Paraconsistent Physiology Checklist

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

A while ago, a thread was made to check the various forms of Paraconsistent Physiology left over from when it was treated as Transduality/Nonduality. From that, a few users and I realized that several verses may or may not qualify under its current requirements. The purpose of this CRT is to give users a clearer standard for checking whether their verse, or specific characters within it, still qualify for Paraconsistent Physiology under the current requirements.

To simplify, Paraconsistent Physiology is a state that defies Classical Logic.

• For example, if Character A is not Character A, that violates the Law of Identity, since classical logic holds that A is A.
• Likewise, if Character A is alive and not alive at the same time and in the same sense, that violates the Law of Non-Contradiction.
• If Character A is neither alive nor not alive, that violates the Law of Excluded Middle, since classical logic does not allow a third option such as “both,” “neither,” or another truth value.

With that in mind, simply being both alive and not alive would only violate the classical logic of one property and would be Type 1. Violating classical logic more broadly would be Type 2, while Type 3 specifically covers cases of many-valued logic, where the state cannot be defined by true, false, both, or neither.

Notes​

• While dualities can qualify, they must follow a form of yes/no, true/false, or A/not-A. Fire and water may be treated as dualities in fiction, but logically, something is either water or not water, not “water or fire.”
• The same applies to Yin and Yang. Even if Yin is female and Yang is male, the negation of male is not male, not female. So Yin/Yang only qualifies if the verse treats them as actual logical negations.
• Lastly, it should be noted that Paraconsistent Physiology does not automatically grant broad interaction immunity. Any resistance, immunity, or special interaction should depend on what the verse actually shows. In other words, even if a character exists outside or beyond a system of classical logic, that does not automatically mean they are immune to everything that operates within that system. The verse must specifically show that their paraconsistent nature prevents certain effects from working on them.

Qualifies:
Disqualifies:

 

[Rakih_Elyan]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Yin_Tian_Shen_Yin

YTSY verse qualifies for all of their PP types.

 

[Rakih_Elyan]

• Too vast, too complex. The gray-black radiance emanating from it pierced through the entire Sealed Multiverse, being one of those thirteen beams of light. This was called Reincarnation-an intricate, colossal macro-structure that transcended spacetime, karma, and even the entire multiverse itself. Compared to it, the Great Path of naturally born multiverses seemed as feeble and laughable as playdough molded by slugs. Yet it remained but a crude tool, originally crafted to remember all names, and later to ensure all names could be remembered. Everything within it had not truly died-not waiting, but stubbornly advancing, just like that family. They weren't dead yet. Their wife and mother still prayed, remembering them. Only when no one left in the entire multiverse could recall them would their True Spirits enter Reincarnation.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 855

• There was much, much more emerging from the gears rotating within those eyes. It was a scene from beyond time and space, beyond the universal logic, consciousness, and imagination of humanity, almost impossible to describe with any language. Some saw a life of poverty, dying as a war refugee. Others saw a past of wealth and luxury, living freely as a nobleman. Yet, humans were the minority. Whether it was frogs or squids, eagles or apple trees, those in the sea, the sky, the earth, or the void of the universe—all were caught in the rotating illusions, facing their end and a new beginning. Reincarnation.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 498

• The cycle of the strong devouring the weak, the weak consuming the minute, and the minute preying on the strong-this is Reincarnation, order, and reason. But it cannot move forward. Fire and meat create cooked food; merely hammering steel against steel can forge swords, plows, armor, tanks, rockets, and spaceships, and even more. Rather than an endless cycle of repetition, it is better to forge a path.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 498

• Reversing the yin and yang of time and space, the eternal cycle of reincarnation without end, neither born nor destroyed, neither tainted nor pure, neither increasing nor decreasing
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 484

• But just as the relativity, comparison, and Reincarnation of 'being' and 'nothingness' form the first Taiji.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 953

• Wuji gave rise to Taiji, Taiji divided into Yin and Yang, and from these two colors emerged the infinite diversity of existence.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 949

• Just as within Yin there was Yang, and within Yang there was Yin-the Taiji.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 949

• And then, a rumbling sound echoed through the void, as if some invisible force was operating in the depths of nothingness. In the depths of the darkness, layers upon layers of light ignited, transforming into massive gears that interlocked and rotated in the abyss of the void, resembling one Reincarnation nested within another. Each turn of a gear would drive the rotation of countless others, and this interconnected cycle of Reincarnation was the embodiment of causality.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 480

[Reincarnation] has nested duality within it.

• "Balance is order and imbalance is chaos."
  — Soul of Searing Steel - Chapter 130

• Sun and Moon lost their luster when it arrived, the sea boiled, and all balance, be it warmth and cold, light and darkness, even life and death was broken.
  — Soul of Searing Steel - Chapter 755

• ["-The principle of all ages, the origin of all truths; the Balance of all realms, the standard of all measures—"] ["-Naming all existence, weighing heaven and earth; fate ordained, sin eternally judged-"]
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 761

• The same hue might be called 'black' in one mind, 'red' in another. Some saw emptiness there, others a turbid blend of colors defying name. All were correct. Between races, differing electromagnetic perceptions and Spiritual Energy frequencies transformed a single red apple into dozens, hundreds, even infinite variations of color and form. Some saw nourishment, others poison, inedible waste, or a terrifying invasive species. All were correct. So how might these disparate realms and races, these irreconcilable perceptions and logics, these perhaps fundamentally incompatible existences, breach this tragic Barrier? How could beings who observe the same world (truth) yet derive countless different right answers communicate their thoughts—how might one soul comprehend another? The answer was Balance. The naming of all things. Through Balance, two utterly dissimilar souls find common ground while preserving differences. Through Balance, two extreme ideologies grasp the starting point of mutual understanding. Through Balance, born from mutual compromise among All Living Beings, souls relinquished describing the world purely through personal perception. Instead, they created language—a blend of objective and subjective third-party methods to define objects, existences, truths. Then bestowed names acceptable to all. Thus everything began. Balance arbitrated mortal perceptions, defined all existence, named heaven and earth, and measured universal standards-enabling communication between living beings and understanding between wills.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 761

• Are all things ranked in superiority and inferiority? No, and yes. Can all things be equated? Yes, and no. The truth of [Balance] lies precisely in this duality of 'is and is not,' 'can and cannot.'
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 783

• As previously stated regarding the essence of Balance: Are all things equal in rank and value? No, and yes. Can all things truly be equated? They can, and they cannot. This duality-the existence and absence, the possibility and impossibility-is the true essence of [Balance]. The same applied to the cosmos and All Living Beings. Theoretically, they were both Minds, both entitled to live and pursue their truths.
  — Monsters Die When They Are Killed - Chapter 783

[Balance] also explains that the duality it contains the duality of "is" and "is not" and even the paradox of no and yes existing at the same time.

Now, for the existing PP on the profile itself:

Paraconsistent Physiology (Type 3; [Absolute] makes it so one can't be affected by any kind of complex or volatile skill, including ones that are illusory or spiritual, because they have transcended all boundaries. As such, even attacks that make every aspect and principle of the universe equal, parallel, symmetrical, balanced, stable, complementing, nullifying, and corresponding, ridding it of change and possibility, are unable to truly affect them)

• Paraconsistent Physiology (Type 3; Initial Flames are formed from countless bits of information of both 'Existence', 'Non-Existence', and 'Ambiguity')

Paraconsistent Physiology (Type 3; Transcenders are the absolute, infinite eternity that surpasses the duality of life and death upon which all logic is founded, as well as the opposition of life and death. All concepts exist as an infinite spectrum of two poles, and all the infinite forms of logic and perception are correct. Furthermore, Transcender's transcend the infinite cycle of [Reincarnation], which is the cycling of all states of duality, including nested dualities)

Paraconsistent Physiology (Type 3; Great Existences can be perceived in terms of good and evil, right and wrong, justice and evil, yes and no, by both mortals and Transcendent Gods. However, such beings are like blind men touching an elephant—anyone unable to transcend time and space cannot perceive their true nature, at most only glimpsing a partial facet)

 

[Deonment]

I will reiterate what was said in the CN thread and state a disagreement with the idea of doing this as an overall thread rather than going verse by verse for such a matter, but if we are going to go ahead with this anyways I'll just go ahead and link this for the list of characters that currently have paraconsistent physiology (or at the very least, who have the category) and quote my past self on discord about verses that don't qualify for such (made in like 2025)

sonic as a whole doesn't qualify (and got downgraded earlier anyways, just didn't get the tag removed)
lucifer doesn't qualify
dark tower maybe could, but the justifications don't work
the unwritten doesn't qualify
everything in martial peak that isn't primal chaos and yang kai don't qualify (and i doubt those two also qualify)
adventure time doesn't have nonduality for anything but the cosmic mind, and everything else just didn't get the tag removed from them after it got downgraded
pretty sure cui heng doesn't qualify with our current standards (unless we accept self/other or unity/division as valid dualities)
cradle as is doesn't qualify by our standards
if nonexistence and existence doesn't count as a duality (which i doubt, but yeah), a bunch of verses don't qualify
GoW didn't lose the nonduality tag when they got downgraded (and even if they didn't then they would get downgraded)
aleph's god doesn't seem to qualify (esp given the page has not a scan or quote on it)
the gods of heaven have 0 scans
HooH doesn't qualify
very unsure about judge holden
li qiye wasn't updated when his nonduality got removed
not sure about xu jingming
Wei Huo may not qualify
wang wei is another page that didn't get the tag removed after a crt
the void (DC) doesn't qualify
unsure about the source
the pixel gun player doesn't qualify (or if they do, not in a way that's relevant for a profile)
if self/other doesn't qualify then sassy is out
raziel doesn't qualify
mystic flower cookie doesn't qualify
the mother of existence doesn't qualify
god of highschool was the verse that started this entire thing, it doesn't qualify

As for verses that do, Wizard101 is the most explicit example ever

In the world of mundane illusion, Death is the absence of Life, Shadow is the absence of Light, and Chaos is the absence of Order. The opposite is also true: Life the absence of Death, Light the absence of Shadow, Order the absence of Chaos. Each defined by its own opposite. Is there a thing that has no opposite to define it? A thing that is its own opposite? Can there be such a thing as Nothing? To let understanding end at what cannot be understood is a great attainment. Those who cannot do this will be destroyed on the Lathe of Heaven.

With Bartleby, The Player, and The Nothing each transcending the boundaries of the Spider and Raven who are Death/Shadow/Chaos and Life/Light/Order respectively, with such things applying to the whole of the wheel/spiral, so they should keep their PP2

 

[ActuallySpaceMan42]

[Reincarnation] has nested duality within it.

[Balance] also explains that the duality it contains the duality of "is" and "is not" and even the paradox of no and yes existing at the same time.

Now, for the existing PP on the profile itself:

Since I added the verse, I'm obviously biased, but seeing as it's been cleared for Logic Manipulation for similar scans in the past, this is fine.

I will reiterate what was said in the CN thread and state a disagreement with the idea of doing this as an overall thread rather than going verse by verse for such a matter, but if we are going to go ahead with this anyways I'll just go ahead and link this for the list of characters that currently have paraconsistent physiology (or at the very least, who have the category) and quote my past self on discord about verses that don't qualify for such (made in like 2025)

This will be different from that thread, since you can choose if you want to have a verse verified here or not. If you want to do it in your own CRT, feel free, but the verses that qualify or disqualify on this CRT can be used and referenced as well.

This will just be faster for the most part.

As for verses that do, Wizard101 is the most explicit example ever

Yeah, that fits.

With Bartleby, The Player, and The Nothing each transcending the boundaries of the Spider and Raven who are Death/Shadow/Chaos and Life/Light/Order respectively, with such things applying to the whole of the wheel/spiral, so they should keep their PP2

Looked at their profiles, and that checks out as well. Are there any scans about how this affects interactions with those qualities? This doesn't affect whether a character has PP, but it will determine if it's useful in matches.

 

[Astral_Trinity439]

This is for Tensura.
I was gonna revise it anyways, but this helps me determine what needs more explanation and what is already enough and make my future thread better
.

These are the following pages:

1. Cosmology Page (Dualities)
2. Great Holy Spirit (Nonduality)

The attribute of time in cosmology page also has Nonduality.
That's all. There is another thread going on to give another thing PP1 but I'll assume that is better dealt with in its own thread.

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

This is for Tensura.
I was gonna revise it anyways, but this helps me determine what needs more explanation and what is already enough and make my future thread better
.

These are the following pages:

1. Cosmology Page (Dualities)
2. Great Holy Spirit (Nonduality)

The attribute of time in cosmology page also has Nonduality.
That's all. There is another thread going on to give another thing PP1 but I'll assume that is better dealt with in its own thread.

That reminds me, we need to add the scans ( or if it's already there, make it more obvious) that the demons were created by the world itself to counteract the creations of the angels. This adds further proof to their duality)