• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Messages
8,874
Reaction score
5,709
This fight happened in canon but I believe neither combatant was giving it his all. A lot of people like to push agendas around and like to push things to the absolute extreme like admirals being far above yonko or vice versa when this fight was clearly portrayed as a relative match, and was too short to draw any definitive conclusions. I also believe Luffy's stamina was heavily nerfed in this fight while Kizaru was insanely nerfed mentally as well.
Both combatants are in character, but serious and will do anything to win.
Battle takes place at onigashima's rooftoop.
They start 1 km apart.

Luffy: @Hasty12345 @Bananossauro @MonkeyOfLife @Arkansalter2 @KingTempest @Nierre @FluffyCreatureZ @Popbum @Mickey1940
Kizaru: @BeTheWay1rst @Gamecooob
Inconclusive:
 
Last edited:
In the OG fight, Luffy was flipflapping around & being on the defensive most of the time, a mentally nerfed Kizaru's speed. Alot of those attacks Kizaru telegraphed beforehand btw.

And even AFTER Luffy got a good hit in, dude had not a single SCRATCH or bruise iirc, just winded. (and arguably he had the time to go and feed Luffy's dumbass)

So, in a fully serious fight, Kizaru won't telegraph or be mentally nerfed.
There'll be no Uber Eats.
But what CAN'T change is Luffy's horrendous stamina.

I'm voting Kizaru.
 
Luffy fra, Luffy using adv con haki is easily taking kizaru out... Gear 5 alone was already overpowering and overwhelming him (in terms of Speed, strength, haki and basically everything...)
 
Emperor luffy. Oh boy...
By this point, Luffy is already miraculously more powerful than whatever Kizaru got going on. Gear 5 luffy can defeat Kaido in a long and hard fight and well pretty much damn near obliterate Kizaru.
Luffy, mid diff.
 
I think the most important factor that will determine the outcome of this fight is can luffy fight kizaru without using gear 5? I firmly believe that luffy with gears and ACOC can keep up with and even overpower kizaru just based on his feats against kaido. Remember that an ACOC kick from a casual base luffy forced kizaru to block and a full power ACOC attack from from gear 5 luffy KNOCKED him out. So if luffy uses ACOC in conjunction with gears, especially gear 4, then Kizaru won't be able to handle him so easily like he did with snakeman.
 
yee, snakeman's power was already overwhelming him

Adding/using adv arm haki or adv con haki would do insane amounts of damage to kizaru
Remember that an ACOC kick from a casual base luffy forced kizaru to block
It wasn't adv con haki tho, was just a normal armament haki clash, sparking only when hit
1091-017.png
Luffy-Vs-Kizaru-Haki.png

From the sound effects also, it might've even cracked his bone a little
 
Last edited:
Luffy fra, Luffy using adv con haki is easily taking kizaru out... Gear 5 alone was already overpowering and overwhelming him (in terms of Speed, strength, haki and basically everything...)
kindly, just, no? What is there to suggest that he wasn't using ACoC already, his friends were at risk of death lol, AND he was obviously looking for smoke.
And, speed, really man? The guy was flipflopping around and on the defensive most of the time, I don't think thats 'superior speed' to Kizaru.


By this point, Luffy is already miraculously more powerful than whatever Kizaru got going on
this is not what the manga says.
I firmly believe that luffy with gears and ACOC can keep up with and even overpower kizaru just based on his feats against kaido.
except... Luffy was arguably using ACoC with snakeman anyway??
This is unclear, as ACoC and ACoA have basically the same indicator, or uh, have NO indicator at all, so we don't know WTF Luffy used here for certain, its too up in the air.


Remember that an ACOC kick from a casual base luffy forced kizaru to block
did you want the guy to willingly get kicked in the gut?
and a full power ACOC attack from from gear 5 luffy KNOCKED him out.
He was winded, not knocked unconscious... This is the same version of Kizaru who was stalling on killing his best friend btw, dude is depressed here so it wouldn't be a stretch to say he willingly continued to lay down.


yee, snakeman's power was already overwhelming him
Wizaru was standing still while Luffy was sweating, then proceeded to soccerkick his ass past the barrier. Looks like overwhelming to me, too.


Adding/using adv arm haki or adv con haki would do insane amounts of damage to kizaru
The time he DID use ACoC, there wasnt even a scratch on the guy...
 
kindly, just, no? What is there to suggest that he wasn't using ACoC already
Because not one instance do we see the effects of con haki like he did on onigashima... Proven also recently with the fact that it works on immortals and luffy never used it to stop their regen
And, speed, really man? The guy was flipflopping around and on the defensive most of the time, I don't think thats 'superior speed' to Kizaru.
1108-012.png
1108-013.png

except... Luffy was arguably using ACoC with snakeman anyway??
Um what?
1092-009.png

Wizaru was standing still while Luffy was sweating, then proceeded to soccerkick his ass past the barrier. Looks like overwhelming to me, too.
Snakeman overwhelmed him first... Kizaru getting hit in the leg and saying it's very powerful without using adv haki

Also about the sweating
0680-018.png

The time he DID use ACoC, there wasnt even a scratch on the guy...
Luffy never used adv con haki
 
Last edited:
Because not one instance do we see the effects of con haki like he did on onigashima... Proven also recently with the fact that it works on immortals and luffy never used it to stop their regen
again, the effects just AINT consistent. Even in Wano, not every attack had any ACoC indicators.
Armament legit, alot of the time, DOESNT have indicators.
Snakeman overwhelmed him first... Kizaru getting hit in the leg and saying it's very powerful without using adv haki
he just said "you're a tough one."
and that "its clear you're the man who took down Kaido".

and its a barrage attack, dude, so what if he gets hit in the leg? didnt even scratch him, he's not playing dance dance revolution, he can't constantly change his position like a maniac, a simple block DID the job.


Luffy never used adv con haki
in.con.sis.tent.in.di.ca.tors.
 
again, the effects just AINT consistent. Even in Wano, not every attack had any ACoC indicators.
in.con.sis.tent.in.di.ca.tors.
you at least always see lightning coming from their limb or weapon, which never happened in egghead with luffy
1094-016.png

he just said "you're a tough one."
and that "its clear you're the man who took down Kaido".
He said very powerful... With no adv haki
Armament legit, alot of the time, DOESNT have indicators.
Kizaru is a logia so we know luffy is using it to interact with him
 
you at least always see lightning coming from their limb or weapon, which never happened in egghead with luffy
hmmm... no you dont.

brother, the simple answer is that Oda doesn't consistently draw regular Haki, let alone ACoC.

Wano had alot of the indicators cuz thats when ACoC was INTRODUCED. Perhaps the guy just doesn't wanna tire himself out with drawing black squiggles every chapter?

I digress, this point of "he didnt use it" doesnt even make sense because why tf would Luffy not take Kizaru, a guy whos trying to kill his friend, and the guy who whooped his ass 2 years prior, serious?
 
First one isn't adv con haki, kaido just says if he has con haki also in general

2nd one you can literally see lightning coming from luffys hand
Hk.png


3rd one I guess he just didn't use con haki

4th one we see lightning coming from his hand beforehand
One-Piece-c1042-v103-p129-VIZ-Digital-CC-PZG.jpg


5th one... Go sleep
brother, the simple answer is that Oda doesn't consistently draw regular Haki, let alone ACoC.
He does always with armament hardening and adv con haki because they are different usages of their base haki
Wano had alot of the indicators cuz thats when ACoC was INTRODUCED. Perhaps the guy just doesn't wanna tire himself out with drawing black squiggles every chapter?
no lol, even if that's true... It would been added and completed in the volume release
I digress, this point of "he didnt use it" doesnt even make sense because why tf would Luffy not take Kizaru, a guy whos trying to kill his friend, and the guy who whooped his ass 2 years prior, serious?
This is why, just trying to distract him so the others can escape
1094-010.png


Here's more proof of everything
 
Last edited:
First one isn't adv con haki, kaido just says if he has con haki also in general
ah, yes, Ashura zoro, infamous for not using ACoC, even though he cut a guy who was a tier above him physically... Zoro is just that guy, hm?


3rd one I guess he just didn't use con haki
copium
4th one we see lightning coming from his hand beforehand
but not when he punches... thats when, y'know, the black lightning should be flying everywhere logically.
no lol, even if that's true... It would been added and completed in the volume release
but it aint.
This is why, just trying to distract him so the others can escape
Luffy's mission was to stall Kizaru for his life to prevent his friends DYING. "just distracting" is NOT the proper description to stall an admiral. Luffy himself said that he "sensed someone strong" and sweated bullets, WHY would he only use basic CoA for an enemy that is "very strong"? If you truly believe Luffy was "overwhelming" Kizaru with Snakeman, and was outskilling him with base gear 5...

You're reducing a wholeass admiral to Robert Gucci, which is nonsensical.
Oda doesn't need to yell in your face anymore that "oh, look, this guy is using ACoC", since we're way out of Wano now and we can just assume Luffy ATLEAST uses advanced armament in his attacks now.
 
Snakeman is 100% inferior to Kizaru, without a doubt, advanced Haki or not. A fully battle-ready kizaru with intent to kill is outspeeding and out-hitting Snakeman, which will force Luffy into Gear 5.


And the thing is- Kizaru doesn't even NEED to 24/7 engage Gear 5th to win this fight-- he can stall, which is a FULLY VALID strategy to win here. He pretty quickly deduced that Luffy was reaching his limit with that form, so why WOULDN'T he just stall until Luffy turns old again?

He obv won't let the boy put his heartbeat into order again, as its quite easy to distrupt a heartbeat. He can accelerate to where he blitzes Luffy again, and again, and again, use his light sword and accelerate with THAT to just give Luffy a gnarly cut, use clones repeatedly and smartly to overwhelm him, simply just dodge out of the way when he sees Luffy preparing to do his spinny-punch bullshit.

It doesn't take alot of time for G5 to gas out, and Kizaru is resilient in his own right, and FAR more experienced with his powers than Luffy.
 
yee, snakeman's power was already overwhelming him

Adding/using adv arm haki or adv con haki would do insane amounts of damage to kizaru

It wasn't adv con haki tho, was just a normal armament haki clash, sparking only when hit
1091-017.png
Luffy-Vs-Kizaru-Haki.png

From the sound effects also, it might've even cracked his bone a little
Nah you're heavily exaggerating. Snakeman was not overpowering kizaru at all, they were exchanging blows with kizaru having the edge.
And luffy did not crack kizaru's bones at all. That is the farthest reach I've seen all week.
As for ACOC, that hit definitely looks like conquerors. If it were armament haki, the sparks would be flying all over and would not originate from luffy's attack only. Here, the lighting is trailing from luffy's leg only, and it looks identical to this kick which is demonstrably conquerors. This is all characteristic of conquerors haki.


except... Luffy was arguably using ACoC with snakeman anyway??
The whole argument here is that luffy was probably using conquerors haki against kizaru the whole time so kizaru's level is way up there, but I beg to differ completely.
All the way from the introduction of ACOC in chapter 1010 up to the most recent chapter with roger and garps clash, ACOC has been portrayed nearly consistently. Conquerors coated attacks always have lightning trails from the point of contact and a black lightning explosion happens when the attack hits. Sometimes the attack doesn't make direct contact if the user has ACOA. There are so many instances of this that it would be redundant to list them all. But, here is a direct comparison of luffy's snakeman against kaido vs against kizaru.
Against kaido, all of snakeman's punches are emitting conquerors sparks, and when they hit, black lightning sparks out while also not making contact. Against kizaru, none of this happens, there's not even the sound effects of thunder crackling.
And it's not even an issue of Luffy being serious or not anymore, there is evidence that luffy wasn't going all out in the first place. When luffy grabbed kizaru the first time, he didn't hurt kizaru. But when luffy was angry and serious, he CRUSHED kizaru in his hand. I don't know why Luffy found it okay to play around against kizaru at first, but him not using conquerors is just the facts. The indicators for ACOC being used or not are consistent before and after egghead. For example here is g5 luffy NOT using ACOC against kaido and still harming him, it looks identical to the kizaru fight.
And it isn't even like it was inconsistent for this fight specifically, the only time we see clear signs of ACOC use is also the first time luffy lands a proper attack and it's the same attack that ENDS the fight.

Now I definitely believe the fight is close because despite luffy being physically on par or stronger than kizaru when using ACOC + G2+G3 or snakeman or boundman, kizaru is still faster than him. However if luffy goes all out in g5, he'll definitely pummel kizaru. Remember kizaru folded to one attack from g5 arguably without ACOA, but luffy fought evenly and beat kaido who could take hundreds of those attacks consistently. Stamina isn't a big a factor as you think, only if luffy fights like he did on the rooftop.
 
But when luffy was angry and serious, he CRUSHED kizaru in his hand. I don't know why Luffy found it okay to play around against kizaru at first
Not interested in this match, but he was not playing with Kizaru at any point. Kizaru's spirit was stated to have broken by that point. Meaning he was not using Haki to defend or wasn't even trying to protect himself in any way. He just sat there.
 
Nah you're heavily exaggerating. Snakeman was not overpowering kizaru at all, they were exchanging blows with kizaru having the edge.
How was kizaru having the edge if Luffy literally overpowered his laser spam and never got hit while kizaru did...? Calling it very powerful also?
And luffy did not crack kizaru's bones at all. That is the farthest reach I've seen all week.
Furtherest reach while the sound effect legit sounds like bone cracking, if it's not bone cracking then what else is it...

Ohh just saw that it's literally confirmed, I was right, His arm bone was breaking... From base luffy, it's actually ggs
0681-017.png

chimpanzee-chimp.gif

Always right 🙈🚬
As for ACOC, that hit definitely looks like conquerors. If it were armament haki, the sparks would be flying all over and would not originate from luffy's attack only. Here, the lighting is trailing from luffy's leg only, and it looks identical to this kick which is demonstrably conquerors. This is all characteristic of conquerors haki.
It isn't trailing from luffys leg, the lighting is coming from the hit, the clash... If it was adv con haki, there would be lightning flowing from luffy's leg alone


That was just armament haki vs armament haki clash
latest
0884-002.png
0884-009.png
0884-010.png
0895-003.png
0895-012.png
latest

Lightning only coming from the hit, that's even showcased in the anime
 
Last edited:
How was kizaru having the edge if Luffy literally overpowered his laser spam and never got hit while kizaru did...? Calling it very powerful also?
Luffy was sweating while kizaru was casual. There was no overpowering, they were exchanging blows evenly. Calling luffy powerful does not mean more powerful than him at that moment.
Furtherest reach while the sound effect legit sounds like bone cracking, if it's not bone cracking then what else is it...

Ohh just saw that it's literally confirmed, I was right, His arm bone was breaking... From base luffy, it's actually ggs
Kizaru was demonstrably not hurt by that attack. It's absolutely insane to even suggest that he broke his arm. I even watched the anime version and it's exactly like the manga, kizaru was forced to block a powerful attack, and that's it, blocked. The crik sound effects just mean they are struggling in a clash, it does not have to be bones breaking.
That was just armament haki vs armament haki clash
Honestly you have a point. That scan with katakuri blocking snakeman's attack looks identical to kizaru blocking luffy's kick. This might just be armament.
 
The crik sound effects just mean they are struggling in a clash
that's never been a thing... The clash happens and then the sound affects happend only once within that clash, the panel of Sanji confirms that those are bones cracking type sound effects... You can't just say no and say it's something else without proof that it is, crak, crik, cruk and things similar are always about something breaking or cracking...
Luffy was sweating while kizaru was casual. There was no overpowering, they were exchanging blows evenly. Calling luffy powerful does not mean more powerful than him at that moment.
Luffy was sweating because physically moving requires stamina, instantly spawning lasers doesn't at all
0680-018.png

With the lasers, luffy destroyed and overpowered them and went through them to hit kizaru's leg, that's a literally fact... Kizaru couldn't hit anything at all even with having a natural advantage in devil fruit powers and was on the back foot in that exchange... The showing and the statement of kizaru calling his attack very powerful all showcases luffy overpowering in that moment
Honestly you have a point. That scan with katakuri blocking snakeman's attack looks identical to kizaru blocking luffy's kick. This might just be armament.
Yee true, it looked very identical to one another
 
that's never been a thing... The clash happens and then the sound affects happend only once within that clash, the panel of Sanji confirms that those are bones cracking type sound effects... You can't just say no and say it's something else without proof that it is, crak, crik, cruk and things similar are always about something breaking or cracking...
Monkey, go to sleep, please. Ah, yes, Kizaru TOTALLY cracked a bone and just didn't say anything about it, made no showing about it, made NO indication about it himself, but ohhh, theres that "crik" sound, mhm. It's as if JOINTS POPPING, two heavy things hitting eachother, or just hitting something dense & moist also make those same sounds, Monkey. Why are you wasting your time searching for these goofyass sound effects is baffling me rn.


Luffy was sweating because physically moving requires stamina, instantly spawning lasers doesn't at all
this doesnt help your case as bro sweated kinda early, dontcha think?


With the lasers, luffy destroyed and overpowered them and went through them to hit kizaru's leg, that's a literally fact... Kizaru couldn't hit anything at all even with having a natural advantage in devil fruit powers and was on the back foot in that exchange... The showing and the statement of kizaru calling his attack very powerful all showcases luffy overpowering in that moment
do you know how much of a lazy, high jackass Kizaru is? "back foot in that exchange" more like just cement-walling Snakeman. Why are you focusing so much on this leg hit which didnt even have consequences or any notability whatsoever...
And Kizaru isnt even wrong with his statement? Luffy's attacks CAN be "very powerful" in the general strength for the one piece planet, can also be very powerful compared to the Luffy Kizaru met 2 years ago, but yet, those attacks AT THE SAME TIME don't have to really hurt Kizaru, y'know that right?
 
Monkey, go to sleep, please. Ah, yes, Kizaru TOTALLY cracked a bone and just didn't say anything about it, made no showing about it, made NO indication about it himself, but ohhh, theres that "crik" sound, mhm. It's as if JOINTS POPPING, two heavy things hitting eachother, or just hitting something dense & moist also make those same sounds, Monkey. Why are you wasting your time searching for these goofyass sound effects is baffling me rn.
His eyes looking like its damaging him and him pauseing mid sentence are the showings of it...

joints popping is still luffy overpowering his durability in base, the sfx debunks the assumption that kizaru was completely fine from the hit.
this doesnt help your case as bro sweated kinda early, dontcha think?
No, how does that mean anything? Just means that luffy is actively trying to destroy all the lasers, plus heat add on top would make you sweat... There was like 2 small sweat drops on his face even, doesn't mean much overall... One can sweat and still keep going for many hours
do you know how much of a lazy, high jackass Kizaru is? "back foot in that exchange" more like just cement-walling Snakeman. Why are you focusing so much on this leg hit which didnt even have consequences or any notability whatsoever...
It made all of kizaru start shaking from a hit to the leg, that's overpowering his defense while luffy is also having to overpower his lasers to hit him already... If you understand about fighting you would know shaking all over from a hit means critical/effective damage was done to you
And Kizaru isnt even wrong with his statement? Luffy's attacks CAN be "very powerful" in the general strength for the one piece planet, can also be very powerful compared to the Luffy Kizaru met 2 years ago, but yet, those attacks AT THE SAME TIME don't have to really hurt Kizaru, y'know that right?
They did tho... Hence he said it after he himself got hit from luffy in snakeman, as far as thinking that is how he defeated kaido
 
I've flip flopped on where I have kizaru on the totem pole but rn imma vote for Luffy, I think hes got it here
 
Monkey, I'm quite honestly at a loss. You have no capacity to look at things objectively when your bias is in the way. How could you possibly think that luffy broke kizaru's arm lmao?

Anyway, I don't remember the rules but I think I can vote on my own thread. I'll put my vote for luffy.
 
Monkey, I'm quite honestly at a loss. You have no capacity to look at things objectively when your bias is in the way. How could you possibly think that luffy broke kizaru's arm lmao?
You guys can keep saying I'm being somehow biased EVEN when later on in the future it reveals what I'm saying to be true... The only thing I'm biased on is the truth

This statement refers to pre gear 5
Before 00: Participates in the raid on Onigashima and fights Kaido one-on-one.
Before 00: Activates "Gear 5" and defeats Kaido.
Before 00: Bounty rises to 3 billion Berries, making him one of the Four Emperors.
Before 00: Shares his "Dream's End" with his comrades.
Before 00: Encounters Bonney and lands on Egghead.
Before 00: Re-matches CP0's Rob Lucci and overwhelms him with "Gear 5."
Before 00: Barricades himself in Egghead, using "Greed" as a shield.
Before 00: Re-matches Kizaru and is more than evenly matched. (Vivre Card)

Like legit your only argument to what I'm saying is just no even tho every evidence leads to that being the case... Kizaru is hurt from the kick, he gets pushed back, his eyes are very serious and frustrated, his arm made a cracking sound. Saying no doesn't go against all that. Luffy saying he's 100 times stronger than before while in base, the same way old Rayleigh was and Old Rayleigh was also being more than even against kizaru, supporting it further for pre gear 5 luffy to be: Kizaru ~< Luffy
 
Last edited:
Back
Top