparently the land mass should have a fragmentation value of 8 J/cc

Antarctica has an area of 14,000,000 km^2

8,400,000 km^3 of land, 26,600,000 km^3 of ice

8.4e21 cm^3 of land, 2.6e22 cm^3 of ice

6.72e22 joules for the land

4.68e22 joules for the ice

1.14e23 joules in total
 
DMUA said:
It doesn't even have a calc on the page

If I got the radius of Antarctica, we could probably use near total fatalities to estimate the results
This is the calc that gave Low 6-B. Using near total fatalities sounds like a good way of going about it.
 
Yeah, it would better reflect nearly destroying it.

Of course, as per getting the radius of Antarctica
 
DMUA said:
Yeah, it would better reflect nearly destroying it.

Of course, as per getting the radius of Antarctica
Apparently The shortest radius is 1500km, and the largest is 3000km.

Sample mathematics questions (for school exams and such) seem to put the radius of Antarctica at around 2000km-2100km.
 
Hmm

Alright

((1500/.28)^3)/2 is 76872266763.848 Kilotons, 76.8722667638483 Teratons, Country level+
 
Ehhhhh

I'm lazy and this isn't my verse so I'll gladly let Agnaa steal the credit
 
now you post it on the calc evaluations thread
 
Alright, so if the calc gets accepted, then the rating is going to be "At least 6-B, possibly 5-B", right?
 
You should preferably ask some administrators and discussion moderators to comment here.
 
Is the translation legit? If it is, are we sure this is not just a textbook hyperbole?

I would prefer the current rating of "likely far higher" given the justification on the page and this statement, but I don't mind a possibly planet level rating if the statement is not hyperbole.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top