Canonicity of RWBY x JL Crossover Comic

[Deagonx]

Deagon's main arguing point currently comes from an unsourced CBR article, i dont see how that is any better

The source is an interview they did with Kerry. Are you claiming they lied about the interview? That's laughable.

with them labeling all of the things we currently use for the verse as outright canon

Except this movie and the comics, one of which was directly called not canon and the other was never called canon in the first place.

Its quite funny, if this were any other verse thi wouldnt even be a discussion, but because its RWBY, a verse that i specifically work on, people are happy to tear down my work as a joke.

They have an issue with me, and are taking it out on a verse ive put a significant amount of work into

This is truly quite pathetic. You are deluding yourself into believing that 8 different staff members voted near-unanimously on this matter due to a personal problem with you?

What a convenient coping mechanism, every time you get debunked and massively overruled, just pretend to yourself that it's all a big conspiracy against you! Surely your reasoning wasn't simply flawed! Surely the fact that your three main sources of evidence all turned out to be falsely represented didn't have anything to do with it?

What a joke. Accusing everyone here of acting out of a personal vendetta against you rather than their own reasoning.

This is closed now. We have triple the amount of votes required to pass this and no disagrees. Thanks everyone for helping out.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

This is closed now. We have triple the amount of votes required to pass this and no disagrees. Thanks everyone for helping out.

I disagree. I would wait still for Firestorm's and Damage's evaluation, unless they themselves note they are unneeded or won't have the time.

 

[Deagonx]

I disagree. I would wait still for Firestorm's and Damage's evaluation, unless they themselves note they are unneeded or won't have the time.

Damage said he agreed, and I DMd Firestorm and he said he was okay with concluding the thread in light of the wide staff agreement.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

Damage said he agreed, and I DMd Firestorm and he said he was okay with concluding the thread in light of the wide staff agreement.

Could you send me firestorm comments on private?

 

[Deagonx]

Could you send me firestorm comments on private?

Sure.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

Yeah... I think I'm agreeing with Deagonx on this now.

Canon adjacent =/= Canon, as far as our profiles are concerned.

sorry I missed this, btw

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

Damage said he agreed, and I DMd Firestorm and he said he was okay with concluding the thread in light of the wide staff agreement.

Well then, my concerns have been satiated. The thread can indeed be closed now.

 

[Antvasima]

I personally agree with Ovens' evaluation post above.

However, I also agree with Lephyr regarding that as a staff member, Deagonx needs to continuously try to tone down his rhetorics to a more polite and respectful tone than what was used here at times.

That is all.

 

[Damage3245]

Shouldn't some kind of note be added to the Verse page as a result of this thread?

 

[Deagonx]

Shouldn't some kind of note be added to the Verse page as a result of this thread?

Yes. I plan to take care of that soon. I just wanted to prevent this from going on needlessly.