- 14,892
- 20,931
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 13,902
- 5,395
I was being hyperbolic but I didn't know there were so few
Anyways what's the process of creating a team profile?
Recon1511
He/Him- 6,793
- 5,430
- 274
- 190
I always thought a team profile for Bang & Bomb would be nice, but I wasn't sure if two people would be enough, actually looking at the category now though I see there are a couple 2-person teams, so maybe that could be done?
A couple others that come to mind are Atomic Samurai's disciples, as well as Maiko Plasma and Electric Catfish Man. And obviously the Monster Association Cadres too.
- 4,145
- 3,941
I think the only real requirement for Team Profiles is an actual name to put them under, hence why we can't have a Team Profile like Kenpachi and Byakyuya but we could have a Gotei 13 one, or Visored.
- 15,285
- 15,462
Well, there’s probably some exceptions to that, like Batman and Robin.
- 4,145
- 3,941
Dynamic Duo
- 15,285
- 15,462
Fair point.
- 190
- 108
to be honest it's only for saitama, garou doesn't scale from saitama at the time of the fight in io
- 7,897
- 3,856
Garou scales. He reacted to Saitama's Io table flip ping pong and in the next chapter was shown roughly comparable to Saitama on the graphs before Saitama started to really grow in power.
- 190
- 108
not for travel speed
- 190
- 108
Speed Saitama in Satelit Io
vsbattles.fandom.com
Saitama and garou move fast in satelit io
vsbattles.fandom.com
these two calculations should look fine, and acceptable, but only for saitama's traveling speed maybe also with attack speed
- 18,395
- 15,982
- 7,897
- 3,856
Garou would scale in travel speed by copying Saitama's stats. Also, Garou was never worried about Saitama's speed, just the ridiculous move he did (the table flip) which bewildered him and made him lose his sense of direction. And in the newest chapter, you see them fighting each other within the rock and debris.
Last edited:
- 7,160
- 3,663
Definitely a must
- 18,395
- 15,982
Not confirmed. The only thing that still makes me believe that it will be a redraw is my copium.
- 7,897
- 3,856
.......
- 15,285
- 15,462
Who in the year of 2022 says that OPM is a gag manga
.......
- 7,897
- 3,856
I see at least one post on Reddit claiming that it's a gag manga and I only visit Reddit every couple of days.
- 15,285
- 15,462
Well, there’s your problem.
- 7,897
- 3,856
It's the main hub for OPM manga fans but I guess youtube is another place where you see that being preached as well. And Twitter and tic tac.
- 4,940
- 1,841
Why doesn’t golden ball and spring mustachio both scale to small city level?
- 15,285
- 15,462
If you’re gonna ask questions like this, can you at least give reasons to why they should scale?
- 4,940
- 1,841
They both could pierce/damage Garou who is listed as small city level. Spring mustachio could fight alongside Iaian and block attacks from homeless, who Iaian was having a tough time doing. The attacks from HE also harmed both of the fighters with Iaian being listed at city level for his durability.
- 7,413
- 8,213
Thinking about Saitama in the manga vs the webcomic.
Saitama has character flaws, he's aloof, does not take things seriously enough, is not really good at dealing with people, and, while he struggles with things like poverty,lack of power,fame recognition and boredom he has consistently shown he is very hard to corrupt (does not abuse his power or go too far in any situation, even when nobody could stop him.) and has an outsatnding sense of morality. (specially in the side chapters, like the one with the cops and the one where he returns a kid's wallet after the kid tried giving it to him.)
In the webcomic it goes even further, as Saitama is pretty much the absolute hero effectively. He has never struggled with any threat that's not harmless and on top of that is a perfect judge of character, being able to see the well hidden good in Garou when nobody else in his universe could. While he's present you're 100% sure nothing can go irreparably wrong and all good and evil done by those he judges will be repaid correctly. Like Garou correctly said, it's like he's the embodiment of Justice.
In the manga he's pretty much the same, until the Garou arc, where he sees the obvious good within Garou every other hero saw, but also fails to properly correct him, trying to gaslight him into being a hero, ignoring all the obvious issues with treating him like a child without addressing his misdeeds in a way that leads him to notice the flaws in his ideology and the lies he told himself. (Granted, the result would probably be the same even if he did, considering GOD basically cheated his way into messing with Garou.)
After that we learn that Saitama is not invincible physically or mentally, might lose control of his temper and nearly lose his humanity, becoming the very thing he swore to protect humanity against, and that even in a situation where real danger is present there's a chance he might still not take it seriously and fail horribly at being a Saviour. Not only that, but we learn that there's actually a threat out there that's incomparably stronger than the one who actually forced him to try and gave him actual loses (at least before going Time Travel and retconing the entire thing out.)
Realistically, OPM without Saitama would be a survival horror series where humanity is faced with endless crises, natural disasters and unpredictable threats with 0 known solutions that keeps on growing stronger and more violent, until their society turns into ruins and even the mightiest heroes humanity looks up to perish before an even stronger monster than the one of yesterday, wich leads humanity into it's demise and possibly a fate even worse than extinction. In the Manga, Saitama's physical and moral omnipotence are both proven false and a crack has appeared in what was once the indestructible pillar of justice that supported mankind.
Saitama has character flaws, he's aloof, does not take things seriously enough, is not really good at dealing with people, and, while he struggles with things like poverty,lack of power,fame recognition and boredom he has consistently shown he is very hard to corrupt (does not abuse his power or go too far in any situation, even when nobody could stop him.) and has an outsatnding sense of morality. (specially in the side chapters, like the one with the cops and the one where he returns a kid's wallet after the kid tried giving it to him.)
In the webcomic it goes even further, as Saitama is pretty much the absolute hero effectively. He has never struggled with any threat that's not harmless and on top of that is a perfect judge of character, being able to see the well hidden good in Garou when nobody else in his universe could. While he's present you're 100% sure nothing can go irreparably wrong and all good and evil done by those he judges will be repaid correctly. Like Garou correctly said, it's like he's the embodiment of Justice.
In the manga he's pretty much the same, until the Garou arc, where he sees the obvious good within Garou every other hero saw, but also fails to properly correct him, trying to gaslight him into being a hero, ignoring all the obvious issues with treating him like a child without addressing his misdeeds in a way that leads him to notice the flaws in his ideology and the lies he told himself. (Granted, the result would probably be the same even if he did, considering GOD basically cheated his way into messing with Garou.)
After that we learn that Saitama is not invincible physically or mentally, might lose control of his temper and nearly lose his humanity, becoming the very thing he swore to protect humanity against, and that even in a situation where real danger is present there's a chance he might still not take it seriously and fail horribly at being a Saviour. Not only that, but we learn that there's actually a threat out there that's incomparably stronger than the one who actually forced him to try and gave him actual loses (at least before going Time Travel and retconing the entire thing out.)
Realistically, OPM without Saitama would be a survival horror series where humanity is faced with endless crises, natural disasters and unpredictable threats with 0 known solutions that keeps on growing stronger and more violent, until their society turns into ruins and even the mightiest heroes humanity looks up to perish before an even stronger monster than the one of yesterday, wich leads humanity into it's demise and possibly a fate even worse than extinction. In the Manga, Saitama's physical and moral omnipotence are both proven false and a crack has appeared in what was once the indestructible pillar of justice that supported mankind.
- 13,902
- 5,395
haven't seen the webcomic but manga saitama can do a serious fart, seems hard to compete with
- 4,145
- 3,941
He woke up
- 18,395
- 15,982
He went from sleeping to being awake. When something similar happened against Darkshine, he noted that Garou's muscle coordination got much better.
Also, narrative implication. Though not very impressive when calced, Murata went out of his way to try to showcase Garou's speed by adding a timer and blitzing multiple people who scale relative to Bang's speed value
- 487
- 476
Alexander the philosopher.
Sigilavox
He/Him- 402
- 210
Honestly, yeah I see it. Both heroes were clearly injuring Garou in the panels, and Garou's way of getting around them was primarily dodging or redirecting their attacks to make sure they missed something important.
- 487
- 476
Alexander, since Saitama is a large dimensional being, can he defeat Godhead Darkseid?
- 4,940
- 1,841
Bingo.
- 18,395
- 15,982
Garou has an accepted weakness to sharp objects in that key.
Recon1511
He/Him- 6,793
- 5,430
I see, but someone mentioned to me that Sleeping Garou was using Awakening Breath which brings the body to it's limits (which implies Garou was using his full body capabilities) and on top of that functions as an stat amp.
But yeah, I think the narrative implications are enough of a justification.
Sigilavox
He/Him- 402
- 210
Is this in an updated sandbox key or something? It's not in the weaknesses section of Garou's current profile, nor in the "Hero Hunter" key. Either way, what's the reasoning for that being a weakness to sharp objects specifically? It's not like he himself comments on his vulnerability to sharp objects more than any other attack, it's just kind of a standard attack.
- 4,940
- 1,841
What’s the logic behind this? It’s clear cut. They could overcome his durability, ability to take force. If anything they would downscale his durability. Piercing or not, you’re not damaging someone 92073951.79x more durable than your attack potency.
- 4,940
- 1,841
I would be different if their attacks slightly cut him or something, but they straight up traverse through his muscles and exist through the other side.
