• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
1,642
Reaction score
602
I was told the verse had TV show-only supporters and I trusted they'd do any of this as I wanted to focus on the comic side
1.1 - TV Viltrumite-tier upgrade
Mark's moon jump has been calculated and accepted and it's the highest AP feat yet.

To begin with, why did it take so long to name his keys after the seasons ? It should be Season 1 | Season 2 | Season 3 this last one is going to be about the same for a about 2 more seasons

Mark performed this feat during his training after Season 2 and before Donald details his growth at the beginning of Season 3 so while we can't quite use the multiplier for this it's safe to say he should be stronger than this by that point. On that topic, here's a brief rundown on why the multipliers aren't that straight-forward to be used anyway
Less than triple strength and double speed increases and he goes from getting neg-diffed, no-sold and statued to being able to beat her? To minorly scrutinise those numbers in relation to Donald's statement is more than fair. Even though it's likely 99% accurate, I'd say bone and muscle density scans would probably be a less accurate arbiter of stats than straight up testing with weights and measuring speed/durability in-universe.
Regardless, despite his growth in strength upgraded Reanimen ganging up on him could still noticeably damage him while he couldn't fight back. Later on, during the Invincible War an alternate Invincible finds himself in the same situation and gets absolutely destroyed, however he was still strong enough to one-shot them and him dying to that leads Donald to say that he "definitely wasn't as strong" as Prime Invincible so it stands to reason that by the end of Season 3 the Reanimen + Equilibrium-disrupting frequency strategy wouldn't be as effective as it was at the beginning if at all. At the end of the season Mark endured a brutal beatdown and managed to put down a guy who they drop like 5 times in the episode could take Omni-Man out, so they're relative to each other right now, so Season 3 Mark and all major viltrumites so far should be "At least High 6-A", as well as Battle Beast, Hail Mary, Allen Post-Recovery and...
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
1.2 - TV Immortal/Season 2 Mark scaling

Continuing this thread where about three mods agreed Immortal really shouldn't scale to Omni-Man. He's been killed way too many times in pretty gory ways to say he consistently scales and he even conceded to being weaker than Mark mid-Season 2 prior to all his training and the events of Season 3

As said above Mark and Omni-Man are comparable to each other right now. Future Immortal, who shouldn't be any weaker than before and should in fact be going all out as he wants to give Mark no choice but to kill him, did quite literally nothing to him and was killed rather easily, when it should've been S1E7 all over again if he consistently scaled (which also has to be pointed out that the only lasting damage Immortal left with all the struggle were bloodshot eyes).

Most arguments for him still scaling is him drawing blood from them but the series is infamous for how everyone can take hits from everyone no matter how big the gap is. Most egregious examples are Titan, Monster Girl and Robot harming Battle Beast and this latest season Capes' members drawing blood from Mark. Honorary mention to the Maulers being able to draw blood from Oliver when he can literally rip them apart

A higher tier can still be argued for him tho, as he could still be reasonably above all the weaponry Earth is capable of producing over being pretty much unkillable in the future, such as these bombs, which also could barely hurt viltrumites. Basically:
Immortal: At least High 6-A, likely far higher
I'd rather a "likely far higher" than "At most viltrumite value" because, seriously, Omni-Man can easily kill them with one attack, that's way too much for a clear cut downscale. Another argument that was brought up was that it's normal for comparable characters in the series to gore each other like that, but even then, while Lucan and Vidor were messed up pretty bad by Nolan they still dealt way more damage to him than Immortal ever could on his own and he couldn't outright punch through them with a single attack and split them in half.
Also like, if you were to put him in a match how much lower than the viltrumite value should his opponent be to not rip him apart after getting in a couple hits lol. He barely has anything else going for him in terms of abilites.

Sort of related to that, the "Likely Country level with bombs" should be removed, because it is just bombs and they should be featured in a Future Immortal key and not as it currently is, except that would be really redundant as the only difference between them is those bombs that he only uses in a flashback and he upscales anyway. Overall pointless addition

In the thread above it was also mentioned that downgrading Immortal would also mean downgrading Season 2 Mark, and looking at the current calculations and fights I'm now inclined to agree. He should still downscale from Nolan as, despite the good fight he put up against Thula, by the end of their fight he was notoriously much more injured than her in a series where common attacks can leave a permanent nose bleed throughout a fight, and she was promptly oneshotted by Omni-Man. The main argument for her being relative to Nolan is the fact that she was sent (alongside other 2) to detain him, but that's not necessarily the case as it's simply about who's available at the time (there's only about 50 viltrumites left), for example one of the viltrumites executioners could fend off both Nolan AND Allen (who's notably stronger than Anissa, who in turn stomped Season 2 Mark) and he wasn't sent to Thraxa also we'll get a scene precisely showcasing viltrumites do vary greatly in strength

So Mark's Season 2 key should reflect Immortal's and mention he upscales
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
1.3 - LS scaling
Following upon the mentions of downscaling and the proposed scaling above for Season 2 Mark and Immortal, Immortal's LS would be downgraded to "At least Class G, likely far higher", same for Season 2 Mark, whose "At least Class T, possibly Class Z" would be moved to his Season 3 key
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
2. Removing Rage Power (and some other abilities)
To begin with the ability itself got a revision to clarify it as a user tried to argue for it for a character getting angry then pushing someone off of them who was previously restraining them, which is literally what's happening in the current justification for Mark having it.

What even is the logic for Mark having it and not other viltrumites ? Robert Kirkman himself debunks their biology being any different

Was able to stagger the likes of Omni-Man and made him bleed a little
Refer to what I said above of everyone harming each other in this series
That isn't Rage Power, that's just not holding back.

While we're at it, these are other abilities that have no reason to be:
  • Supernatural Willpower (Can keep fighting even after suffering severe injuries. He refuses to back down even when fighting enemies much stronger than himself)
That's not Supernatural Willpower, that's just the standard stamina that comes with his viltrumite physiology inb4 Supernatural Willpower for all viltrumites
  • Acrobatics (Hypermobility, All-Terrain Mobility, & Self-Momentum; Can perform complex acrobatics and flight maneuvers)
Acrobatics is for maneuvers physically performed with the body and he's literally never done any of those. I'm assuming it's because of these scenes but those are just flight tricks
Sequids control people by penetrating their skin, that's why everyone with super strength is immune to them, not some kind of biological resistance viltrumites happen to have

Sort of related to Mark, Red Rush has this in his profile:
And Mark pulls a similar feat, except apparently none of these give Afterimage creation, so it should be removed from Red Rush's profile
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
2. TV Low tiers re-scaling
These profiles are so bad where to even start ?
Rex Splode
Let's start with his physicals, whose justifications are really bad
Took a beating from Monster Girl with little to no notable injuries
He literally got his teeth punched out, face disfigured and suit all messed up
Can survive large explosions including his own which should be somewhat comparable to attacks from his arm
They're not somewhat comparable, they're not comparable at all. His arm cannon oneshotted a guy who was barely scratched by all his other explosions, it's far above all his arsenal, that's why he says he should lead with it.
Also, seriously, who's the guy who applied this because how could you miss the circular scaling ? He's physically 9-A because of the arm cannon's calculation and the logic that it's equiparable to his other explosives (which they aren't), except those same explosives are also rated Tier 6 over oneshotting Komodo Dragon and Octoboss (scaling them to instances where Mark and Immortal where very much holding back). WHAT ? Which is it ? Shouldn't he be Tier 6 physically then ?

Here we have two instances of him tanking his own explosions point-blank so these should be calculated and used instead

Either that or all these other instances of him being near explosions should be properly calculated, whichever the case. And, he should be given Damage Boost of course.
I don't know what rating could be given to his coins/bars so I'd like some input on that

Shapesmith would also be affected by this, which by the way, why does he even have a 9-C lower end ? He can take hits from someone who can easily rip apart Rex Splode and Dupli-Kate, he should just be whatever the above yields

Powerplex
How tf do you screw such an easy profile ? His whole deal is enery absorption, which was then enhanced by the discs. It should be: Varies, up to viltrumite value
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
Miscellanous
War Woman, Red Rush and Martian Man profiles were made out of nowhere

First, War Woman performs about the same as Immortal, if not a bit worse
Small Country level, likely far higher (Withstood blows from Omni-Man during their fight)
Easily overpowered and borderline knocked out in that clip lol. I wouldn't mind leaving her stats as "Comparable to The Immortal"

Second, if I get it right Red Rush is rated like that as the current Omni-Man calc is really close to base Low 6-B and High 6-C+ is the next best for downscaling so I'm not sure where he would end up with this upgrade. I disagree he's that strong anyway, if he had anywhere near those stats he would've staggered and even beaten the Mauler Twins on his own instead of being relegated to evacuating civilians and only joining in when they're already being defeated, tho they are being affected by his attacks, so perhaps "Possibly 7-A" ? He doesn't really have showings besides the fight with Omni-Man, and that's more meant to showcase he's so fast he can progressively deal damage while being much weaker rather than him being anywhere close to Omni-Man

Third, I could see Martian Man measuring up Durability-wise but certainly not on AP lol, he would've joined in to attack Omni-Man if that was the case instead of acting like a rubber band, also, same deal as with Red Rush, he would've solo'd the operation if that was the case. Best I can think of is his tank throw is properly calculated for AP, and for his durability "At least High 6-A, likely far higher", if not outright the viltrumite value

On a secondary note, Allen and The Maulers got an "At least 7-A" over their fights with Mark. Allen should probably stay 7-A, since he's unquantifiably above Mark and Nolan thinks he's strong enough to take him at that point. The Maulers could get upgraded to High 7-A since they could draw blood from s2 Mark who should be significantly above his 7-A feat at this point (and the difference is less than 1.2x)
  • Agree: Maverick_Zero_X, LephyrTheRevanchist
  • Disagree:
  • Neutral:
 
Last edited:
Refer to Robert Kirkman's video
All Kirkman said was that Viltrumites also have adrenaline and powerscaling isn't really important in the grand scheme of things

In a similar vein, all humans do have adrenaline and can get stronger with rage, but only people with noticeable showcases of a "berserker mode" would be granted that power. And Mark's rage power is demonstrably noticeable since he can 180 a stomp fight
 
Tentatively, the proposals of the opening post seem reasonable, from what I've read, but I'd like to know what other Staff Members & Knowledgeable Members think.
 
All Kirkman said was that Viltrumites also have adrenaline and powerscaling isn't really important in the grand scheme of things

In a similar vein, all humans do have adrenaline and can get stronger with rage, but only people with noticeable showcases of a "berserker mode" would be granted that power. And Mark's rage power is demonstrably noticeable since he can 180 a stomp fight
He says that to clarify Nolan's statement of Mark's rage and adrenaline allowing him to beat Conquest, explaining it's more of a general thing rather than exclusive to him due to his biology like many people say

And regarding the Machine Head fight, I also briefly discussed it here. Taking it at face value everyone involved in this fight would scale to Mark's values...except not at all. Taking all their showings into account these guys are not anywhere near Mark's level physically to say he needed a rage boost that enhances his regular stength to beat them
image.png
image.png
image.png

His Rage Power couldn't one-shot a guy who was defeated by Shrinking Rae and gave up fighting Bulletproof, so it stands to reason that, again, that was more of Mark simply not holding back in that moment rather than Rage Power
 
Last edited:
Tentatively, the proposals of the opening post seem reasonable, from what I've read, but I'd like to know what other Staff Members & Knowledgeable Members think.
Dude, I messaged one, saw that he was indeed looking at the thread and still didn't comment anything 💀
 
If it's been rejected before there must be reasons.
Hm, what has been rejected before ? If you're talking about the Immortal downgrade thread, that was left inconclusive and even then about 3 mods agreed he should be

I'm simply bringing it up because Immortal hasn't been that tough for a while. It may be worth refering to Kirkman's interview again as he’s of the mind that writing characters as if they’re strictly stronger or weaker than each other is limiting. It was simply more dramatic for the story for Immortal to get his licks back against the guy who murdered his team even if said guy punched a whole through him with one punch, there's no more need for that so he's now being outdone by characters comparable to Nolan and even below him.
 
The only issue i got is that we see red rush's punches on omni man, and they were individually dealing visible damage there in the close up shot

The mauler twin's are a bit of a issue, but i'm pretty sure even immortal and war woman didn't one shot them either
 
He says that to clarify Nolan's statement of Mark's rage and adrenaline alloing him to beat Conquest, explaining it's more of a general thing rather than exclusive to him due to his biology like many people say
Yeah but Mark is the only one to use it to a high enough level to qualify as an ability

As for the fight against Machine Goons, I don't really see the problem Mark is losing because Holds-Back-Man™ rage boosts and destroys all of them before getting backhanded by BB. I'd just say it's a combination of both, since Mark is very clearly stops holding back... when he's very angry which is what Berserker mode is for

Edit: I'd like to reiterate a bit, I think Mark's "rage power" should just be compiled with his no-holding back rating and they should be treated as the same thing
 
The only issue i got is that we see red rush's punches on omni man, and they were individually dealing visible damage there in the close up shot

The mauler twin's are a bit of a issue, but i'm pretty sure even immortal and war woman didn't one shot them either
Red rush having an at most High 6-A (or Low 6-B) rating wouldn't be a far stretch.
 
Last edited:
good chunk of this is aight but there's a few lil details I'd like ironed out first it's 3am tho and I spent all day doing manual labor so im ******* out now ill reply tomorrow
 
As for the fight against Machine Goons, I don't really see the problem Mark is losing because Holds-Back-Man™ rage boosts and destroys all of them before getting backhanded by BB. I'd just say it's a combination of both, since Mark is very clearly stops holding back... when he's very angry which is what Berserker mode is for
The problem is that the main argument for this scene being Rage Power is "Stomped enemies that were giving him problems before" implying they're on par with him but their interactions with characters other than Mark show they're incredibly fraudulent. Accidentally found another clip where they are overwhelmed by regular GDA soldiers lol

I have no doubt that if TV Tether Tyrant and Kursk had profiles now they'd be 7-A and Class G
 
Last edited:
The only issue i got is that we see red rush's punches on omni man, and they were individually dealing visible damage there in the close up shot

The mauler twin's are a bit of a issue, but i'm pretty sure even immortal and war woman didn't one shot them either
Red rush having an at most High 6-A (or Low 6-B) rating wouldn't be a far stretch.
Immortal and War Woman are holding back against them. The thing is Red Rush also has his blitzing speed that's on at all times, paired with such strength then it wouldn't have made sense to relegate him to support. He's just not meant to be that impressive AP-wise
 
Last edited:
I have no doubt that if TV Tether Tyrant and Kursk had profiles now they'd be 7-A and Class G
Tether Tyrant and Magmaniac (also Kursk) weren't like punching Mark to hurt him, they were all using their "non-physical" abilities (TT's tethers, Magmaniac's magma, and Kursk's electricity)
So like, they're durability is obviously human level, but they have up to holding back Mark level abilities

And like I said in my edit, I think we should just combine the holdsback rating and rage boost rating, since he stops holding back when he gets angry (obviously), which is still under berserker power
 
Hm, what has been rejected before ? If you're talking about the Immortal downgrade thread, that was left inconclusive and even then about 3 mods agreed he should be

I'm simply bringing it up because Immortal hasn't been that tough for a while. It may be worth refering to Kirkman's interview again as he’s of the mind that writing characters as if they’re strictly stronger or weaker than each other is limiting. It was simply more dramatic for the story for Immortal to get his licks back against the guy who murdered his team even if said guy punched a whole through him with one punch, there's no more need for that so he's now being outdone by characters comparable to Nolan and even below him.
Even though Immortal is notably weaker than any full blooded Viltrumite tier character, he still has impressive enough showings to scale him above their casual feats imo. Being able to harm Omni-Man on two occasions, being able to fight an Invincible variant for a day straight, and King Immortal slightly drawing blood from season 3 Mark should be enough to put him above Omni-Man casually surface wiping the Flaxan planet with his speed (Low 6-B) or Season 3 Mark no selling the Mauler's Nuke (High 6-A).

Edit: Thula should also realistically be upscaling from either of these as well as there's no way a pure blooded adult Viltrumite that is that old and was sent on a mission to kill Nolan along 2 others is a billion times weaker than him. And a post-thraxa season 2 Mark would scale for obvious reasons.
 
Last edited:
That's already there, it's exactly where his High 6-A end (19.63 Petatons) comes from
I think he should already scale above this and/or Omni-Man's surface wipe off of his performances.

Viltrumites are treated as basically unbeatable by the the coalition of planets, with one of their more promising weapons (Allen) not even being able to contend with one, and they should have WAY stronger weaponry than Earth Technology. Scaling even weaker Viltrumites like Thula above almost any Earth weapons shouldn't be unreasonable here. Even if you want to argue that the Mauler's Tech used in the EMP rocket are an anomaly, the hammer should be upgraded to 6-C using vaporization (because of the insane amount of steam, crater of red hot rock and ash at the edges), which she and arguably pre-powerup Allen should upscale from. Also if we end up downgrading Immortal, s2 Mark, and Thula to upscaling s1 Mark, they should be High 7-A since they vastly out scale him (and the difference is less than 1.2x).
 
the hammer should be upgraded to 6-C using vaporization (because of the insane amount of steam, crater of red hot rock and ash at the edges), which she and arguably pre-powerup Allen should upscale from.
And have that replace the "At least 7-A" lower-end, right ? I'm not opposed to it, but it's something being brought up just now and given the pace things move here that calculation will take ages to get accepted

They'll still have a High 6-A high-end so it's no that urgent, we can add it later
 
And have that replace the "At least 7-A" lower-end, right ?
yes
I'm not opposed to it, but it's something being brought up just now and given the pace things move here that calculation will take ages to get accepted
With the trailer for season 4 dropping, things will hopefully move faster.

Edit: Made a blog rq (got to 17.7 Gigatons)
They'll still have a High 6-A high-end so it's no that urgent, we can add it later
true
 
Last edited:
I agree with dropping rage power, but discarding Immortal's scaling is a huge stretch, he is so consistently the closest human to Viltrumite level that he was chosen to hold off evil Invincible in the season 2 opening.
 
I think he should already scale above this and/or Omni-Man's surface wipe off of his performances.

Viltrumites are treated as basically unbeatable by the the coalition of planets, with one of their more promising weapons (Allen) not even being able to contend with one, and they should have WAY stronger weaponry than Earth Technology. Scaling even weaker Viltrumites like Thula above almost any Earth weapons shouldn't be unreasonable here. Even if you want to argue that the Mauler's Tech used in the EMP rocket are an anomaly, the hammer should be upgraded to 6-C using vaporization (because of the insane amount of steam, crater of red hot rock and ash at the edges), which she and arguably pre-powerup Allen should upscale from. Also if we end up downgrading Immortal, s2 Mark, and Thula to upscaling s1 Mark, they should be High 7-A since they vastly out scale him (and the difference is less than 1.2x).
Just realized The Maulers and Allen also have "At least 7-A", should they also be High 7-A or drop the "At least" ?
 
Agree with the changes in general, though I'm a bit skeptical of completely dropping the Immortal's scaling. A 7-A logically wouldn't be able to hold their own against and draw blood from Tier 6 characters at all.
 
Last edited:
Agree with the changes in general, though I'm a bit skeptical of completely dropping the Immortal's scaling. A 7-A logically wouldn't be able to hold their own against and draw blood from Tier 6 characters at all.
Refer to the paragraph about how everyone can hold their own against everyone no matter how big the gap should be

Immortal would still a "possibly High 6-A" high-end over logically being above all of Earth's weaponry (which also can barely hurt viltrumites) so it shouldn't be that much of an issue
 
Last edited:
Just realized The Maulers and Allen also have "At least 7-A", should they also be High 7-A or drop the "At least" ?
Allen should probably stay 7-A, since he's unquantifiably above Mark and Nolan thinks he's strong enough to take him at that point. The Maulers could get upgraded to High 7-A since they could draw blood from s2 Mark who should be significantly above his 7-A feat at this point.
Agree with the changes in general, though I'm a bit skeptical of completely dropping the Immortal's scaling. A 7-A logically wouldn't be able to hold their own against and draw blood from Tier 6 characters at all.
What do you think about fully upscaling the Immortal above all of Earth's weaponry, instead of it just being "possibly"? (The Hammer and Maulers Nuke) Which did little to no damage to season 3 Mark and Nolan. It would upgrade him to High 6-A, but be significantly lower than where all the Viltrumite tier characters are at. 19.63 Petatons vs 2.17 Exatons
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top