• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

All Purpose Dragon Ball Thread

Ruphas_Mafahl123 said:
Bro.

Today I argued against that Shin the Science guy from the DB Community fandom.
Click to expand...
I mean, I don't really have much of an opinion on that person. I only ended up serving to proxy debate them because I was being plagerized and asked to defend the person who stole from me.
Ruphas_Mafahl123 said:
...Bro is legit a low-tier debater.
Click to expand...
W...what does that even mean? Like, how the Hell can someone be a "low-tier" Debater? Is there a competitive debating meta? Like, you lost me there.
 
RedReaper616 said:
I mean, I don't really have much of an opinion on that person. I only ended up serving to proxy debate them because I was being plagerized and asked to defend the person who stole from me.
Click to expand...
I see.
RedReaper616 said:
W...what does that even mean? Like, how the Hell can someone be a "low-tier" Debater? Is there a competitive debating meta? Like, you lost me there.
Click to expand...
His's condescending attitude, how he intentionally minsterprets coherent reasoning in regards scan explanations, how he applies the Occam's razor fallacy, etc

I'm sorry for saying this, I admit I went off the charts here...the dude just got into my nerves.
 
Last edited:
Probably because he is a non-character, and the only reason why anybody would even care about indexing him is to have a second Tier 1 character connected to non-Bandai Dragon Ball.
 
Ok, I will express my view on this matter.
To be honest, I wouldn't use the Daizenshuu/Chōzenshū to explain in-lore stuff from the DBZ TV Anime or it's movies, neither GT.
Sure, they can be used as a referential encyclopedia in regards power levels, races, etc.
But taking at face value what they say in regards Toei works is a mistake.

Daizenshuu/Chōzenshū were published by Sueshia, Toei had minimal involvement there.
Daizenshuu/Chōzenshū have a different world view in regards DB than Toei.
In my opinion Toei's own sources should take more precendence over specific stuff like hidden lore explanations, continuity, etc..
After all, whatever Daizenshuu and Chōzenshū have to say about Toei's own shit is kinda irrelevant.

Becouse well, if anything, they are third party people explaning stuff from the Toeiverse, not really the main producers, screen writers, etc that were involved.
 
Last edited:
Nullflowerblush said:
Like?
Click to expand...
Well, official statements, guides where Toei Staff was heavily involved, or written mostly by Toei.
Not Sueshia that has an entirely different point of view in regards DB.

For example, a Toei Movie pamphlet saying DBZ Broly had Infinite power which grows every second, should hold way more credibility than Sueshia (Caramel mama studio), or Akira's team saying the contrary on the Daizenshuu or Chōzenshū which are a bit more manga shifted.

In my opinion, I consider that primary supplementary material specifically made for the TV Anime, movies, etc should take more precendence over official statements from third party people not directly involved in the main animated work's production.
 
Ruphas_Mafahl123 said:
Daizenshuu/Chōzenshū have a different world view in regards DB than Toei.
Click to expand...
MCnM5XA.jpeg
 
Actually I'm curious as how Soul Adagio would intract with Dragon Ball Ki, as Ki is accepted to be soul power. Like would it work on Kid Goku (Who's also 5-B)?

Soul Manipulation (Ki is synonymous[119] with spirit, life-energy and the soul.[119] Ki being spiritual[6] is a fact reiterated a multitude of times; consequently, the energy[120] is invisible[121] and formless[122] prior to being converted.[1] The manipulation of energy is done by using the internal spiritual energy from within[1] and being able to materialize it, and project it outwards.[10] Therefore, manipulating this means interacting with your own soul to draw upon ki for various uses)

Resistance to Soul Manipulation (Soul Damage & Destruction[See Notes 7]; Spirits in the Afterlife[128] can fight others and the spirit is strengthened like its body[129]. Many characters[25] have demonstrated[130] being able[131] to naturally[131] handle having[132] their spirit[119]/ki[6] stolen from them[133]. Ki users when splitting[6] their soul[134] have been shown taking damage to their spirit[134], and still handle the effects[134] of the damage. When fighting against other Ki users, their Soul Damaging effects are inherently resisted with the most powerful Ki users being able to endure the effects of Hakai[135] which directly targets the soul and attempts to destroy it completely)

Soul Damage (Ordinary Ki can directly interact with spirits[119] and harm them[145], causing damage to the soul itself[145]. Techniques like Hakai, which outright destroy souls[146], can even be used[39] by those[147] with ordinary[148] Ki)
 
Ruphas_Mafahl123 said:
In my opinion, I consider that primary supplementary material specifically made for the TV Anime, movies, etc should take more precendence over official statements from third party people not directly involved in the main animated work's production.
Click to expand...
The TV Anime Guide series was written and edited by Kisōsha and Drill Project staff. The Extreme Battle Collection series was written and edited by Kisōsha. The Dragon Ball Z Anime Special series was written and edited by Kisōsha. The GT Perfect Files are written and edited by Kisōsha and third party, non-Toei writers. Even the Dragon Books, which are packaged with the Dragon Box releases of the TV anime, are written and edited by Kisōsha.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
The TV Anime Guide series was written and edited by Kisōsha and Drill Project staff. The Extreme Battle Collection series was written and edited by Kisōsha. The Dragon Ball Z Anime Special series was written and edited by Kisōsha. The GT Perfect Files are written and edited by Kisōsha and third party, non-Toei writers. Even the Dragon Books, which are packaged with the Dragon Box releases of the TV anime, are written and edited by Kisōsha.
Click to expand...
Yeah, with the involvement and revision of the GT Staff and the people involved.
What I'm saying is...., that doesn't change the fact that when those two wrote the Daizenshuu/Chōzenshū guides barely anyone from Toei was involved.

Regardless, i'm just stating my opinion in regards the matter.

Supplementary material specific to certain series should override whatever other external sources say.
 
Last edited:
The GT Perfect Files, the Dragon Books, the Daizenshuu, and the Chōzenshū are all made 協力 or "In Cooperation With" Toei Animation. As far as we are aware, these four share the same amount of "involvement and revision" from the Toei Animation staff.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
The GT Perfect Files, the Dragon Books, the Daizenshuu, and the Chōzenshū are all made 協力 or "In Cooperation With" Toei Animation. As far as we are aware, these four share the same amount of "involvement and revision" from the Toei Animation staff.
Click to expand...
I'm not sure about that..

If anything, Japanese Anime guides tend have tons of contradictions between each other mostly becouse different people work them.
If we are being realistic, we have no real way to prove with 100% confidence if what you are saying it's actually the case.
These incosistentencies arises becouse it depends on the team that work them.
But there is still a fact, GT/Toei Staff defintely have much more involvement in their own works than external sources...

And mind, unlike Westerners, Japanese people do not even know what canon is, and they simply do not really care about it.....

Applying Western-centric standarts of consistency to Japanese works is a huge mistake..

A common mistake for many people of this wiki is to view Japanese media through the Euro-American cultural lens
 
Last edited:
Ruphas_Mafahl123 said:
But there is still a fact, GT/Toei Staff defintely have much more involvement in their own works than external sources...
Click to expand...
If we are being realistic, we have no real way to prove with 100% confidence if what you are saying it's actually the case. You can't just say something is a fact like that makes it true. You can't prove it. You'd think if they were as involved as you think they are—hands on and all—they would, at some point, be credited with writing on any of the aforementioned guidebooks.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
If we are being realistic, we have no real way to prove with 100% confidence if what you are saying it's actually the case. You can't just say something is a fact like that makes it true. You can't prove it. You'd think if they were as involved as you think they are—hands on and all—they would, at some point, be credited with writing on any of the aforementioned guidebooks.
Click to expand...
It was the case in the perfect files? iirc
 
I feel like profiles for DBS characters whose portrayals across the manga and anime aren't distinct enough from each other to be separate should be composited. They're essentially the same characters anyway, and since the worldviews of both continuities are almost nearly identical, I don't really see why we should be splitting hairs over how these characters are depicted across the two mediums.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
I feel like profiles for DBS characters whose portrayals across the manga and anime aren't distinct enough from each other to be separate should be composited. They're essentially the same characters anyway, and since the worldviews of both continuities are almost nearly identical, I don't really see why we should be splitting hairs over how these characters are depicted across the two mediums.
Click to expand...
interesting
 
Nullflowerblush said:
I feel like profiles for DBS characters whose portrayals across the manga and anime aren't distinct enough from each other to be separate should be composited. They're essentially the same characters anyway, and since the worldviews of both continuities are almost nearly identical, I don't really see why we should be splitting hairs over how these characters are depicted across the two mediums.
Click to expand...
Not quite...

Still different powerscaling
 
I also agree with the profile fusion, like Daishinkan is the same as in the anime, it only showed differences in skills (where the anime hasn't shown yet with the Moro saga), so anyway I'm fine with the profile fusion...
 
I mainly suggest it because I plan on making a thread for revising Hit's Time-Skip, and I'm going to be using manga evidence.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
I mainly suggest it because I plan on making a thread for revising Hit's Time-Skip, and I'm going to be using manga evidence.
Click to expand...
I’m not sure which manga evidence would actually help in explaining it. Hit says he’s stopping time, but against SSJ Goku he says he’s traveling to the future (so the explanation still contradicts itself), and Manga Hit has a PL limit whereas Anime Hit hasn’t shown such a limit. Goku just breaks through + resists through his own ability to do that, and Jiren “transcends time” so it doesn’t work on him. And, of course, Manga Hit infamously lacks basically all the Assassin Arc elements of Anime Hit’s kit (Phasing, Energy Duplication, Phasing Attacks, Illusions, etc.) created by Hit’s Parallel Space. The best I can think is using Time Lag as a mirror to Cage of Time, but like…Time Lag just slows down Jiren, and is made to get around a limit in Manga Hit’s abilities. Cage of Time is an actual, perpetual time freeze that Jiren just powers through because, apparently, time manipulation doesn’t apply to his strength.
 
Nullflowerblush said:
I feel like profiles for DBS characters whose portrayals across the manga and anime aren't distinct enough from each other to be separate should be composited. They're essentially the same characters anyway, and since the worldviews of both continuities are almost nearly identical, I don't really see why we should be splitting hairs over how these characters are depicted across the two mediums.
Click to expand...
I can only see that working as different keys with tabbers properly distinguishing them like the Star Wars and DCEU profiles had before. By extension shouldn't it also apply to characters like Raditz? Giving him "Manga, Toei and Kai" Keys, since it's the same deal
 
RedReaper616 said:
I’m not sure which manga evidence would actually help in explaining it.
Click to expand...
Primarily, Whis saying: "Time Control… What a surprise to see someone with the same ability as me."
RedReaper616 said:
Hit says he’s stopping time, but against SSJ Goku he says he’s traveling to the future (so the explanation still contradicts itself)
Click to expand...
From his perspective, he is stopping time when he fast-forwards, given he is (typically) granted free range of movement against his opponent for the duration of his Time-Skip. However, he obviously does not stop time against Goku, considering that; even though his fully powered Time-Skip worked on God Goku, Goku was still capable of transforming into SSB; time is not frozen when he time-skips, he simply moves ahead of the actions of others as they naturally advance.
RedReaper616 said:
Manga Hit has a PL limit whereas Anime Hit hasn’t shown such a limit.
Click to expand...
Hit's Battle Power limitations are not explicitly declared, but nothing ever suggests they do not exist.
RedReaper616 said:
Goku just breaks through + resists through his own ability to do that, and
Click to expand...
  • Goku outpredicts his 0.1-second-long Time-Skip.
  • Hit "advanced himself" and developed a 0.2 and then 0.5-second-long Time-Skip, which successfully affected Goku.
    • He began unlocking his full potential throughout the fight explicitly like Saiyans can.
  • Goku powered up via Kaio-ken x10 and successfully outpredicted Hit's Time-Skip again.
  • Hit advances himself further and becomes stronger, lengthening his Time-Skip even further, allowing him to evade Goku's Kamehameha.
RedReaper616 said:
Manga Hit infamously lacks basically all the Assassin Arc elements of Anime Hit’s kit (Phasing, Energy Duplication, Phasing Attacks, Illusions, etc.) created by Hit’s Parallel Space.
Click to expand...
Simply because he has not demonstrated any of the abilities on-page—y'know, because the manga version of the Tournament of Power was not interested in characters not named Goku, Jiren, or Vegeta (barely)—does not mean he does not possess them, nor does it mean he does not have the potential to develop them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Mbpoops
Transcending all Dimensions! the forgotten dokkan profile
Replies
13
Views
1K
AlipheeseXIV
AlipheeseXIV
Broly movie but in GT (GT Goku and Vegeta vs DBS Broly) [1-4-0]
2
Replies
50
Views
1K
MannyQ361
Alternate Universe: Haxgon Ball Z
Replies
0
Views
436
ALEPHGOAT
Killerdrone123
  • Locked
Quick GT Goku addition
Replies
24
Views
3K
Vietthai96
Vietthai96
FoxySonicMaster108
Dragon Ball Z: Anime and Movies being one thing?
Replies
2
Views
947
JustANormalPerson01
JustANormalPerson01
Back
Top