- 30,209
- 25,594
I've spotted an issue regarding the currently accepted calculation for Garou's feat during chapter 155 of the manga.
Note: So that this thread is not bombarded with posts, it is probably best the Calc Group Members, Staff Members and only very knowledgeable users comment on here.
The Issue
The main problem of this calculation is that it is finding the dimensions of the light structure by taking measurements from this calculation, which is explain in this section:
The image used for the pixelscaling is here:
But here's the thing, the larger red line there that is being used as the basis for the pixelscaling, is described as "Z City itself" so the diameter of Z City from the above calculation is being used... but there is no basis for this as far as I can tell.
This is just a distant far-off shot of the landmass where the city is based... but nothing about this original page tells us that is the entirety of Z City... And there are no landmarks in that panel that we can point to in order to say it is a full shot of the city.
It's a very simple issue at the root of it; 135 km is the currently accepted figure for Z City's diameter... but the panel used for the pixelscaling has no reasonable basis for being assumed to represent the diameter of Z City. Which would make the subsequent measurements of the calculation wrong, and the entire calc would be unable to be used.
Solution
The best solution for the time being, would probably be for DarthSpiderr's previous version of the calculation to be used. JasonSith has accepted one of the PE ends for it, so it should replace the currently used calc and only a few ratings would have to be adjusted. Other versions of the calc could probably be made, but this one at least can be readily used.
Note: So that this thread is not bombarded with posts, it is probably best the Calc Group Members, Staff Members and only very knowledgeable users comment on here.
The Issue
The main problem of this calculation is that it is finding the dimensions of the light structure by taking measurements from this calculation, which is explain in this section:
This is where the problem begins. The size of the hole, which is being currently used for obtaining the structure's size, is inconsistent and is leading to huge disparities between the ends. Instead, I'll be using another panel and using the size of Z city itself. This is the panel where Z City was observed by Gotz Okkie. I'll be taking Z City's size from here.
The image used for the pixelscaling is here:
But here's the thing, the larger red line there that is being used as the basis for the pixelscaling, is described as "Z City itself" so the diameter of Z City from the above calculation is being used... but there is no basis for this as far as I can tell.
This is just a distant far-off shot of the landmass where the city is based... but nothing about this original page tells us that is the entirety of Z City... And there are no landmarks in that panel that we can point to in order to say it is a full shot of the city.
It's a very simple issue at the root of it; 135 km is the currently accepted figure for Z City's diameter... but the panel used for the pixelscaling has no reasonable basis for being assumed to represent the diameter of Z City. Which would make the subsequent measurements of the calculation wrong, and the entire calc would be unable to be used.
Solution
The best solution for the time being, would probably be for DarthSpiderr's previous version of the calculation to be used. JasonSith has accepted one of the PE ends for it, so it should replace the currently used calc and only a few ratings would have to be adjusted. Other versions of the calc could probably be made, but this one at least can be readily used.