The Eminence in the Shadows Discussion Thread

[Celestial_Pegasus]

I mean does the anime really change the overall narrative though? LN Cid fights Beatrix and Iris inside the stadium, anime they go all over the city, ok we can't use those speed feats which cover the city since it wasn't in the LN, end result is the same Cid low diffs both characters. Lets say another feat happens like the LN, idk Cid vs Vampire Queen, we can actually see the characters move unlike the LN, in that case their speed wouldn't contradict anything, seems it could be case by case, not one big stroke of no way anything could ever be accepted.

But anyway i am not really gonna argue it, have much more important things to do.So i won't oppose this, more calcs are always welcome.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

I mean does the anime really change the overall narrative though? LN Cid fights Beatrix and Iris inside the stadium, anime they go all over the city, ok we can't use those speed feats which cover the city since it wasn't in the LN, end result is the same Cid low diffs both characters. Lets say another feat happens like the LN, idk Cid vs Vampire Queen, we can actually see the characters move unlike the LN, in that case their speed wouldn't contradict anything, seems it could be case by case, not one big stroke of no way anything could ever be accepted.

But anyway i am not really gonna argue it, have much more important things to do.So i won't oppose this, more calcs are always welcome.

Actually I'm not disregarding overall anime feats. Sorry I should have explained better. Yeah it's case by case if feats are mentioned in the LN and Manga we can use anime counterparts for Calculations.
But current speed scaling should be reworked. I got MHS+ Calculation for Cid but it needs to be accepted first.

 

[Second22]

Christmas Gift

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

Wtf, am I forgetting something or was that not in the LN?

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Wtf, am I forgetting something or was that not in the LN?

Anime done extra scenes.

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

I mean monologuing about lightning and then lighting up the solar system is a very cool scene.

Probably not usable here though, side note I noticed the anime also makes references here and there to the WN.

 

[Second22]

High 6-A is accepted.

I mean monologuing about lightning and then lighting up the solar system is a very cool scene.

Probably not usable here though, side note I noticed the anime also makes references here and there to the WN.

I wonder if we should separate key Anime and LN?

 

[Celestial_Pegasus]

I don't follow our Canon rules, so idk, but if Toei Goku has a profile, maybe anime Cid can as well? Can't remember any other profile where the anime version of the character is listed as a key.

But yea the eminence anime has a drastic difference in terms of feats, probably requires a whole discussion thread to decide what to do.

 

[Vzearr]

https://vsbattles.com/threads/the-eminence-in-shadow-upgrade.162910/

 

[ZawierJ]

Is this calculation accepted.

 

[Second22]

Is this calculation accepted.

Calculations have been accepted, but since it's not in the WN, I'm not sure if it can be used.

 

[ZawierJ]

Calculations have been accepted, but since it's not in the WN, I'm not sure if it can be used.

What is WN?

 

[AdamVhenJP]

What is WN?

Web novel

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Calculations have been accepted, but since it's not in the WN, I'm not sure if it can be used.

@PhantomØ4 has some information for that feat being canon. Because of author specific involvement.

 

[Second22]

What is WN?

Web novel

 

[Second22]

@PhantomØ4 has some information for that feat being canon. Because of author specific involvement.

Okay, that’s cool

 

[ZawierJ]

Web novel

Anime is Canon too so we can use it i think.

 

[ZawierJ]

Why this "I Am Atomic" calculation has been rejected? Does anyone knows?

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Why this "I Am Atomic" calculation has been rejected? Does anyone knows?

It's not rejected. No one evaluated it that's all

 

[ZawierJ]

It's not rejected. No one evaluated it that's all

Oh, i get it.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Me & @Godsatoshi23 created this new profile

Elisabeth

Elisabeth (エリザベート, Erizabēto?), known as the Blood Queen (血ちの女王じょおう, Chi no Joō?), is a Vampire Progenitor and a former leader of the Crimson Tower, one of the Three Monarchs of the Lawless City. Initially perceived as the ruler, she was, in fact, a figurehead manipulated by her subordinate...

vsbattles.fandom.com

 

[Godsatoshi23]

First Eminence in Shadow movie PV!

 

[TWILIGHT-OP]

First Eminence in Shadow movie PV!

Release date?

 

[Godsatoshi23]

Release date?

It still haven't told

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Release date?

Stalker-chan stop stalking otherwise I'll downgrade Wang to Wall level so that Alexia can beat his ass

 

[TWILIGHT-OP]

Stalker-chan stop stalking otherwise I'll downgrade Wang to Wall level so that Alexia can beat his ass

Stalking a stalker now?

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Stalking a stalker now?

Calling professional Stalker @Reiner04 out. Deal with Twilight

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Guys needs input on this scaling chain. Any chances needs to be done comment in there.

Eminence in Shadow Revisions - Part 1

I have two things to address this Common Abilities for Shadow Garden Members Here is the Sandbox for Shadow Garden members common abilities. New scaling chain and Updating the current AP & Durability. I'm going with Freiren Characters approach where Physical sts is Seperated with magic...

vsbattles.com

 

[Andresx27]

Me & @Godsatoshi23 created this new profile

Elisabeth

Elisabeth (エリザベート, Erizabēto?), known as the Blood Queen (血ちの女王じょおう, Chi no Joō?), is a Vampire Progenitor and a former leader of the Crimson Tower, one of the Three Monarchs of the Lawless City. Initially perceived as the ruler, she was, in fact, a figurehead manipulated by her subordinate...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Hey, you, and the good other bro, were the ones who created Elisabeth's page? Well, I've been wanting to share this for a while now, could I ask you a favor for later, if possible?

NT: They changed the name of the page a little, to avoid confessions, on the part of the Moderators and others, hehe.

 

[Digital_Franz]

Hi. I hope you are well.

I don't want to bother you but I have some problems with Shadow's profile.

First of all, his Durability. I don't think I AM ATOMIC is qualified to be used as an argument for durability. I AM ATOMIC doesn't have any reinforcing feats for Shadow so I think it should be removed.

Also I have a problem with the Regenaration negation. It's rated High-Mid just because Alpha negated a monster that could regenerate after being bisected.

The regeneration of the monster in question Highball is Low-Mid. Here's what it says on the regeneration page:

If a character can regenerate from having their head destroyed but not from having their heart destroyed, they would be listed as having Low-Mid regeneration

High-Mid: The ability to regenerate from being blown/cut to pieces, brain included, or from a small piece of the user's body, such as a finger, or the heart

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Hi. I hope you are well.

I don't want to bother you but I have some problems with Shadow's profile.

First of all, his Durability. I don't think I AM ATOMIC is qualified to be used as an argument for durability. I AM ATOMIC doesn't have any reinforcing feats for Shadow so I think it should be removed.

He literally stands the middle of that nuke I don't see why he doesn't qualifies for that.

Also I have a problem with the Regenaration negation. It's rated High-Mid just because Alpha negated a monster that could regenerate after being bisected.

The regeneration of the monster in question Highball is Low-Mid. Here's what it says on the regeneration page:

I'm re reading the series so I'll look into it. I already had plans for revising everyone

 

[Digital_Franz]

He literally stands the middle of that nuke I don't see why he doesn't qualifies for that.

I AM ATOMIC disperses the energy from the center(him) so it doesn't affect him or at least nothing says it affects him.

I'm re reading the series so I'll look into it. I already had plans for revising everyone

OK.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

I AM ATOMIC disperses the energy from the center(him) so it doesn't affect him or at least nothing says it affects him.

Share the scans where it doesn't affect him.

 

[Digital_Franz]

Share the scans where it doesn't affect him.

I don't have any as there is no scan where it affects him.
The fact is that when he was facing the clones of Olivier, when he decided to destroy the sanctuary with I AM THE ALL RANGE ATOMIC, he was injured by a clone of Olivier. So honestly if it affected him he would be dead by then.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

I don't have any as there is no scan where it affects him.

Then there is nothing to discuss. Bring the scan and we can discuss that. Also it's your burden to prove During I'm Atomic he isn't amping his durability with magic. It's your burden.

The fact is that when he was facing the clones of Olivier, when he decided to destroy the sanctuary with I AM THE ALL RANGE ATOMIC, he was injured by a clone of Olivier. So honestly if it affected him he would be dead by then.

I suggest you go back and read the chapter with patience.
Cid never had any magic amps while he got injured.

 

[Digital_Franz]

I suggest you go back and read the chapter with patience.
Cid never had any magic amps while he got injured.

Which shows that I AM ATOMIC is not a magic amp.

 

[Digital_Franz]

Then there is nothing to discuss. Bring the scan and we can discuss that. Also it's your burden to prove During I'm Atomic he isn't amping his durability with magic. It's your burden.

Also give me a scan where he is affected. This is just an assumption on your part and on the wiki we work with feats.

 

[Godsatoshi23]

Hi. I hope you are well.

I don't want to bother you but I have some problems with Shadow's profile.

First of all, his Durability. I don't think I AM ATOMIC is qualified to be used as an argument for durability. I AM ATOMIC doesn't have any reinforcing feats for Shadow so I think it should be removed.

It is already stated in volume 1 that one's magic capacity is equal to their total defenses. Since Shadow uses his magic capacity to perform 'I Am Atomic,' which causes the attack, it is safe to say that he has that level of durability as well.

That said, I’m no match for nukes. Well, I know my defenses will increase with my magical capacity, but have you seen the firepower of those weapons on Earth?

And I am Atomic is made to withstand nuclear based Weapons.

 

[EldemadeDityjon]

Which shows that I AM ATOMIC is not a magic amp.

No it shows you don't have good reading comprehension that's all. (With all due respect)
He didn't had magic when he fought Oliver if he had magic he wouldn't even need I'm Atomic to beat that clone. He wanted to destroy whole thing because it was draining his magic. Stop making headcanons.

Also give me a scan where he is affected.

Not my burden you are making the claim so you should prove that

This is just an assumption on your part and on the wiki we work with feats.

No you are the who assuming things without reading the series. Bring the scans or just stop making headcanons.

 

[Digital_Franz]

It is already stated in volume 1 that one's magic capacity is equal to their total defenses. Since Shadow uses his magic capacity to perform 'I Am Atomic,' which causes the attack, it is safe to say that he has that level of durability as well.

And I am Atomic is made to withstand nuclear based Weapons.

This is much clearer and more obvious. The explanation on the profile is vague and when I came here no good argument was provided. Thanks for explaining to me.