-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Concepts
- Thread starter Yobo_Blue
- Start date
- 3,607
- 4,086
It depends on whether you are talking about "concept" in relation to one of its philosophical meanings or the various meanings that fictional works can take on them. In case the best question would be what constitutes a Universal, although it is a simple post I believe you can find some answers on this here.
- 8,427
- 3,147
I always saw concepts as the basic, most fundamental aspects of reality.
I don't know if that is accurate though.
I don't know if that is accurate though.
- 11,879
- 14,532
There is no way fiction in general sees it. Different fiction treats them differently. But as example here the explanation of concepts from Owari no Chronicle.
Spoiler
Ooshiro gave a bitter smile and said, "Unless you jump into the air, what is set as the ground will be constantly updated for you. In other words, the world always exists below your feet in this space. The concept related to gravitational pull has been altered."
"I see," said Sayama as he let go of Shinjou's hand. He looked toward Ooshiro and continued, "What exactly is this power?"
"Let me ask you something instead, Mikoto-kun. How do you think you could explain this power? What if you met with academics and intellectuals from around the world and asked them what power can alter the world so conveniently?"
"They would say it is a trick."
"Exactly. However, this is the truth. Now, another question. …What basis would they use for determining this is a trick?"
"That is obvious. This breaks the laws of physics."
"Yes, yes. Indeed it does. Light is bent by gravity, but with this power, light only bends according to the direction set as the ground for it. Even if the real ground is in a different direction. But Mikoto-kun, when you talk about the laws of physics, what world's physical laws do you speak of?"
"This world's physical laws."
"Then let me ask you something else. If alternate worlds did exist, on what basis would we determine they are different from our own? The terrain? The atmosphere? The life forms? Or perhaps the culture?"
With that question, Sayama realized the answer to it all.
He finally said, "Is this what you want to say? There was a world with physical laws fundamentally different from our own. And this power we are seeing follows that world's laws!"
"Precisely. This world's physical laws cannot be applied to other worlds. A world with different physical laws will naturally overturn the very basics of the physical laws we know."
"But there have to be certain absolutes, right? Like the motion of light."
"No, no. Even that is based on this world's physical laws. When light is emitted, it spreads and continues on. But why does it do that? Why can't there be light that does not do that?"
"That is…"
"That is simply what light is in this world, right? But," Ooshiro took a step forward so their gazes would match perpendicularly, "what if light being that way was actually quite rare?"
"…"
"We only know how things work in this world. We assume the workings of this world are absolute. But what if there were a great number of other worlds and it turned out the rules of this world are great exceptions compared to the other worlds?"
"But we do not know of any other worlds, so we can only assume they would be the same as us."
A bitter smile appeared on Ooshiro's lips when he heard that response.
"True," the old man said. "But another world is another world. They are fundamentally different. What we think is simply 'how things are' and what the other worlds think is simply 'how things are' are fundamentally different."
"Are you saying," Sayama looked down at his feet, "there is a world where this is how gravity works?"
Ooshiro nodded, walked over to the opposite window, and stood on it. He looked straight up toward Sayama.
"The ten other worlds and this world are perceived as individual gears and so we refer to them as such. 1st-Gear through 10th-Gear all had their own unique characteristics. And do you know what we called this power of 'how things are'?" Without waiting for an answer, Ooshiro said, "Concepts. We called them concepts! They are a power that can control even the laws of physics. They are the ultimate reason behind everything. That is what concepts are!"
Spoiler
Ooshiro gave a bitter smile and said, "Unless you jump into the air, what is set as the ground will be constantly updated for you. In other words, the world always exists below your feet in this space. The concept related to gravitational pull has been altered."
"I see," said Sayama as he let go of Shinjou's hand. He looked toward Ooshiro and continued, "What exactly is this power?"
"Let me ask you something instead, Mikoto-kun. How do you think you could explain this power? What if you met with academics and intellectuals from around the world and asked them what power can alter the world so conveniently?"
"They would say it is a trick."
"Exactly. However, this is the truth. Now, another question. …What basis would they use for determining this is a trick?"
"That is obvious. This breaks the laws of physics."
"Yes, yes. Indeed it does. Light is bent by gravity, but with this power, light only bends according to the direction set as the ground for it. Even if the real ground is in a different direction. But Mikoto-kun, when you talk about the laws of physics, what world's physical laws do you speak of?"
"This world's physical laws."
"Then let me ask you something else. If alternate worlds did exist, on what basis would we determine they are different from our own? The terrain? The atmosphere? The life forms? Or perhaps the culture?"
With that question, Sayama realized the answer to it all.
He finally said, "Is this what you want to say? There was a world with physical laws fundamentally different from our own. And this power we are seeing follows that world's laws!"
"Precisely. This world's physical laws cannot be applied to other worlds. A world with different physical laws will naturally overturn the very basics of the physical laws we know."
"But there have to be certain absolutes, right? Like the motion of light."
"No, no. Even that is based on this world's physical laws. When light is emitted, it spreads and continues on. But why does it do that? Why can't there be light that does not do that?"
"That is…"
"That is simply what light is in this world, right? But," Ooshiro took a step forward so their gazes would match perpendicularly, "what if light being that way was actually quite rare?"
"…"
"We only know how things work in this world. We assume the workings of this world are absolute. But what if there were a great number of other worlds and it turned out the rules of this world are great exceptions compared to the other worlds?"
"But we do not know of any other worlds, so we can only assume they would be the same as us."
A bitter smile appeared on Ooshiro's lips when he heard that response.
"True," the old man said. "But another world is another world. They are fundamentally different. What we think is simply 'how things are' and what the other worlds think is simply 'how things are' are fundamentally different."
"Are you saying," Sayama looked down at his feet, "there is a world where this is how gravity works?"
Ooshiro nodded, walked over to the opposite window, and stood on it. He looked straight up toward Sayama.
"The ten other worlds and this world are perceived as individual gears and so we refer to them as such. 1st-Gear through 10th-Gear all had their own unique characteristics. And do you know what we called this power of 'how things are'?" Without waiting for an answer, Ooshiro said, "Concepts. We called them concepts! They are a power that can control even the laws of physics. They are the ultimate reason behind everything. That is what concepts are!"
- 8,683
- 5,567
Fiction has no consistent definition.
In some a concept is closer to the Theory of Forms, existing as one of the archetypes that makes up reality. In others it's just the idea beyond a certain existence. In others the term is meaningless.
In some a concept is closer to the Theory of Forms, existing as one of the archetypes that makes up reality. In others it's just the idea beyond a certain existence. In others the term is meaningless.
- 3,607
- 4,086
There is no universal meaning of the term Concept based on fictions, it depends purely on what Fiction is determining in its cosmology. The best solution if there is not an in-depth explanation on this then the best thing to do is to analyze the multiple theories about Univerals.
But as always, you must be talking about the meaning of Forms or Ideas (ἰδέα ) based on Plato Theory of Forms (Which is called Concepts in some works of fiction, after all speaking Concept is much more interesting than speaking Form. Even more considering that most of the people who follow fiction have no idea about the Problem of Universals that is the origin of this whole debate.) In that case I suggest you read the blog I put up about Platonic Realism and this Blog about Digimon (because here I continue the explanation on Platonic Universals).
EDIT: Just now I've seen other people respond, I think they've explained the situation well.
But as always, you must be talking about the meaning of Forms or Ideas (ἰδέα ) based on Plato Theory of Forms (Which is called Concepts in some works of fiction, after all speaking Concept is much more interesting than speaking Form. Even more considering that most of the people who follow fiction have no idea about the Problem of Universals that is the origin of this whole debate.) In that case I suggest you read the blog I put up about Platonic Realism and this Blog about Digimon (because here I continue the explanation on Platonic Universals).
EDIT: Just now I've seen other people respond, I think they've explained the situation well.
- 11,879
- 14,532
We rate them as the frachises present them.Yobobojojo said:
However, when it comes to the conceptual manipulation we have on profiles it should usually be able to do some parts of what is described as possible uses on the conceptual manipulation page.
- 11,879
- 14,532
We have criteria for conceptual creation on the Conceptual Manipulation page when it comes to the question if something should be viewed as that ability. They should give an idea about when we give out conceptual manipulation.
But when it really comes down to which kind of concepts it are, beyond just putting it on the profiles, I think the only hope you have is the fiction going into detail about the topic. Aside from the we don't really have standards to my knowledge.
But when it really comes down to which kind of concepts it are, beyond just putting it on the profiles, I think the only hope you have is the fiction going into detail about the topic. Aside from the we don't really have standards to my knowledge.
- 1,096
- 94
Concepts which are formed by binaries are not things which are definite, they are things of Everything that a subject simply observed.
As for the creation trio, one embody time, another the spatial conception, and another the anti-matter, wherever this is only encompassing the attributes of space-time, and that constant does not stretch any further than a multiversal reality. Mathematical concepts are functional only where they origin from. On the contrary to the metaphysical, who "exist" as "truly formless beyond the physical, as something indefinite, stretching endlessly.
Short answer; there is no standard for determining this. Only the verse can determine it, right or left does not say everything.
As for the creation trio, one embody time, another the spatial conception, and another the anti-matter, wherever this is only encompassing the attributes of space-time, and that constant does not stretch any further than a multiversal reality. Mathematical concepts are functional only where they origin from. On the contrary to the metaphysical, who "exist" as "truly formless beyond the physical, as something indefinite, stretching endlessly.
Short answer; there is no standard for determining this. Only the verse can determine it, right or left does not say everything.
Similar threads
