- 15,317
- 22,642
I already said it, Transdimensional is physical stuff, a physical theory in real life, you link it to a google answer isn't gonna make it being literal concept in the verse.How are they unrelated if the transdimensional space created is literally formed by the "unrelated" stuff in question?
So Frequencies only carries a trace of human's will if it is concentrated in a single place rather than being human's will itself? Pretty much disqualify for AE1 because rather than being human's will itself, Frequencies only carry a trace, and that trace will only appear when Frequencies are concentrated in a single place mean if it is not concentrated, human will will not appearWhat verse context are you referring to? I think you're focusing a little too much on the Shorekeeper scan, I never actually used the Shorekeeper scan itself to support the AE. The AE support literally comes from these abstractions themselves not the Shorekeeper scan at all, though it is in of itself a form of support.
It's directly stated that when frequencies are concentrated in a single place, it's possible their reverberations can still carry traces of human will with Rover even saying that he once saw a friend reconcile with a dead friend inside of a Sonoro precisely because of this fact which is in fact it's own quest. Furthermore spirits/souls are literally made of frequencies (everything is as I have already shown), the people who underwent the Fisalia families trials were also able to use their emotions to form a Sonoro.
A Sonoro was able to instantly draw out Carlotta's memories, experiences, and even passing thoughts to create itself. With Carlotta's Mirror Self being a product of Carlotta's own memories, desires and fantasies, who is able to turn the Sonoro into her domain, this is literally all textbook definition of abstractions which is the ability to "embody an abstraction, such as a concept, thought, or information, and being immortal thanks to it". Officially taken from the AE page itself, we also have even more support in the same quest here wherein Carlotta who can erase the existence of frequencies, is unable to directly kill Mirror Carlotta as a result of the Sonoro. Which perfectly fits in line with AE1 that directly states the following:
"Exists purely as an abstraction. These characters lack a true physical form, and affecting them requires the ability to affect directly the abstraction itself, because eventual physical manifestations are merely avatars."
Being soul/spirit is incorporeality, which i think i accepted them
Can create, produce stuffs from abstraction like memories, thoughts, etc.... isn't gonna make those stuffs. You linked to "embodies abstraction" part in AE page to prove your point, but that is AE2, if you are arguing those stuffs created from memories, thoughts, experiences being AE2 then i have no problem with it, but those aren't AE1 feats
So all and all, i still disagree with AE1, Incorporeality?, i'm fine with it