RotofBots said:
Medaka, in my opinion, is actually quite a bland protagonist. In what way do you ever expect any battle with her to have any sort of tension? There simply is none, because you always know she'll win. It's established from the beginning that she'll always win. 194 chapters just to see Medaka win over and over again by asspulls, Deus ex machina or even bending the tenets of the narrative itself to her favor. She was made to be this formulaic and boring by design and that's quite saddening. Medaka has nothing. She does things for the sake of people. For the sake of the reader. She does what the reader wants her to do all the time. The entire concept of this character is so inoffensive; so formulaic; so safe, that you never expect anything out of her than what you always would. She'll never do anything stupid, or screw up, or say anything out of character. She exists for the sake of filling in the protagonist slot.
Sorry for the rant >_>
slight spoiler for medaka box below ( don't know how to use spoiler tag on forum sorry)
medaka interest as a characther never was about her battle strengh because as you said , she pretty much op and will always win ( cept when she don't) , it was about her place in the world and her unability to understand people because she is so OP .
at two years old she already ridicule the greatest minds of the planet and can do everything physical with extreme ease .
The result of all that is that at two years old , she already ponder "why the **** am i even alive for? this chapter sums up a good deal :https://www.***********.net/medaka-box/51
at the end of the chapter , you learn what she choose as a reason to continue living , which sound quite good on paper.
only for the manga , many chapters later , to shit all over it and make you realise how bullshit and toxic that was
i don't like medaka box characthers or story because they are op or do good fights , i love them because the characthers are awesome and it made me realise how so many shonen tropes that are considered normals ( like born geniuses ,OP characthers , the eternal side kick , assuming the main characther is always right just because it won a fight ... ) can in fact be so very toxic for the mental development of the person
i love medaka box because it perfectly deconstruct the shonen manga tropes that i grew bored with and do it with awesome characthers