- 405
- 531
I'm adapting
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Jujutsu Kaisen Discussion Page #1
- Thread starter PowerToScale
- Start date
- 5,975
- 5,828
Ask this guy
- 14,443
- 6,257
To me it seems like wiggle room for potentially upgrading otherwise underwhelming feats/abilities within the primary source all for the sake of scaling. Which I get the point but then it just makes the primary source have less value if we're gonna end up using secondary sources over it, even provided we have interviews of the author saying they worked on it.
Guacamolefletcher
Username Only- 1,815
- 2,031
This is not a good reason, and there’s precedent in a lot of other shonen verses
- 14,443
- 6,257
What do you mean?
Guacamolefletcher
Username Only- 1,815
- 2,031
There’s a lot of verses where the anime is accepted as primary canon eventhough its an adaptation
Not to that extreme, but it’s possible to use these things for scaling
- 14,443
- 6,257
Yeah that feels off to do is all.
- 405
- 531
the only upscaling I'm familiar with is a few more calcs which get characters in their already accepted speed ranges (subsonic - supersonic), one very minor and still consistent AP upgrade, and a few additional hax for Mahoraga (better large size, size manip, underwater breathing, and better regen). So far, all this seems largely insignificant and consistent with the manga.
Guacamolefletcher
Username Only- 1,815
- 2,031
The anime would give better 
calcs
calcs
- 5,975
- 5,828
Also body control that allows for air and water manipulation
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
I don't think so. This might be after Yuta's battle.
Narrative states he needs chants , signs and directions that's all.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
You have the translation for thisi stopped reading it when they say highest output in history. clearly a jjk reader that didn't bother diving deep. because that statement talks about Modern Sendai(correct translation)
next.
Guacamolefletcher
Username Only- 1,815
- 2,031
It does noti stopped reading it when they say highest output in history. clearly a jjk reader that didn't bother diving deep. because that statement talks about Modern Sendai
next.
- 5,975
- 5,828
If Sukuna suggests he needs to charge up Cursed Energy to do it, then there's no reason to deny it
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
Yeah that's after Yuta's battle when he doesn't have his 3rd arm to make the sign and send the slashes in his own set. Direction?
- 5,975
- 5,828
- 14,443
- 6,257
Sukuna fire arrow ^
And better regen is nothing insignificant nor consistent with the manga lmao. Also it just opens the door for dismissing manga in general is the issue.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
- 5,975
- 5,828
Not suitable for battle, but he can clearly lift it, and thus use it to aim the WCSIt's literally useless
- 405
- 531
how is Mahoraga's regen inconsistent with the manga?
- 14,443
- 6,257
Because we don't see him regenerate to the same extent as the anime. He barely regens at all in the manga actually.
- 405
- 531
in the manga he regens through Sukuna's domain and slashes through the head prior, he clearly has notable regeneration, with some cursed spirits also having feats of regen comparable to that (such as Mahito regenerating from a puddle of blood). I don't see why the manga not showing something makes it inconsistent, too, we don't use that standard for other verses.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
Not suitable= He can't use it for the fight
He used his upper right hand to send the slashes not lower one. Also He didn't used signs here.
- 14,443
- 6,257
That's just mid regen? And no, no cursed spirit shows regen on that level, Mahito's regen comes from reshaping his soul and Mahoraga isn't a cursed spirit how are they relevant here? And that's the very point of inconsistent, the manga doesn't show it but the anime does, that's inconsistent.
- 5,975
- 5,828
Sukuna implies he currently has the WCS at his disposalNot suitable= He can't use it for the fight
He used his upper right hand to send the slashes not lower one. Also He didn't used signs here.
This doesn't even matter anyway. My main point was that there's a charge-up period, as speculated by a character who doesn't truly know and corroborated by the guy who fires said attack
- 405
- 531
I never said otherwise, I was using it to show Mahoraga having notable regeneration is established inverse.
"no cursed spirit shows regen on that level"
"Mahito shows regen on that level"
The point is to show instances inverse.
the absence of a scene != inconsistent with the scene, simply not the standard for things.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
I never claimed he doesn't have it.
I'm wondering if the charge-up time was him using another BV during Yuta's battle for compensation for losing his hands so he can skip the signs and work with chants, charge-up time, and direction.
This doesn't even matter anyway. My main point was that there's a charge-up period, as speculated by a character who doesn't truly know and corroborated by the guy who fires said attack
- 14,443
- 6,257
Through his soul reshaping, not because he's a cursed spirit."no cursed spirit shows regen on that level"
"Mahito shows regen on that level"
But we're talking about Mahoraga? Why would the regen of other groups matter? I'm not saying regen in general is inconsistent
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 14,957
- 10,859
Mahoraga is not a cursed spirit. Anyway I think anime wanked Mahoraga Regeneration. I mean Gojo was about to Cook that with red.
- 405
- 531
I never said otherwise, again my point was to show that low-high regeneration isn't absurd for a character in the verse to have.
- 14,443
- 6,257
But that wasn't the issue I took with the feat to begin with? And Low-High is something absurd for the verse as of now. RCT doesn't allow for this, Cursed spirits don't show this either
- 405
- 531
I literally showed an inverse instance of it, idk how you can say it's absurd, and also again there's no contradictions to it so I don't see why we'd take the stance it's "absurd" and "inconsistent"
- 14,443
- 6,257
Read what I am saying. PLEASE. I am saying that the feat is inconsistent for Mahoraga because we don't see that happen for him in the manga at all.
Now overall, the regeneration is absurd for the verse as RCT and Cursed Spirits don't show regeneration comparable to it, the best example you've given is Mahito, and I've told you twice Mahito's example is SOUL RESHAPING, it is not natural regeneration. Your example does not work in this context.
- 5,975
- 5,828
Not that I agree, but the regen doesn't seem that extreme when you consider that, like Mahito's, it is done via a medium
Anime Mahoraga can only perform low-high regen against an attack it has sufficiently adapted to
Anime Mahoraga can only perform low-high regen against an attack it has sufficiently adapted to
- 1,309
- 901
so you think gege is allowing them to create noncanon now when they just said they work with gege to follow the story as precisely as possible. then what do you think approval is. go ahead and create something that doesn't represent the story or what i want? lol
gege never said don't read my manga. the anime may provide: emotionally, color wise, impact wise, (added bonus of voice acting conveying more emotion), sound wise better and things that the manga does not have, or make some scenes and more, look far better. But that doesn't mean it would replicate things unique to the mangaa nd the like.
For example: in season 1 gege didn't want to have any narrator, which is why u don't see any narrator statements in season 1 anime (talk about "not involved with anime" eh?) which he then changed his mind on (Season 2). Do u think those statements are now suddenly gone and invalid canon wise? no.
“There’s an order from Akutami-sensei to not use narration for anime production, which is often used in the original work. The narration used in the original work is a unique expression of manga and — I think it feels uncomfortable when a third person reads it out loud in the anime."
Though he later on changes his mind on this as we all see in season 2
The manga has things the anime may not have sometimes. Heck it doesn't even have the extra pages done in the anime, like the correcting the limitless one (Honestly they should have, since it does give a clear insight but idk why not) and such.
It's why the anime is treated as secondary canon, although in some aspects for scenes, it could be "primary" canon (in a limited sense) for essentially doing the scene better than the manga did.
- 215
- 123
It fits for Mahoraga because of its immense adaptation.
Plus, EVERY time Mahoraga was defeated it was Disintegrated, Both by Fuga and Unrestricted Hollow Purple. Its not inconsistent at all.
Plus, EVERY time Mahoraga was defeated it was Disintegrated, Both by Fuga and Unrestricted Hollow Purple. Its not inconsistent at all.
- 2,151
- 821
